Joker 2019 Killing Randall but spares Gary. Arthur stabbing Randall in the neck with scissors

Randall stabs Arthur in the back while Arthur stabs Randall in the front.

I was dreading the rest of this scene because I thought he was going to kill Gary too, but I knew that Gary never did anything to deserve it and was a very nice man. I was so relieved when he told Gary that he wasn't gonna hurt him.

Was waiting for something like this scene all movie. It didn’t disappoint

Don't go to school tomorrow vibe

Bless Gary

That arthur actually spared gary shows that he just wants to take revenge on the ones who hurted him and spare the ones who was nice to him

i bet Gary wore his shitty pants that day

Legend says, that everytime Gary visits the Joker with a companion, he brings a step stool with him.

Arthur scaring Gary was just so mean!

This movie did an excellent job of portraying just how horrible things can be in life. I feel so bad for Gary in this scene. That would scar me for life.

When someone says they stopped taking their medication that’s a clear sign to get tha fuck outta there💀💀💀💀

Imagine being a genuine loving nice person like Gary and then you see this happen between two people you worked with. His reaction is so pure cause he is devasted by the death of someone mean to him from work but also so caring he is asking “why would you do that Arthur?”. I may be wrong but that’s what I see

🔪🦍

Oooh aaaahhhhhhh

it fuckin crazy innit

I bet there's a deleted scene somewhere where he did kill Gary, but they decided to go with the scene where he doesn't.

Hes just way too thin. Looks sickly 😒

For real, Gary’s screams are actually kinda heartbreaking like even with all the midjet shit thrown at him he still saw Randall as a close friend

This is the fork in the road scene.
This decide if Arthur was going to be scene as pure evil or a tragic anti heroe.

Gary it's so innocent and adorable, I was almost pannicking thinking Arthur would kill him

"Be nice to people" is easy. "Assume the best in everyone" is difficult. But when you can assume the best in everyone, you automatically treat them with kindness and sympathy.

Assuming the best in people is difficult though because it takes optimism, and optimism runs the risk of being wrong. And when we're wrong about something we're optimistic about ohhhh does the world love to kick you while you're down for it.

It's also difficult because it's rather ingrained in us to assume the worst immediately when someone does something rude or bad. That's not because humans are evil, we're simply pattern-recognizing, generalizing creatures. When we see someone lashing out in public or getting loud and angry, we can choose to fight the immediate assumption that they're just awful people and consider that they might be having a bad day. When we do that, we automatically treat them with kindness and sympathy, and sometimes that small act of recognizing someone's humanity when they're at their lowest point is enough to bring them back down.

Next time someone cuts you off in traffic in a rush, when someone's being rude or acting strange towards you, when someone kills 3 guys on a Subway, just remember that you don't have the benefit of seeing their life story in a movie. And just like Arthur, seeing someone's life story doesn't necessarily justify their actions, but you can start to understand them. Remember they're human. That's what's difficult. "Be nice to people!" is easy, especially when people are nice to us. "Assume the best in everyone" is difficult. But even though there probably are some people out there that are 100% evil, it's very rare. More than likely that they're just a person having a bad day.

I love gary❤❤

Todd id an amazing dark comedy director.

I remember when I first watched this scene that i got a genuine smile when I saw Gary and Arthur smiling at him too. I was also glad Arthur stabbed Randall for being a dick, especially after insulting my boy Gary. But then i was worried because I genuinely thought that Arthur was going to kill Gary. I legit cried when Gary tried to open the door but couldn't reach the lock. I was crying while saying, "come on Arthur. Please don't kill the only one who was ever nice to you. Don't transform fully into the joker yet. Please let him go"
Then he did and the amount of relief i fell was amazing.

Crap mov8

right in the feels...not gonna lie

❤Am I the only one who though Gary was gonna be the penguin ?

I have had people be nice to me and then say "when you shoot up the place remember I was always nice to you"... I'm a quiet white male that apparently looks like a serial killer so I get those jokes all the time... I find them funny but some are stupid ... My favorite was when I was at work and I got visably upset and my coworker jumped under his desk and was like "it's happening guys code red".... I couldn't stop laughing ... It was the comic relief I needed at that time

When Arthur opened the door:

Randall: 😠
Gary: 😊

Poor Gary 😕 still takes a minute take piss out his accent and scare the guy. Arthur was a dk.

"I stopped taking my medication. I feel a lot better now."
As someone who is bipolar and a whooole bunch of other shit wrong with me, let that sentence be *RED FLAG NUMBER 1*

In the theater, I KNEW Gary was next

This was the most scared I was in the whole movie. I thought Arthur was going to turn on Gary

Love you Joker bhai❤

forehead kiss is deeper than words

movies who always felt that im alive and to feel im not alone

literally me.

Gary ❤

Man this movie was awesome

The entire moral of the movie summed up in one line. "You were always nice to me".

This is the reason why Joker doesn't kill Batman because Batman is always nice to him.

I was so worried and stressed of thinking Arthur would kill Gary

😵‍💫😵‍💫😵‍💫

Poor gary

Gary will eventually become Penguin

is that you KHABIB?