Why was India split into two countries? - Haimanti Roy

Why was India split into two countries? - Haimanti Roy

TED-Ed

2 года назад

3,487,923 Просмотров

Ссылки и html тэги не поддерживаются


Комментарии:

@RO-vr9qx
@RO-vr9qx - 02.01.2024 20:46

Pqp

Ответить
@naveerarizwan5329
@naveerarizwan5329 - 01.01.2024 07:42

My family is originally from North India, my mum’s side is from Lucknow and my Dad’s side is from Dehli, during the partition my we forced to leave our land behind and move to Karachi, Pakistan. My grandparents still remember their homes and the deaths my family suffered. But ultimately decided that Pakistan was the right decision, especially now seeing the state of my muslim brothers and sisters in India I can’t help but agree.

Ответить
@aniket_S_yt
@aniket_S_yt - 01.01.2024 00:53

Are you sure India had Christians before the British Raj? And where did these Christians come from?

Ответить
@briandoherty8337
@briandoherty8337 - 31.12.2023 07:35

Because the English did despicable things and are War Criminals and in the process of committing war crimes they created a mess that cannot be fixed, like Ireland.

Ответить
@Mohammad_Abushaqra
@Mohammad_Abushaqra - 29.12.2023 05:06

كيف تعالج كسر الخاطر.😔.

في بعض التجمعات العائلية...
قد تجد شخصا " سليط اللسان يوجه كلاما جارحا "😢
فكيف تحمي نفسك من أثر الكلمة الجارحة.. ؟

- عند سماعك قولاً مؤذياً أو جارحا" من :
زوج أوزوجة أو أخ أو أخت أو أب أو أم أو قريب أو بعيد...
يقع بالقلب ألم ...و يحدث في النفس خدوش💔

فإذا سكت عنها وتجاوزت سمي هذا الحلم والعفو.... ...

ولكن :
كيف تتجنب هذا الألم...؟
والأهم كيف تحافظ على القلب من أذى تلك الكلمات الجارحة ، لكي لا تصيبك أمراض مثل :
الكراهية ، الغل ، الحسد أو مرض جسدي أو عصبي الخ...؟؟

يشير القرآن الكريم في ثلاثة مواضع إلى هذه الوقاية
التي نبحث عنها :

● قال الله عز وجل في نهاية سورة الحجر :
﴿وَلَقَد نَعلَمُ أَنَّكَ يَضيقُ صَدرُكَ بِما يَقولونَ* فَسَبِّح بِحَمدِ رَبِّكَ وَكُن مِنَ السّاجِدينَ﴾

● و في أواخر سورة طه :
﴿فَاصبِر عَلى ما يَقولونَ وَسَبِّح بِحَمدِ رَبِّكَ قَبلَ طُلوعِ الشَّمسِ وَقَبلَ غُروبِها وَمِن آناءِ اللَّيلِ فَسَبِّح وَأَطرافَ النَّهارِ لَعَلَّكَ تَرضى﴾

● و في أواخر سورة ق :
﴿فَاصبِر عَلى ما يَقولونَ وَسَبِّح بِحَمدِ رَبِّكَ قَبلَ طُلوعِ الشَّمسِ وَقَبلَ الغُروبِ﴾

فلك أن تلاحظ الأمر بالتسبيح بعد كلمة
( يقولون ) فوراً...أي عند سماع الكلام المؤذي...
* فسلامة القلب أمر مهم ... وكأن ( التسبيح )
يقي القلب من أي أذى يسببه الكلام الجارح وليس وقاية فحسب، بل يورثك رضا تشعر به يستقر في قلبك ⁦♥️⁩

- جعلنا الله و إياكم من المسبحين آناء الليل و أطراف النهار.

Ответить
@moonchild8024
@moonchild8024 - 26.12.2023 08:28

European countries are built on the back of colonialist past of bloodshed

Ответить
@karthikk2896
@karthikk2896 - 17.12.2023 17:00

It' was a beautiful gift from Jinnah and Jawaharlal Nehru to Indians but even though it's not a Hindustan

Ответить
@garrettburke8218
@garrettburke8218 - 15.12.2023 16:36

Are the Indians upset that Britain gave them their autonomy?

Ответить
@andieallison6792
@andieallison6792 - 15.12.2023 15:04

The English seem to be under the impression that racism doesn't exist there, that racism is only an "American Thing", or that "well it's TeChNiCaLlY not racism it's xenophobia!" (as if that makes it any better).

If anything racism in the UK is arguably worse because they refuse to believe that it exists there. Or that because Great Britain was a global superpower and colonizer a long time ago, that means everything is okay now.

Ответить
@strawmanfallacy8666
@strawmanfallacy8666 - 15.12.2023 13:23

Fun fact: India has more population of Muslims than Pakistan. In fact India has the 2nd highest population of Muslims in the world after Indonesia.

Ответить
@strawmanfallacy8666
@strawmanfallacy8666 - 15.12.2023 13:20

Its wrong to call Gandhi and Nehru as Hindu majority. They were secular and fought for a secular unified India. Gandhi even offered Jinnah to be the first Prime Minister of India and make every cabinet minister a Muslim. But Jinnah didn't budge and wanted partition of the land. He wanted India-Pakistan relationship to be like USA-Canada with porous borders. Even he didn't expect the sheer scale of bloodshed and human rights atrocities.

Ответить
@keilanodriscoll822
@keilanodriscoll822 - 13.12.2023 22:11

This brought a tear to my eye. Humans really can bring utter devastation to each other.

Ответить
@sabamuneir1072
@sabamuneir1072 - 13.12.2023 13:51

jawahar nalnahru represented hindus but mahatama ghandi represented secularisum

Ответить
@Atheist-hy6xq
@Atheist-hy6xq - 10.12.2023 08:02

India divided because of Muslims. Muslims want separate islamic country
No hindu, Buddhist country created by dividing india but Islamic country created

Ответить
@rajendrameena150
@rajendrameena150 - 09.12.2023 01:24

Don't say mahatama Gandhi and Jawaharlal Nehru represent Hindu majority. They are hated by Hindus by all their works till date. Gandhi was the darkest chapter in the Indian history who taught cowardness to the country and we gain independence just because of world war and Azad hind fauj of Subhash Chandra Bose.

Ответить
@maricacavaldini9915
@maricacavaldini9915 - 04.12.2023 18:37

i'm european and wouldn't know anything about the partition of india if i hadn't watched a doctor who episode, and it's really worrying

Ответить
@stealthninja2058
@stealthninja2058 - 04.12.2023 02:32

I wish India and Pakistan should just stop being I. A war like every year 😂😢😢❤🎉😅🇲🇽🇵🇰🇧🇩
But I mean 😭 it’s sad but China 🇨🇳 might fix it..!
Nah they won’t. But I mean Japan is so passive that they may heal the wounds of Indian Asian China 🇨🇳 and Africa will probably be lead by
Swedish and Swiss Troops and The Amtrak Coalition Pact of Police in NATO of Defense and Anti-Communist and fully autocratic and 100% Democratically with 0 political parties leading to a Civil War where the Japanese will just united them all into Princess Mononoke of Hokkaido, Imperial Japan during the Sengoku Jidai with
Toyotomi Hideyoshi’s attempt to invade Korea and China which was stopped by Korean General and Part of Chinese Culture
Yi-Shu-Shen or Admiral Yi…

From the 1500s and into the early and violent end of the Samurai: In 1947:
Japan was bombed in Hiroshima and Nagasaki in Tokyo and with Hirohito left in power and Pacific Commander of the Armed forces
Famed and most famous WWI general named
Admiral Nitmirz of the Pacific fleet station in Honolulu, Hawaii when the fleet lead in the Australian wars of Liberation of the Philippines

Ответить
@iQ_ui
@iQ_ui - 03.12.2023 05:35

Doesn't emort anything

Ответить
@Bean23842
@Bean23842 - 01.12.2023 11:33

We learned it in school in 1st grade and this is always the first ch of history

From bd

Ответить
@Genius_thought
@Genius_thought - 01.12.2023 05:57

In India only hindu Jain bauddh and sikhkh were only not others religion people

Ответить
@kavitaandy9361
@kavitaandy9361 - 30.11.2023 04:55

India was partitioned through sheer wicked spite by the British and it shows their culture of hate and coersion and being the most Nosey country with the most Nosey people in the world.

Ответить
@TheSm1thers
@TheSm1thers - 30.11.2023 02:27

This video has an extremely anti-British bias. It ignores that Britain wanted a united India and was forced into partition. Also ignores that strong religious rifts existed before colonisation.

Ответить
@AmeyaBloxYT
@AmeyaBloxYT - 24.11.2023 18:36

"A moment comes, which comes but rarely in history, when we step out from the old to new, when an age ends, and when the soul of a nation, long suppressed, finds utterance"
- Jawaharlal Nehru, tryst with destiny speech

Ответить
@princemahadi573
@princemahadi573 - 24.11.2023 08:40

Where is Subhash Chandra Bose?

Ответить
@souvicchakraborty3911
@souvicchakraborty3911 - 20.11.2023 15:37

ajob!

Ответить
@Thinker9999
@Thinker9999 - 20.11.2023 08:03

Religion is poison

Ответить
@jarvisjackson4833
@jarvisjackson4833 - 17.11.2023 02:46

Don't blame the British for what the Muslims wanted. This totally ignores how the Muslims colonized the Hindus. It would have been much worse if the British hadn't done what they did. This racial animus was already there.

Ответить
@nickoteen4550
@nickoteen4550 - 15.11.2023 22:20

As a citizen on akhand Bharat i don't believe in existence of India and Pakistan and Bangladesh. Make bharat as it was before all the chaos and discrimination

Ответить
@bsyashwanthgowda4087
@bsyashwanthgowda4087 - 14.11.2023 12:03

It's high time that we Indians should come out of the colonial mindset and be a proud Indian .

Ответить
@WhiteCatfish56076
@WhiteCatfish56076 - 12.11.2023 19:48

It should have been twenty countries.

Ответить
@Butterfly..-..
@Butterfly..-.. - 10.11.2023 22:02

Bro I’m Kashmiri and we either say we r a part of Pakistan or a whole other country that belongs to Pakistan rn so like I’m not Indian I’m Pakistani

Ответить
@carolynmckay1599
@carolynmckay1599 - 10.11.2023 18:56

What if we just got rid of religion? It would solve alot of problems.

Ответить
@JhabruTiger
@JhabruTiger - 08.11.2023 20:08

British were the worst thing ever happened to this world.

Ответить
@sakibabrararnob5197
@sakibabrararnob5197 - 07.11.2023 23:05

As a Bangladeshi, I regret the decision of Partition. It was all due to the British's 'Divide & Rule Policy' & hypocrisy of Jinnah & Savarkar & others. A whole country divided into two parts destroying the unity of India. But this partition will not last forever. India again will be reunited Insha Allah. Waiting for the reunion.

Ответить
@dod4004
@dod4004 - 06.11.2023 23:39

It's a common myth that the British Government wanted colonies partitioned. Actually the British preferred to create strong federal states and strongly opposed breaking colonies up as it was thought they would be too weak to defend themselves.

Many British federal creations survive today and are taken for granted: Canada, Australia, Malaysia, Nigeria, South Africa to name a few. Some failed examples include the Federation of the West Indies and Rhodesia and Nyasaland.

Wherever colonies were divided, it was strongly--sometimes violently--opposed by the British Government, including Palestine, India, Cyprus and Ireland. In every case, the government was opposed to partition and their hand was forced by the inhabitants.

Ответить
@anayadegani626
@anayadegani626 - 06.11.2023 18:31

Even in 2023, we are still facing the problems. Kashmir wished to be independent but India's leaders put a gun to the ruler's head and forced them to sign the treaty joining India. There is a lot tension and religious hate in India & Pakistan all because the Britishers were just lazy and refused to listen to the populace's will

Ответить
@consciousdn9758
@consciousdn9758 - 04.11.2023 19:23

"In the aftermath of World War II under enormous finacial strain from the war, Britain finally caved" utterly Flawed. Remember British was looting India for it's own benefits so British chose to quit India not just because of financial strain from the war, it was because of the great leader Netaji Bose effect as PM Clement Attlee expressed later in an interview, when British realized after the Royal Indian Navy mutiny in 1946 that loyalty of the Indian soldiers to the British crown was not guarateed thing.

Ответить
@eeveesbibleKJV
@eeveesbibleKJV - 04.11.2023 03:34

This is why I Hate the british

Ответить
@richarddecker9515
@richarddecker9515 - 02.11.2023 07:34

Divide and conquer

Ответить
@vishaldeka5298
@vishaldeka5298 - 01.11.2023 09:17

If you heard what Biden said about America having to invent an Israel, you would know that US and their allies invented Pakistan to protect their interests in the Indian subcontinent.

Ответить
@iamthenews5624
@iamthenews5624 - 01.11.2023 02:42

India and Kashmir have been warring since 1947?

Ответить
@iamthenews5624
@iamthenews5624 - 01.11.2023 02:42

1971: Pakistan became Bangledash and Kashmir became India 😉

Ответить
@iamthenews5624
@iamthenews5624 - 01.11.2023 02:39

How can you create East Pakistan in the middle of India? 🤣

Ответить
@iamthenews5624
@iamthenews5624 - 01.11.2023 02:35

Hindus: Wanted a United India
Muslims: Wanted a 2 State Solution
Britain
Muslims get Pakistan bengal, punjab
Hindus get India with Assam
😭😭😭

Ответить
@iamthenews5624
@iamthenews5624 - 01.11.2023 02:28

British Categories:
Muslims: Largest minority
Hindus:Majority
Sikhs: Are Hindu 😭
You can only vote in your Category 😭😭😭😭

Ответить
@safayatkhan2280
@safayatkhan2280 - 28.10.2023 07:20

Safe to say England single-handedly ruined 90% of the world

Ответить
@PatiHuMai
@PatiHuMai - 27.10.2023 11:18

Janna hi nahi hai

Ответить
@divyeshkumar6357
@divyeshkumar6357 - 25.10.2023 21:58

A little correction : M.K Gandhi and J.L Nehru were totally secular towards the masses. The Congress party had a number of prominent muslim leaders like Syed ahmad khan, abdul ghaffar khan etc. who were the reason of a lot of muslims choose to stay back in India. It was due to the divisive policies of British , that allowed Jinnah and his followers to proceed with a separate identity.

Ответить
@kittyaya3425
@kittyaya3425 - 25.10.2023 11:46

As a Muslim I find this very sad.

Ответить