Комментарии:
Fun fact, English school year starts in September not July.
ОтветитьWhat if Dumbledore never gave Ron the Deluminator?
ОтветитьI think that the curse on the dark arts teacher was a big factor in how dumbledore chose what teachers would be there and when. That definitely needs to be thought about when wondering why he let the ministry pick that year.
ОтветитьAwesone!!! Yet I cannot help but imagine the smile on JK;s face being similar to the smile a great artist would give when hearing people pontificate meanings into their painting that they never intended. No matter, for it is the meaning we derive that satisfies us. Top job!!!
ОтветитьOkay this may sound like a dumb question, but when Hagrid brings Harry to the dursleys, doesn't he say that he got the flying bike from sirius black? Would that raise red flags for Dumbledore that sirius didn't betray the potters? I love this whole channel and I love learning and teaching my husband and daughter more lore!!
ОтветитьYes I love Google auto fill. I still have an inside joke with my cousin about how you pronounced Sasuke
ОтветитьI looked it up cause I was curious, a peacock can cost up to $2000 depending on breed
Ответить"I will not allow you to MANHANDLE my students!"
One of Dumbledore's all time most amazing lines ever.
Dojt forget about Dumbledore unequivocally informing McGonagall that Harry NEEDS to be away from the wizarding world until the time is ready.
"Famous before he can talk and walk, famous for something he wont remember. Its enough to turn any boy's head"
Dumbledore wants to be certain that harry wont grow up to become a bighead like james.
Or Percy.
("Its for you perc. And there's going to be flags with HB on the hoods. For Humongous Bighead."
Honesly one of my favorite lines ever)
What if Harry told Dumbledore about hearing the voices in the walls???? Would the story play out the same or would there have been something different happening??
Ответить“Help will always be given at Hogwarts to those who ask for it”
-Albus Dumbledore
Idk... some of the circumstances mentioned are probably like Joseph Joestar rolling with the situation, not exactly thinking so far ahead but taking absolute credit for them.
ОтветитьChoosing the weasleys btw probably has something to do with their family having a direct connection to the administration of hogwarts. Ik it's a later add on but it still applies
ОтветитьMolly Weasley as the Defense Against the Dark Arts Teacher would have been a DISASTER, in my opinion. Don't get me wrong, I love her but she would have been coddling every single student, especially Harry and her children that they wouldn't really gain sufficient knowledge and skills from her lessons.
ОтветитьWho's hairy?
Ответитьis no one going to talk about how dumbledore practically screwed over every one with owls and newts in harrys 2nd andfifth year by hiring the 2 worst dada teachers like even harry was better
ОтветитьThe seats at the quidditch world cup are not the best in the stadium. They are arguably the worst. The Malfoys are sitting with Fudge in his box, which should in theory be the best in the house. Unless the books state that they are the best in the stadium, which I certainly don't remember, getting those tickets is exactly what you said, basically giving them away.
Ответитьanyone else get the toilet paper ad during the bathroom break?😂
Ответить1 big 2 hr long CONVENIENT video..
Ответитьbad logic
ОтветитьI love this so much! ❤
ОтветитьNext to Dumbledore Molly Weasley was the worst! She didn’t see Harry for himself, she saw him as she wanted to see him. She had this idea of who she thought Harry should be & tried to force him into this role. She was willing to hurt Hermione for this image. & Hermione never brings it up?! What the actual heck?! How did Hermione marry into that mess?
ОтветитьI think the reason the number of the platform comes up is a Question to the weasly children to see if they know it, which of course they do
ОтветитьHonestly love how well Jay forgetting that he wore the same green shirt three videos in a row worked out for this compilation lol
ОтветитьUnclear of your ending here. Was there any scenario where Voldemort "could' have killed Harry? By not using a wand? Was Harry's victory guaranteed? Straighten me out.
Ответить“Hey Harry, so there’s a prophecy that concerns you, and in order for me to tell you about it, it’s best for you to learn how to block out Voldemort mentally. Once you’re able to accomplish this, you’ll learn what the prophecy is. Until then, you’ll most likely be provoked to go to the Ministry to find it.”
“Oh, by the way Harry. Remember the package.” - Snuffles
Like. Sirius could be alive but nooooo people are too clever for their own good.
I always like to think that Dumbledore expected that they would bring Neville with them to get the Stone because Harry was also quite friendly with Neville during the year. With Neville's aptitude for Herbology he would have easily got them past the Devil's Snare but it was the only task that they all panicked over until Hermione figured it out. He knew Neville was involved at the start because he also gave Neville house points for standing up to the trio.
ОтветитьAm I missing something? Why does he constantly say aberforths name wrong?
ОтветитьI still love this theory because it's so supported it's basically fact. Just awesome
ОтветитьLong story short: Dumbledore knew he couldn't destroy Tom, so he did his best to set Harry up for Success... good guy
ОтветитьPeacocks are actually only about £25 pound plus (don't know how much that would be in dollars) depending on the breed, so compared to some other types of pet birds they are relatively cheap.
ОтветитьBen and Jay! We need you to make a version where Dobby doesn't die, please? 😍 It always makes me cry and would be so happy if you make a world where he's still alive 😊
ОтветитьI knew this video would be fantastic so I liked at the moment the first topic rolled.
ОтветитьLoved the video, thanks. I hate the way you say bogart.
ОтветитьI absolutely think the Deathly Hallows were always a contingency for his plan. Individually, they were all means to protect or aid Harry but together, they were a backup plan to help Harry survive, in case the blood thing didn't
ОтветитьHonestly the whole Molly Weasley not knowing what platform number the hogwarts express is at is more likely just bad writing than anything else lol
ОтветитьDo you record the script in two halves? Or do you record each line then move the chair. IT ISN'T AUTISM FRIENDLY
ОтветитьHarry didn't die at the end because voldermort had Harry's blood in him which tethered him to the living world, whether Harry meant to die or not Harry would have survived. Only his Horcrux was killed. What would have been different if Harry didn't mean to die was that the other students would have lacked Harry's sacrificial protection.
ОтветитьDumbledore cannot be testing Harry to see if he has the guts to face voldemort in the Sorcerer's Stone because Harry does not know that he is going to face voldemort, He actually thinks he is going to find snape
Ответитьcan you make a vidoe of if mundunges was killed and mab eye was noy
ОтветитьI wonder what would have happened if Tom Riddle would have become the darks art teacher?
ОтветитьObviously we got confirmation that it was Moody (Crouch Jr) that put Harry's name in the Goblet of Fire but I wouldn't have been surprised if it had been Dumbledore, as another way to train Harry
ОтветитьSo a problem with book 3 theory Harry wouldnt need to stay with the Durselys to stay safe if the Weasleys didn't go to egypt so Dumbledor wouldn't have suggested the trip as an excuse to keep harry with the Dursleys.
ОтветитьI'm sure someone has brought this to your attention already, but the Weasleys went to Romania to visit Charlie not Egypt to visit Bill, at Christmas in the first book. I know you do a lot of research but you also make a lot of mistakes too.
ОтветитьYour channel has really made me love the character of Dumbledore, more then perhaps any other wizard in any franchise.
Ответить