Комментарии:
Great video, but the Lynch voice impression is very bad and incredibly grating.
ОтветитьWow. I am inflating my numbers if I say that I had caught 5% of all this, even as a Twin Peaks aficionado. Same for Mulholland Drive. However, I deeply enjoyed both shows (yes, I enjoyed Fire Walk With Me as well). I had my own, probably incorrect, theories on what things meant, sometimes I would not even try to explain something and simply enjoy its mystery. I guess that makes me a viewer who is not obsessed with closure. The supreme evil of Judy has not corrupted me entirely.
ОтветитьI LOVE when you switch voices. I LOVE this video. You are just the coolest. I’m so happy I found your channel.
ОтветитьI've enjoyed so many things "inspired" by twin peaks and never got it. I watched the first two seasons, and it didn't click. At times, i thought it was a comedy and went down a reddit rabbit hole trying to understand what made it so great.
The silent hill guys could surely explain it to me outside of "it was way way ahead of its time"
Now I realize it was ahead of it's time, but that doesn't mean it aged well. I appreciate what it did, I appreciate it's why I have some of the media i have today...but christ this didn't age well. It's like an arthouse version of a modern drama series that didn't become a cult classic, but is so undeniably influential it keeps coming back up.
I appreciate it for that, but everyone telling me to watch it and go in blind set me up for failure, as I imagine it did for a lot of others.
Sir you are incredible. I’m rewatching this video as I am rewatching The Return and you continue to blow my mind. This is the most satisfying interpretation and makes me appreciate Lynch a million times more .
ОтветитьKnowing Lynch the horse is simply, "The old gray mare, she ain't what she used to be."
ОтветитьThe bad with the good, the bitter with the sweet, the coffee with the cherry pie... the Heineken with the Pabst!Blue!Ribbon!
ОтветитьThis guy is GENIOUS. I never wiuld have noticed these things IN A MILLION YEARS
ОтветитьClosure of a tv mystery show, hero/good unequivocally winning is equated to consumable violence. Just being good is awful and better is a balance between good and evil instead? And audiences wanting it is a rotten idea?
ОтветитьNashville Rules would cut the hem of Patsy Cline's gown into tatters for The Wizard of Oz you could leave out in the rain without a rainbow. I mean just completely rip the tent apart and ruin the Easter Service with fates.
ОтветитьThe thing is a show can only go on so long. We have so many zombie shows
ОтветитьThis is what happens when you can't let a theory go.
ОтветитьIve said it before, but it bears repeating--
An idiot would attempt to explain Twin Peaks, but only an asshole would devote 4 hours to doing so.
I wonder how long did he take to render this. Good job!
ОтветитьMy head hurts but I like it though
ОтветитьOh my God. YOU'RE JUDY
ОтветитьBrilliant! Thank you.
ОтветитьI love this SO much. Thank you! Also Twede's still makes a damn fine cup of coffee - and the pie was good!
ОтветитьBro... The Lynch impersonation... The first 20 min I wanted to scream... NOW??? I feel like Lynch is Narrating! LMAO! Great video!
ОтветитьNot explained, at all, none of it, not one single bit.
ОтветитьRewatching this to understand alan wake 2.
ОтветитьThis is reтarded
ОтветитьDavid lynch?
More like.
David lunch.
Cuz he loves food.
So we killed her by "wanting to know" instead of accepting never get any answers about anything. You can really see how this spawned so many other movies, tv shows, books etc... All very overrated.
ОтветитьEven if David Lynch would personally say this is all nonsense (and he never would say anything anyway), this is an incredible breakdown with meticulous work. There are some leaps at times but it still fits together very well.
Kudos to the dedication to put all this together. It really helps putting everything into a context that seems to make perfect sense.
This is such trash review, please dont watch and save 4 hours of your life and spend it on something else
Ответитьbob is bbb or 666
ОтветитьWhat the hell
ОтветитьSomewhat ironically, this is the kind of explanation that Twin Peaks fans have a tendency to reject, and continue to demand answers - which is the entire point!!
ОтветитьDude. This is incredible. Screw whoever has a problem or tries to diss what you’ve done. You’ve given a gift to TP fans. Unfortunately, not everyone will be able to accept that gift graciously. Thank you for doing this work. I love it and I see sense in everything you said. Even if I don’t share every opinion on every point, I definitely can see and appreciate the arguments you make. They are all well researched, analyzed and thought out. Fantastic! If anyone has a problem with any of that, they’re not worth your time or attention.
ОтветитьShould never have taken that edible before watching this 🫠
ОтветитьWhat you keep referring to as balance; is what we call nuance
ОтветитьNielsen ratings are all fake. That means that it was a couple thousand households that decided what hundreds of millions of people were actually watching
ОтветитьMan, this is some of the best content ive seen on this platform
ОтветитьSorry but this analysis makes too many assumptions and interconnections... Why are the woodsmen black ? Because they drive trucks, which have wheels. What do wheels have ? Tires! And what are tires made from? Rubber! and where is Rubber harvested? in Africa!, and what color are people in Africa? Black! That's why the woodsmen are black! The answers are all before us!
ОтветитьI have listened to your text in this many times, and i think you have done a fantastic work! Very good! Very interesting! Then there are a lot of other interpretations, like spiritual, just makes Twin Peaks to the best cultural project during the latest century!
ОтветитьThe Little Girl Who Lives Down the Lane...is an old movie starring Jodie Foster.
ОтветитьI appreciate the Spoiler Alert of a lifetime. People often just include it as a sort of disclaimer, but especially for something where deciphering the art is part of the experience, it's nice to see genuine thought put into it.
Also, good analysis. The end of Season 2 bugged me for months, and then I finally got around to season 3 somehow expecting resolution, and... several months later still couldn't stop thinking about it without coming to any conclusions. Lack of closure certainly led me to consider it more deeply.