PRO assistant referee offside test - 2015

clip #19 was considered offside but in fact it is onside since there was 2 players, one was in offside position and the second was not, and the second one was the one involved in the active play, not player one!

Good video, one criticism: The video should have audio, one thing I use as a referee for offsides is I listen for the kick. 20/25

Let's try a another argument...all these are onside because the ball is kicked by someone wearing a black top - presumably the referee - clothed similarly to the assistant referee. The guy in the red top is never offside as the ball hasn't been played forward by a member of his own team. Joel Lacey - feel free to use that argument as it's just as ridiculous as your one.

Shit test shit video. Do full size pitch with correct pitch markings and goals so we can get a bearing on wtf is going on

this job is difficult it requires more concentration not easy at all. Love it from Rwanda

7 negative answers, the rest good. I think I could be an arbiter in Spain.

On Clip 19 one of the attackers is offside and one is onside. The pass goes to the left where the attacker was onside. The one who was offside didn't interfere therefore he is passively offside. That's just a bad training video if they don't care for passive and active offside.

if you don't know what to call, you shouldn't call shit

You should give the information, that the passive offside doesnt matter in your video, because this costed me some points in the end.

I thought every single one was offside LOL

BS. I only watch first 5 but all are off-side. Off-side rule is clear: 2 players needed. There only is a "defender" (well a guy running). People forget that the keeper counts in those situation. But here we can't see if there's a keeper, I assume we see all the players. So all are offside.

the referee needs a smartwatch with a big 4k screen enough to see the best replay instantly, so the game doesn't lose its flow

try with pause and play :'D

19 is not Offside lol this video is absolutely useless

Honestly, I think this video is rubbish. First off, the point of view should be directly on the line and not at an angle. On clip 16, it may be that if the camera view were on the offside line, the player's head would have been ahead of the defender's foot. Secondly, this video should be labeled 'offside position' since there seems to be little effort to determine which of the two attackers is playing the ball.

Should have shown the answer right away. Not after all clips

17 out of 25.... looks like I need glasses....lol

on, on, off, on, on, on, off, on, off, on, on, off, on, off, off, on, off, off, on, on, on, on, on, on, on. All correct when 19 and 21 are correctly ruled onside since the player in the offside position would not have an impact on the play

There are 2 things that bother me in this video. First of all, it is really difficult without the sound of the ball being kicked because it forces you to watch the ball and the player when all you want to be doing is watching the player. Also, the camera angle is on the wrong side, so that is kind of weird too

clip 3 was offside.

I feel like some of these freeze frames are taking before the ball is kicked or as it is just touched and not leaving the passers foot yet.

I thought everything was offside HAHAHAA

Ronaldo r9 is very good at this. I’ve seen so many goals of him where he timed his run perfectly and stayed onside. His famous goal vs Lazio in UEFA final is one of them.

Only 2 wrong not bad

Too many offsides

18/25

got 12/25

17/25, more importantly, got the last eight in a row correct so got better the longer it went.

I got 15/25. That was tough

This video no sound...

22/25

20/25

20/25 all them times I've had to run the line in Sunday league cus I'm a sub does have advantages

18/25


Although as others have said, the ruling on Clip 19 appears to be incorrect. Same argument can be made for Clip 21 as well. But whether the player in offside position challenges the ball or not is less obvious in that one. The movement is a bit awkward.


Additionally Clip 5 is hairline close. Very hard to correctly rule that one. Especially watching it from a 30 (or less) fps video and with this angle.


Conclusion: VAR is a blessing from soccer gods.

sixteen good , i need to improve

21/25 i think i did good tbh

How effective is Episoketren System? I have heard several awesome things about this popular training program.

Clip 16 having drawn lines on its offside to me

What is the best way to earn the respect and admiration of my friends and other players? I read a lot of superb reviews on the internet about how Episoketren System can assist you improve your soccer technique. Has anyone tested out this popular training program?

I try to find AR training video. finally I found it. Thanks for good vedio.

Isnt it 22 offside

look at the red guys foot

Excelente conteúdo.
Se me permite uma consideração, em relação ao clip 19, o jogador que recebe a bola no vídeo, no momento do passe está habilitado. Foi considerado fora de jogo, mas o jogador que está em offside não joga.

Pretty false scenarios of limited use IMO. No sound. All close to assistant. All assistants have to use ball kick sound as passer and attacker often not in same field of vision.

Now is offside when VAR says offside

Clip Number 5 is questionable. You can see the toe of the attacker just ahead of the back heel of the defender in the answer clip.

13/25 Proud of myself, one day will be up there, god willing.

I got 17/25 but got 11 out of the last 12 so got better as it went on! Very tough though

Sorry but impossible without sound. You can’t look for when the ball is kicked and be off line anyway. What you really need is a GoPro on the assistants head

I got 20/25, very good test! We assistant referees who are at lower levels should practice much more with similar tests.