Blind Test: AI vs Real Photo, Can YOU Tell?

This should be called "I edited AI generated images to try to make them look real, can you still tell it was AI Generated versus real photos with no editing?"
He didn't take an AI generated output and compare it to a real photo.
He took an AI Generated photo and did tons of manual editing in photoshop and inpainting.
That isn't a fair comparison, because I am looking for AI generated things and he is undoing them.
You could do the same and take real photos and add in obvious AI Generated features to make it look AI Generated.

I don't think this is a fair video and by the reveal of the 2nd photo, I feel deceived by the video title and verbal challenge.
I got the first image guessed correctly, but knew something wasn't fair/right.
I was 50/50 on the second image and as soon as I started seeing what was done, I was angry about the whole video.
At this point, I stopped watching the video, even though now I know what the actual rules of this game are.

I remember back when PS first started to take off and we heard it'll spell the end for many areas of commercial photography, it didn't happen, then along came digital and we heard the same thing and that also wasn't the case.
Not really heard the same said about AI which is ironic because this will without doubt spell the end for many photography businesses.

It won't take too long until aI will be able to make things look completely real. That said, I dont believe ai will replace artist or photographers at any point but rather help them achieve better results with less effort. As long as we 'keep creating' as umesh said- ai will accompany us, not replace us.

4... damn...

I would suggest that no young person pays money studying for a degree in photography anymore !!

All blogers is AI generated !

6/10

Great video! AI image creation is becoming so convincing! I would love to see a video (or a series of videos) related to integrating AI image generation with real photography. For example, I currently shoot home interior products at actual model room locations in order to show the product in a typical environment. It would be incredible to able to use s studio-shot image of the product, isolate it from the solid colour background, and then use AI to generate a realistic background environment with the correct angle and lighting etc. Are there any tutorials for achieving this kind of thing online? Keep the great work!

Come and take a look at me, I have many free AI tools like this

We're living in a century of lies.

Hats Off to your new video editor. The wiggle to the camera is adding an oomph to the overall look. Adding 3D elements is a new approach. Loved the overall funky look.
And what happened to the outro. Who turned the TV off. What happened to "like the video and subscribe, and not just subscribe, ring the bell icon so that you my friend don't miss any other tips, tricks and tutorial. I would like to take this time and thank all these wonderful people from patreon....."

Dengggg....mind blowing

Can you do a video on the updated camera raw filter. It looks different from the one in your mock-up video

To be honest non of the photos here are or look "Real". A more suitable title for the video would be "Has this image been heavily Photoshopped, or is it AI generated?"

Really hard to tell what's photographed and what's generated...

I'm really glad, that photography is 'only' my hobby and I don't have to earn money with it! I guess AI will cost a lot of photo-related jobs...
Sadly, I fear, we will get more and more pseudo-perfect, but boring content.

I see copyright laws from the consumer as well as from the creator side, and they feel off. But training a commercial AI with non-free content cannot be right. Pandoras Box?

Amazing

I got 7.5/10 pretty good I guess

I heard you can do this on your own. I'd love to learn how.

My score was 3 or 4. Not bad, but not good either haha

it's definitely stealing stock photos 😅

with so many cell phones (with camera) we are F$·***K, now with AI we are DEATH 😭😭😭😭😭 ✝

Hello,Sorry, i have problem with editing flyers in photoshop,when i export the fonts are not shining and they get burn,please can you help me what to do?

Hello,Sorry, i have problem with editing flyers in photoshop,when i export the fonts are not shining and they get burn,please can you help me what to do?

Why did the camera go to therapy?

It had too many issues with its "focus," and it couldn't picture a positive frame of mind!

Could you tell us about the settings you use in photoshop? I would appreciate it very much

You need to take your MJ images into pika and animate them, Unmesh

So what’s the point of making a fake portrait of a person who doesn’t exist?

For the first one, the woman on the left has misshapen pupils and a gap splitting one of her teeth in half

Intellectual property is a heavy ANVIL on technological innovations... if it's not subtracting, it's not stealing!

This is insane!! .. I only got one correct 🤯. Ai is better than the real ones here.

Plot twist: Unmesh is also created by Ai

I scored zero

Great video, I would say that any photo that has had post processing is no longer real. Surely unless the photo is an exact capture of what the photographer is seeing, then any post processing makes it a synthetic image. AI is just a continuation of filters and Photoshop post processing.

I hit less than 50% with four correct, so I did worse than a coin toss.
I was watching on a tablet, on my monitor, maybe a little better.

There is barely any difference because AI just stealing existing images.

I hate everything about how it is passed off as real photography. Extending a studio background is one thing, but creating images from AI and passing them off as photography is appalling. It's worse now that nobody questions anything they see.

Great video and just a shame Magnific charging $40 a month, that’s ridiculous

1 is my score 😂😂

If I'm honest . Ai lack Imagination no fantasy. It's easy to pick out a briljant photographer by the trick they use so create a picutre/make a picture

I think A I really sux!!! It's totally destroying any credibility artistic photography has! photography isn't an art anymore! Photoshop was the beginning... A I is the end!!!

I'll just say that AI does NOT exist and NEVER will exist! A machine CANNOT be taught NEW concepts. It can be shown billions of images and create different ones from patterns that it sees, but it has NO idea what something is if it hasn't been shown something similar before. It's just semantics. Imitation Intelligence? Yes. Artificial Intelligence? Definitely not!

5

Ну, после того как я обработаю фото в редакторе, оно тоже будет уже не фото в полной мере, а созданной на его основе картинкой. То же делает и генератор изображений.

if your adjusting the AI that much to make it look like real then it is no longer Ai generated. and your game is a little more rigged

Had to go look it up... Heard it but never knew the name. You'd have to REALLY know that song to catch it.

0 🤣

those AI cats fall right in my uncanny valley. The eyes look super weird. i could tell in seconds which ones were fake. but with the locations and products not at all 😅
damn, that middle cat gives me the creeps please do never ever show it again 🤣

And what is the use of creating all these fake pictures? Unless the world you want to live in is all fake? What is the use? Advertising an AI generated burger would be a lie, as many other living things that were generated by AI.