The Eerie Case Of The Watcher

Make sure to leave your questions for our Post Mortem episode down below!

Where does the joke about Ryan's dad cutting off someone's head come from?

Just gone looking for the house on google maps and see its blurred out, maybe for good reason.

Did no one think to talk to the mail carrier? Like not one person has that idea? Or a city worker? Both would have access to the address and no one would think twice if either would show up

The more and more this story goes on, the more this Watcher guy sounds like a script. Someone in that neighborhood was just being edgy

I feel like Ryan and Shane are the watcher lol, I mean their handle is "We are the Watcher" :P

This channel would be so much better without the unfunny commentary

I’m from this area of NJ and know people from this town. The talk of the town is that the family is just making it up for clout lol

yeah the watcher has definitely watched this video lol

We need to know who wrote these letters

I think I honestly would write a letter back and taped it in front of my mailbox for the watcher to get 😂

I love that there clothes are nearly matching

same thing is happening to me through cyber bullying..

i honestly think that the watcher was just a mentally disturbed individual who had some sort of deep connection to that house

I believe the Watcher was determined to have been a woman, not a man, based on DNA.

We live in a time of high quality hidden cameras, ring, motion sensors, etc there’s really no reason to why this dude hasn’t been seen or found. They could have hired a private investigator as well.

The letter made me think of SCP-1269.

For those interested, my family has lived is Westfield for years. It’s a very safe and wealthy suburban town, but there are alot of old-Victorian style homes that have been occupied for years some of which were passed down and are now home to elder recluses who dislike the “yuppy” types moving into town. Developers try and purchase this Victorian era homes to build more modern houses but these lifers refuse to sell. We are friends with many in the town government and the police chief has said they believe it was one of these old reclusive residents, probably living in a family home, who decided to mess with the new home owners.

The Game Character or the Judge has my eyes on them cuz both are linked.

IS THIS WHY THEIR NEW CHANNEL IS CALLED WATCHER?? ahhh! I’m 33 and I care about this.

The Circleville writer makes a comeback!

No because I watched the show and the way I was literally trying to figure it out only to find out that it was UNSOLVED

I went to go see the house after watching the show cause it was so close by and wow!! Beautiful home but me and a friend went at like 9-10pm and watched this.. super creepy

Starting to think that the watcher is the mailbox

Waqqaqz as s

this one always bothered me i could never finish it, especially when the dude said he’ll talk to the kids. but as i go to sleep rn i feel like i need to finish this video

mfs is standing at my window peeking in, and i shoot him, am i wrong?

if they can afford a million dollar house they can afford to find another house that isnt watched, and just let this one sit there empty. or they can set it on fire and claim the insurance.

The series on Netflix literally called the watcher is so good

It could be someone who knows the Broaddus family, or someone they owed money to, as they were able to upgrade to more expensive homes in a relatively short time. it was never mentioned if police questioned them and if they had any potential enemies. The house has since been sold in 2022 to another family who has not gotten a single letter.

It seems a lot of serial killers and terrorists use the mail service. Why do we not know who sent packages? Why dont we get the info of the sender? So many killers would be caught. 😂

Man I would be sitting on the roof with a sniper

I love the fact that they named their new channel after this (most likely anyway) due to how ridiculous the guy is.

i like how the family randomly received a letter in the mailbox about a guy who's supposedly been stalking the address for generations and they were just like, "yeah, okay lol"

It seems to me that could be a mailperson.

And then several years later, these two became 'The Watcher', iykyk. I love you ryan and shane💗

i live about 20 minutes from this house. one night, i stopped by and parked right in front, wondering if i might see someone drop off a note. no such luck. 😅

Ur really anoying

Typed letter? Unless the watcher used a typewriter they had to print the letters, and those are traceable back to the individual printer used.

is this were they got their new company name

Maybe the Watcher was the friends we made along the way

Watcher reminds me of an edgy teenage cringe lord

I remember watching the Netflix series about this. It was really good. Highly recommend watching but after watching it it makes me wonder if all the neighbors took part in being "the watcher" maybe it was also the realtor.

The bite lip 😂

This 12 am viewing about to be devious

Sounds like a Stephen King novel

Not too crazy lol, could be a angry Karen neighbor being a B.. or an underground HOA

Imagine the Watcher… during the pandemic. 🤔🤔🤔

Is this episode where they got the name for their new channel lol

On a serious note i think tbe watcher had hidden some cameras somewhere of not he eould have had to have been in the house at some point to hear tbe pet names and know she was a painter