Red Dead Redemption 2 Easter Egg - The Strange Man

He's an accountant of sorts

I have to much ARThur …..

Nestan

Herbert Moon loves himself so much he named his daughter Herbeta

He didn't sppear behind me but the picture was done.
Why was that?

I remember i was just strolling around with my horse and found the cabin i wasn't sure if i already visited it but when i looked at the mirror i literally jumped outta my seat when i saw the strange man behind me, so i ran outside and got eaten by a gator

Fun fact if you visit this location in online you can find a tarot card and and a bottle of London dry gin

I love the detail that the painting becomes more and more complete as time passes. It's as if the game is telling you that your death is approaching.

this is creepy as fuck

The strange man is a mark by God by killing his brother able he will walk this earth for eternity

Than why he act like he never saw him in rdr1

I always thought he was Josiah Trelawny, but i was wrong.

The Strange Man Is G-Man

Theres a detail you forgot: the blind man saying something like " there are 2 evil men after you, one from this world, one from another" ( Micah and The Strange Man)

Idk why but I think I really hate myself cause i always watch or rewatch stuff that scares me or gives me fear/anxiety. But damn this actually makes me curious about the strange man even more 🥺🧐🤔🙃

This is where John knows Strange Man from!

I went to the cabin today and I genuinely felt like I was being watched through the game or something

I'm not expecting an answer after three years, but I gotta ask just in case: what was the background music for this video? It's amazing.

To this day i cant believe this game didnt win GOTY, altho it got a lot of awards i still think that RDR2 should've won instead of GOW.

Y’all how long do you have to wait to visit the strange man again Like how many days in single player do you have to wait

Red dead 2 had some of the best Easter Eggs I've seen.

The layers on this game are insane

Is the music in game?

this is creepy as fuck holy shit

Is it possible to inspect it as Arthur?

What I noticed besides what everyone else has already mentioned.

1- raven posed exactly the same as the witches cauldron

2- candles like the alter in the ufo house with all the dead ppl

3- hanging bottles on the front step like the hanging bottle tree near valentine

4- flowers outside match flowers outside Lagras tackle shop

Some of you don't know but this strange man can be found in Bully in the house of the freaks

This is creepy as fuck😰

Anyone just have that one dude in hide n seek that gets caught and says “I’m not playing” DA F YOU IN A TIRE THEN?

Great, now I gotta load the game up and go down this rabbit hole 😅

What's the music

What's the music

Isaac is the name of Arthur son's no?

I do have a theory he's a victim of blackwater masacar or the grim riper

To complete the painting do you need a 100% on everything all animals studies and items etc

The venom statement could also refer to the mission American Venom where John hunts down Micah and kickstarts the chain of events that lead to the first game

Is it me or every time your near the cabin, your horse runs away

is that supposed to be jack swift? they look similar

It’s Lucifer himself.

Absolutely miraculous world building, can’t believe these guys just put out the gta trilogy after being known for such attention to detail

So the phrases carved in random dressers throughout the game were really left by the Stranger?

He's Death. Don't know what his deal was with Herbert, but by some mediums' standards, Death makes deals. I don't know if that's the case with Herbert, but I always speculated he's more fascinated with John because John was there during the infamous ferry heist. It's also worth noting the difference in poems depending on what you do to Jimmy Brooks.

The moon will shine on in the darkness = maybe Herbert Moon

You should have brought John as well into that cabin

>walks into shack
>first item to pick up
>"potent snake oil."
>h m m m m m