Комментарии:
when he says "this... priest" he know that person is only trash.
Ответить„You go to certain death.“
„All death is certain.“
This is the line that stuck the most with me out of the entire movie somehow. Encapsules the character so very well.
Despite all the inaccuracies , this is such a great film
ОтветитьFor anybody wondering it has been confirmed that yes he is an Angel. It’s not interpretation , he is meant to be an angel as per the directors cut. The original cut out all of the mystical elements of the character but yes he is an angel as confirmed by I believe the director and one of the writers.
ОтветитьThe Director's Cut is a far superior film, and I personally loved how in the theatrical cut he's just a knight, but in the Director's Cut he's an angel. That scene where Balian turns away, and turns back only to see a barren wilderness where seconds before the Hospitaller stood is a great scene. Trivia would have it that the horse's sudden skittishness was not planned, but just happened at that moment which makes the scene seem all the more supernatural.
ОтветитьThe switch of the Hospitaler as a character between the theatrical cut and the director's cut is a master move. Well done in both versions, where in one he is portraited as a real man and in the other it let yo your interpretation of if he is a man or a angel.
ОтветитьProfessor Lupin didn't die ... he just managed to get redirected and reborn as the Hospitallier
ОтветитьWhen watching the movie I had no idea he was supposed to be a angel! When he told balian “what god desires is here and here and what you decide to do everyday you will be a good man… or not” hit me so hard when first watching this movie. It made me realize that I don’t gotta be perfect. Just be a good person everyday that’s enough.
Ответить100% he was an angel
Ответитьreckoning is to come for crimes of crusaders. funny, and here i thought crusaders were reckoning for muslims that killed pilgrims to holy land. Funny how somehow thoes who crate movies often do not know history at all. Should asked someone at least...
ОтветитьIsnt this professor lupin
ОтветитьThis movie is like a Jamie Oliver dish. Not very authentic
ОтветитьYou know....one of the critics I have heard about this movie was that the hospotallier talked in a way that most likely nobody talked back in the day. But what if he was indeed an angel? He would have talked that way to help Balian with his questions. After all, he was not one of them. He talked in a way so that Balian could understand.
ОтветитьGod I need to see the directors cut... I already loved the cinema version.
ОтветитьBest character
Ответить“I have not heard that.”
The giveaway
Remus stop using the timeturner and teach your students how to practice magic over the summer break
ОтветитьHe ain't no angel. Just a crusader that was on campaign for what he believed was the right thing. Many, most, crusaders, of course, as all men "on campaign" had ulterior motives for taking the cross.
ОтветитьIt's always strange when the character that has 5 minutes of screen time is more like in more remembered than the main actors
ОтветитьThe director’s cut is such a fine piece of cinema.
ОтветитьAs a heathen, christians would be alot less irritating if more of them like this.
ОтветитьOrlando bloom is just awful to watch on screen next to these men who are far superior.
ОтветитьI can't think of a worse color for your order to adopt to wear in the middle east than black.
ОтветитьLame.
"A reckoning for what was done 100 years before. The muslims will never forget."
Yet they did quite conveniently forget what had been done 3-4 centuries earlier when they conquered those same christian lands......
Angel is more like a Buddhist than a Christian
ОтветитьAs much as this character is a good one Ridley Scott uses him to promote false teaching. It's only through faith in Christ that you can receive grace and salvation. Not through right action. Right action is expected, but it is not what saves you.
ОтветитьWait there was a black knight or was he like some dude they met along the way?
ОтветитьALL DEATH IS CERTAIN!
-This is the spirit of a real brave man! A real knight!
a
ОтветитьYou can always tell its david thewlis. Why? He whistles his S's. Lol
ОтветитьThe Muslims will never forget not should I....
ОтветитьThe burning bush scene being removed from the movie is unforgivable, arguably the most important scene in the whole movie and clarifying everything people were confused about during the original
ОтветитьThe Hospitaller holds anachronistic views for someone from the Middle Ages, but that's the point. He's not of this earth. I believe Ridley Scott's intention was to show us how people in the Middle Ages literally believed that angels walked among us - like, really literally - were there to help us, and were holier, better versions of ourselves who knew things we did not.
ОтветитьHe was a poet and they cut off his head.
ОтветитьI personally believe the Hospitaller is an angel sent by God to guide Balian and prepare him to Jerusalem righteously. In the beginning, The Hospitaller helps hone Balian's abilities, and when he starts to lead in Jerusalem, he guides Balian toward the deeper truth: God desires peace, not endless war and the Lord is using Balian to be a protector for both the Jews, Christians, and Muslims that are caught up in the conflict. At the end of the movie, it is then and only then that the angel leaves to go with the army as he knows that Jerusalem is in safe hands because he has guided Balian on the right path. Such a fantastic character.
ОтветитьI believe that the Hospitaller character is based on Saint Nicasius of Jerusalem. However in the desert scene, it is not the Hospitaller but an angel in his form - that is why he was able to suddenly appear and disappear at the time Balian's faith is most tested. Balian must have realised that something mystical has just happened. This is the spiritual centre of the movie. Later we see the Hospitaller dead after battle.
ОтветитьAh the angel Michael the warrior Saint
ОтветитьHe's not either he's balians re assurance
ОтветитьI love the character of the hospitaller. I still think Saladin is the best character in the film. But that's just me. If you say there's definitely no one on the horse but they make a point of showing him hiding alongside the horse. I'm not saying you are wrong but I think you are definitely reading in what you want to see in that scene. Oh Baldwin is another awesome character.
ОтветитьA superb movie.
Great characters.
So full of meaning.
Few like this.
He always leaves it a matter of choice, at it should be. "What you do every day will make you a good man (pause, smile) or not." Always the invitation to choose, right or wrong.
ОтветитьThe idea of having a guardian angel/archangel manifesting as a monastic knight during the crusades is such a cool conecpt
ОтветитьMan! I wish I had an angel like that guiding me and giving me wisdom and strength. I'm going through a really rough phase right now. 😒
Ответить"according to your lord and this... "priest""
ОтветитьThe dialogues in this movie is impressive.
ОтветитьReminds me of the soldier that spoke to Joshua and said he was on neither side.
ОтветитьIs he even in the movie? I really want to know now.
Ответить