My Family, Partition and Me: India 70 Years Ago (Family History Documentary) | Real Stories

My Family, Partition and Me: India 70 Years Ago (Family History Documentary) | Real Stories

Real Stories

3 года назад

252,790 Просмотров

Ссылки и html тэги не поддерживаются


Комментарии:

@pranavsharma7884
@pranavsharma7884 - 09.09.2023 11:10

I am sorry for everyone who ha to go through the pain of partitions. Idk bit the way he said ethenic cleansing and genocide and the fact that 1.6% muslim were left. But every one of them wanted a seperate nation, that's not just political ideology that's bout shaping life's of millions of people. It's sad they choose partition.

Ответить
@katr8756
@katr8756 - 05.07.2023 14:26

Indian people still treats widows like they're rubbish!! The British may have stopped widows from being burned alive on their husbands funeral pyor, but widows are now destined to a slow death of starvation, or death from the elements.

Ответить
@katr8756
@katr8756 - 05.07.2023 13:45

Hey, that's what India, and the rest of the religions wanted!!! Independence! So that's what they got! And how ironic that Britan is demonized for their "terrible" colonialism, but then, thousands move to that "terrible" awful colonizing ountry of Britain as soon as they can. What hypocrites!!

Ответить
@devasishpaul8550
@devasishpaul8550 - 23.03.2023 18:01

Muslim community was very keen for separate country and the result is infront of us...

Ответить
@ggs511
@ggs511 - 21.02.2023 13:20

Britain must pay reparations to those affected by partition

Ответить
@kumarsiva5843
@kumarsiva5843 - 15.01.2023 10:36

The british instigated the partition.

Ответить
@jsbedi60
@jsbedi60 - 10.01.2023 19:29

I am a Sikh . I was born in 1960, and grew up listening to stories from my Grandfather.
Yes. We are a refugee family, that was forced out from our home (s) in Montgomery and Lahore.

Its ironic, and sad, that Punjab and Bengal contributed the most to the Freedom Movement, and it was Punjab and Bengal that got screwed and bore the brunt of the
Partition Fratricide /Holocaust.

When Gandhi was picking salt, or doing his little Satyagraha shenanigans, Patriots from Punjab and Bengal were fighting British bullets.

The biggest myth of History is that Gandhi got India her independence.

This Holocaust never got its rightful place in the annals of history.
We were / are Non White, not Judeo Christian, we were / are poor and uneducated........so our lives mattered less.

Today, its only Punjabis and Bengalis that understand our affinity for our people on the other side of the border.

Ответить
@loyisad1211
@loyisad1211 - 01.01.2023 12:22

Im fascinated how the privileged bubble of Mandy and Bim mirror each other. Mandy's father was not the owner of his land any more than Bim's zamindar father was. I suggest people read up on the zamindar caste and why and how they got their land.
That's not to say they deserved any barbaric violence that they had to suffer. They were both good men but the systems that give them that power was not (colonialism and casteism)

This documentary just helped me see the real root discontent that exploded in violence.

Caste is not religion issue. It is present across religions. I wouldn't be surprised that the militias that drove Syed away were lower caste and his family was, again, higher zamindar caste.

Ответить
@muhammadakram4303
@muhammadakram4303 - 05.09.2022 02:58

A real and heart breaking journey in our history.

Ответить
@maxiscoozuba4338
@maxiscoozuba4338 - 22.08.2022 22:57

These families were the lucky ones. This doc follows people of means, people with the money to escape. The people who had no money such as their staff suffered a far worse fate

Ответить
@ilianaperisteridi951
@ilianaperisteridi951 - 19.08.2022 20:19

You have the British to thank for this disaster. They did the same thing in Palestine, Cyprus and wherever else they ruled and left after looting treasures which even today are in their museums!

Ответить
@fawaziaali6814
@fawaziaali6814 - 10.08.2022 22:25

If Ghandi did bring an end to the violence we need another Ghandi now in India 🇮🇳

Ответить
@fawaziaali6814
@fawaziaali6814 - 10.08.2022 22:00

India and Pakistan need to normalize relationships. This would strengthen economic social and geopolitical power. This kind of divisive policies are promoted by the superpowers. So 😥 but it's time for change.

Ответить
@RohitKumar-jy6sd
@RohitKumar-jy6sd - 21.07.2022 15:46

I request to the people of Bangladesh please help me find clues about my ancestors, i am from Delhi India i will not give up my grandmother grandfathers friends family would be there

Ответить
@nesa8811
@nesa8811 - 21.07.2022 07:45

Wow he slaughtered the man amd went back to pray in the mosque? Jeeze

Ответить
@nesa8811
@nesa8811 - 21.07.2022 06:51

I got teary watching this. 😔🤮🤮

Ответить
@kerinnewmai320
@kerinnewmai320 - 11.07.2022 11:03

My tears 😢💧roll down , I can't do it anymore

Ответить
@joanfischer1819
@joanfischer1819 - 29.06.2022 03:14

Such good and factual information. Really enjoyed watching this. My parents ended up being on the Pakistan side, not out of choice but made the best of an unfortunate situation. I’m sure many people experienced the same.

Ответить
@muhammadamirbutt6361
@muhammadamirbutt6361 - 21.06.2022 15:16

Whole time I was watching this video by God I was crying its so emotional and there are millions other sad stories like this, I heard from my grandfather what was happening those days.😥😥

Ответить
@damionhogans2947
@damionhogans2947 - 02.05.2022 03:15

“This is not my country… this is not my house” that still breaks my heart watching this a year later. The trauma that man has been through is unimaginable. Partition turned people’s worlds completely upside down and everything that they knew before was taken away (homes, friends, jobs, cultural identities etc.)Hopefully one day( way in the future)the wounds between these two countries can be healed

Ответить
@alexlim6300
@alexlim6300 - 17.04.2022 07:48

Britain.really achieved their goal of. Divide and conquer. The muslim league and the indian authorities trusted the Brits on the procedure of independance completely oblivious of their machiavelic plan.

Ответить
@missstirring6063
@missstirring6063 - 27.01.2022 10:50

Why is Mandy on this? Her colonizer family didn't belong there anyway. Should have focused on the Indian families.

Ответить
@prit0012
@prit0012 - 28.12.2021 17:12

British evil policies killed many. Europeans did colonization, 2 WWs Killed millions nd millions

Ответить
@wingedwarror3657
@wingedwarror3657 - 28.12.2021 06:41

I wish this history were taught to people of all nations. We must everyone please work together to tell these unfair stories. We must and each help spread this knowledge. It is so horrific that in today’s world we are still blind to cast systems, religious discrimination and human inequality. If we are not part of the solution to bringing ourselves together as a human race how do we ever expect to achieve enlightenment? How do we expect we are able to help protect our Heavenly Father’s children? These are our brothers and sisters. And I’m an old white, conservative, retired military man from Utah, USA. Thank you very much for helping me to learn this. I hope I will for the rest of my life, work to try and help change this and hopefully help these beautiful people and bring improvement to many other people’s lives. We who live in freedom and peace must continue to help bring blessings to other peoples of all nations. These are a proud and wonderful people and nobody should ever allow others to be treated like this. Peace must find a way; peace and love for one-another must become our reality on earth. Evil must be defeated! Evil will be defeated when our Lord, Jesus Christ returns to continue His reign again in heaven and on earth. Freedom! Freedom! Freedom! All glory be to God.

Ответить
@anilkoswatte8796
@anilkoswatte8796 - 20.09.2021 10:02

Dear Anita Rani, many thanks for your wonderful efforts to educate us, ANIl from Sri Lanka,

Ответить
@rajeshreevarma514
@rajeshreevarma514 - 18.08.2021 14:21

Where is 2nd part

Ответить
@MylesWrightMusic
@MylesWrightMusic - 13.08.2021 11:20

Anyone know if part II is available?

Ответить
@adstix
@adstix - 11.08.2021 05:57

I'm not a Muslim nor Sikh or Hindu but tears welled up my eyes watching this video!
Man's inhumanity to his fellow man can never be justified by religion!
I hope the present generation can really rise beyond religious fanaticism!
Unscrupulous politicians across the world also need to stop inciting religious sentiments!

Ответить
@Franky46Boy
@Franky46Boy - 06.08.2021 22:19

A massive movement of millions of people that can only be compared with the diaspora of Greeks, Armenians and Assyrian Christians from Turkey and the migration of Turkish people and Muslims vice versa, fleeing from the Balkans and Greece in the 1920's....

Ответить
@fekularsome2363
@fekularsome2363 - 25.07.2021 10:07

Stafford Crips did many meeting with Muslim league and told them they will have separate land if they work how the British told them they participate in the interim govt only to disrupt the Work of Govt, And soles full like That Mandolin Supported them! And don't want participate in Constitution building!,this Crips later announced if any resolution between Congress and ML doesn't came up August ,47 they will hand over India any leave they don't anything to do with India now, Giving Ml To uses Direct action Of Killings In Bengal Mostkillig,Punjab sikh of hindus was In East Bengal and Calcutta! They support Mullin league But we all know what happen 71!

Ответить
@minapoonja4338
@minapoonja4338 - 22.07.2021 08:48

Very Sad. Had tears listening to this documentary. Partition separated my Dad's step mom and half brothers and sisters. They all had to go to Pakistan and my Dad never new their whereabouts since he had left with his Aunt to come to East Africa when my grandfather remarried. Lost total contact. I am sure I have paternal families in Pakistan and but do not know them. It will always be an unknown paternal family history. Partition - Livelyhood Destroyed - Heartbreaking - Separated Families!

Ответить
@roshinimaricar5219
@roshinimaricar5219 - 18.07.2021 19:16

😭😭😭😢😥😢

Ответить
@roshinimaricar5219
@roshinimaricar5219 - 18.07.2021 19:05

Why this girl can't speak Bengali !

Ответить
@roshinimaricar5219
@roshinimaricar5219 - 18.07.2021 19:01

I hate Pakistan's Partition ! I want them United with Hindustan ! 😥😢

Ответить
@Blackwhite-yg8qv
@Blackwhite-yg8qv - 17.07.2021 17:33

Partition of India was an ugly event ,the drama was created by then jinnah and other traitors hired by then British rullers ,the drama was more or less like boris Johnson's brexit. but brexit was done without blood shed ,on the other hand indian partion still spills blood and poor people of great indian sub continent are paying a heavy price for this division ,architectured by vicious Honourable british crown and politicians .The irony is a drunk man divided a 3000 years OLD nation knowingly the outcome will be death and disaster.there is a lot to say, but words or details will not heal the scars and damage done, there is only one nation to blame for ....I am sure you know who to blame for THIS mass murder ..irony is they do not even help unite the india instead they are igniting hate when it comes close to unite.

Ответить
@ssachdeva31
@ssachdeva31 - 15.07.2021 20:33

Partition is going to happen again when Muslims become majority in west bengal and assam

Ответить
@233asha
@233asha - 14.07.2021 18:23

This is horrible history left by European

Ответить
@dannygomes4086
@dannygomes4086 - 14.07.2021 12:16

I am from Bangladesh. Unfortunately we are never taught about these atrocities happened in our country more than 70 years ago. Just a shame.

Ответить
@sunilnair8351
@sunilnair8351 - 08.07.2021 11:46

My country is secular, we have laws to protect minority rights, we got reservations for our minorities in jobs and education for their uplifting.
We don't have any restrictions for any minority to command the country, the government, army or police.
But we are bad guys and bad people.
Contrary to Pakistan which sudo libral call good. Unfortunately our own within the country have this notion. That is the biggest Irony

Ответить
@shivajithakur7735
@shivajithakur7735 - 06.07.2021 01:24

hindu and sikhs never asked for any nation muslims did.

Ответить
@karti-soor
@karti-soor - 05.07.2021 06:06

"Nasty politics, and sectarian violence.. Divide and rule, exists for centuries.. In the 21st century still, the British their partners in crime American invading, and toppling sovereign states government.... Ruins prosperous oil rich countries.. Libya and Iraq....

Ответить
@antanarivo2589
@antanarivo2589 - 04.07.2021 18:52

the brits legacy: indian partition/kasmhir, palestine, pattani, kenya ..... separating people from their families and land

Ответить
@dr.naseemabeautytree3100
@dr.naseemabeautytree3100 - 02.07.2021 16:06

any malayalees here ,,,

Ответить
@Mp-is4bu
@Mp-is4bu - 30.06.2021 03:35

All because Jinah and Nehru were puppets to British government....
Angrez chale gaye.. Jinah aur nehru chod gaye...

Ответить