Why the Nakba is key to understanding Palestinian history #shorts

Why the Nakba is key to understanding Palestinian history #shorts

Vox

9 месяцев назад

2,115,926 Просмотров

Ссылки и html тэги не поддерживаются


Комментарии:

@Jehoshua.J.A.K.
@Jehoshua.J.A.K. - 27.01.2024 01:37

Isreal is 4,000 years old. It is the land of Abraham and his decedents. Jews were chased out when Isam was created. After WW2, Isreal was guven back to the descidents of Abraham whomown the land. Islam has been trying to destroy a second time for the last 80 years. To say otherwise is a lie and qualifies as antiSemitism. Anti-semetism is hatespeech!

Ответить
@strikeru.s.m.c.8771
@strikeru.s.m.c.8771 - 27.01.2024 01:14

Wow! Palestine 🇵🇸 people were really Black but because of America, Britain and the United Nations Palestine has been "Ethnic Cleansing" which means they've been "WhitedOut" in Spanish they call it Blanqueamiento and in Portuguese its called branqueamento. This is why in America 🇺🇸 they push for black and white people have relationships with each other 👀 Holy Cow!.😮

Ответить
@melchiormapa3597
@melchiormapa3597 - 26.01.2024 22:59

Palestinians arabs are occupiers of the Jewish land, Jerusalem is the ancient Jewish capital more than 3000 yrs sgo. The jews are coming back to their ancestral lands.

Ответить
@bz6122
@bz6122 - 26.01.2024 22:01

The presentation of half truth is basically laying.
The arabs organized and started attacking the Jewish community since 1918.
The deadliest was 1929.
Most of he arabs have immigrated to Israel by the 19th century. They have never called themselves Palestinians nor a nation until the 1920s. "Hagana" (defense)was a response to the arab attacks.
The arabs started the 1947 War and 1948 war , the result of those wars where new borders after Israel managed to push back the arabs and the 7 armies that joined up together in order to eliminate Israel. There was no plan but just very bad consequences for the arab attacks . If the muslims had expected Israel in the 1948 borders , none of this would have happened.

Ответить
@EricMSM
@EricMSM - 26.01.2024 18:07

And they still call palestinians "terrorists"

Ответить
@SchlesMapper
@SchlesMapper - 26.01.2024 13:37

Which side accepted the UN border?

Ответить
@TANTHEMANFILMS
@TANTHEMANFILMS - 26.01.2024 02:24

and how many Jews where displaced from Arab and Muslim countries during the time of the Nakba?? ....

Ответить
@rojetar8304
@rojetar8304 - 25.01.2024 17:21

Just need to add something. Palestinian Arabs are not historical ones. That’s a fully different topic. Also, why many Muslim countries let Jews live in their lands but they don’t let Palestinians live there? How many Jews are living aboard ? So it’s ok to deport them all now right?

Ответить
@bee8470
@bee8470 - 25.01.2024 10:47

You’ve become the very thing you swore to hate

Ответить
@rezaroohnia5140
@rezaroohnia5140 - 25.01.2024 08:14

There was no Palestine. The property was owned by the ottoman empie

Ответить
@ericloch9677
@ericloch9677 - 25.01.2024 02:17

Yeah so has isreals

Ответить
@marjorierijnbout7905
@marjorierijnbout7905 - 25.01.2024 01:19

How?
You are terrorized and killed and brutally slaughtered.
And then you move to another country and you end up to be the oppressor. Again how?

Ответить
@MuhammadAshhad-xh9sj
@MuhammadAshhad-xh9sj - 24.01.2024 23:57

That's why i hate UN

Ответить
@Phixion8841
@Phixion8841 - 23.01.2024 18:51

they lost land by starting genocidal religious wars

Ответить
@muhammadfaruq1675
@muhammadfaruq1675 - 23.01.2024 17:06

Thank you Vox for telling the truth.

Ответить
@gayathrigayu4888
@gayathrigayu4888 - 23.01.2024 14:15

Where is Judea?
Who occupied it?

Ответить
@juliaadams9087
@juliaadams9087 - 23.01.2024 14:13

Yet the ignorant will remain fixated on October the 7th and asking whether you condemn H 🙄
I’m not saying what happened was okay, it’s not, but there is a much bigger context that needs to be considered.
It’s like Palestinians are expected to accept their land being stolen and their rights becoming non existent - and if they speak up or act up, then they’re terrorists.

Ответить
@danielfagen
@danielfagen - 23.01.2024 03:23

Forgot the part where 800k jews were forcefully expelled from arab countries. We call these jews Israeli while we call Palestinians refugees

Ответить
@Peashooteratthelawn
@Peashooteratthelawn - 23.01.2024 03:21

ISRAEL IS NOT A COUNTRY

Ответить
@SalahaddinAl-Ayubi
@SalahaddinAl-Ayubi - 23.01.2024 02:54

paramilitary forces NO
terrorist organizations YES

Ответить
@sigmam2104
@sigmam2104 - 21.01.2024 22:07

But 3000 years ago titus🤓🤓🤓🤓

Ответить
@aidandevlin2298
@aidandevlin2298 - 21.01.2024 21:34

God bless Israel 🇮🇱

Ответить
@sergioariasdiaz540
@sergioariasdiaz540 - 21.01.2024 20:53

la llamada Palestina siempre fue una tierra de paso y de inmigracion , desde el imperio mameluco y otomano hasta el mandato britanico,
Recibio oleadas de miles de inmigrantes. Egipcios. Sirios. Libaneses, drusos, circasianos, judios, cristianos sirios, argelinos, etc...hay tienen el origen de una buena parte de la población de ambas orillas de Rio Jordan....usteds solo informan de manera muy superficial de un conflicto tan complejo....😂

Ответить
@deadhuddy1722
@deadhuddy1722 - 21.01.2024 07:39

In the begging why are Muslims and Christian’s in the same bar graph

Ответить
@kwabenatree
@kwabenatree - 20.01.2024 16:46

Vox, please tell us the truth and stop lying to us. It seems like you dont respect your views. The Jews bought North israel from the Ottomans and Arab's. Palestine people were created in 1967. The land that UN wanted to give to the Jews was waste land and swamps. Go and check malaria outbreaks in Mandatory Palestine. Those are the lands that were given to the Jewish people by the UN.

Ответить
@theempresss2020
@theempresss2020 - 20.01.2024 12:05

Free palestine 🇵🇸

Ответить
@ananielee
@ananielee - 20.01.2024 10:03

For those who say people in Gaza are just paying for what Hamas did, who do you think you are that you can play God and decide people’s life?

Ответить
@danielpiesto532
@danielpiesto532 - 20.01.2024 05:21

They bought most of the land.

Ответить
@Marvsueny
@Marvsueny - 19.01.2024 20:30

Arab coalition started the 6days war right after Israel was formed which stated the whole thing, somehow skipped in this video. Must be the short video time limit 😂 Jewish communities are also already there for ages starting a lot of the cities with the Christian, sounded like they are fresh immigrants in the video.

Ответить
@SLNHanumaK
@SLNHanumaK - 19.01.2024 19:23

Funny to see how conveniently people are choosing from where the history starts.

Ответить
@tamirfrenkel9686
@tamirfrenkel9686 - 19.01.2024 16:42

"HaHagana" literally means "The Defence" in Hebrew, seriously stop spreading lies.
In all through history, recent and old, the jewish were attacked by the arabs and only responded, how can you call it occupation when you are constantly being attacked.
I guess Jewish people have to say sorry for winning the wars even tho we just defended ourselves?
Thats ridiculous.

Ответить
@user-zm2vj5ws3j
@user-zm2vj5ws3j - 19.01.2024 12:32

All lies

Ответить
@choosen1130
@choosen1130 - 19.01.2024 12:17

You forgot to mention how the Arabs drove all the Jews from their lands which also contributed to the immigration of Jews into isreal

Ответить
@choosen1130
@choosen1130 - 19.01.2024 12:17

You forgot to mention how the Arabs drove all the Jews from their lands which also contributed to the immigration of Jews into isreal

Ответить
@choosen1130
@choosen1130 - 19.01.2024 12:17

You forgot to mention how the Arabs drove all the Jews from their lands which also contributed to the immigration of Jews into isreal

Ответить
@choosen1130
@choosen1130 - 19.01.2024 12:17

You forgot to mention how the Arabs drove all the Jews from their lands which also contributed to the immigration of Jews into isreal

Ответить
@jamoin4310
@jamoin4310 - 18.01.2024 16:15

Why shouldn’t Israel have habe 700k settlers when 850k Jews got expelled from Arab country?

Ответить
@Molere
@Molere - 18.01.2024 10:06

Que penses-tu de la RÉVOCATION de la traite de Balfour ????

Ответить
@YadinZedek777
@YadinZedek777 - 18.01.2024 09:46

Before WW1 the land under Ottoman rule was considered Syria. After WW1 the Land that consist of modern day Israel and Jordan made up Palestine. The league of nations already partitioned Palestine by 1922. Between 1920 and 1922, Western Palestine was considered Jewish Palestine and Eastern Palestine was considered Arab Palestine.

Ответить
@exceedcharge
@exceedcharge - 17.01.2024 18:43

i love the massive scale of eternal kvetching this video generated and still going strong 🌜

Ответить
@GermanGrandpa.
@GermanGrandpa. - 17.01.2024 18:41

Finally someone spoke about the story from the beginning

Ответить
@pythonhotlost6039
@pythonhotlost6039 - 17.01.2024 06:12

Why do you miss so much of history in your video. For a site that pretends to be balanced to attempt to explain such a complex conflict in 60 sec is a bad idea at best and actually very moranic. The reason Arabs lost all their land is because they started multiple wars that they have lost. Gaza and West Bank were never parts of any country and until 1967 (six day way) were occupied by Egypt and Jordan respectively. Palestinian identity was created by PLO with KGB’s help in 1964 before so called occupation. You are missing tons of history and context.

Ответить
@davidnorth3411
@davidnorth3411 - 17.01.2024 05:47

When you look for the reason theirs a rebuttal given, go further back , to find what ? worse atrocities than current piloted programs .

Ответить
@user-nn1ig8hm9u
@user-nn1ig8hm9u - 17.01.2024 00:48

History doenst start 4 generations ago

Ответить
@awesomeninja524
@awesomeninja524 - 17.01.2024 00:31

They using the worst thing to happen to them as a justification for the atrocities they are committing. And if you disagree you get labeled anti semitic. What can you even do at that point

Ответить
@Vatican_ball
@Vatican_ball - 16.01.2024 23:54

Free Palestine
👇🇵🇸

Ответить
@Plantium700
@Plantium700 - 16.01.2024 21:34

We must learn more about the time of ''The Salafh!

Ответить
@christianorvin
@christianorvin - 16.01.2024 15:37

Why put Christians among the numbers with Muslims?

Ответить
@TheUniqueGamer7
@TheUniqueGamer7 - 16.01.2024 14:14

FREE PALESTINE 🇵🇸

Ответить
@TheUniqueGamer7
@TheUniqueGamer7 - 16.01.2024 14:13

FREE PALESTINE

Ответить