Комментарии:
30,000 Frenchmen, 14,000 Englishmen , sounds like the French are outnumbered to me 😅😅😅
ОтветитьThose actors are not archers. 10 pound bows! The real archers shot bows from 70 to 210 pounds. Deadly fellas in a bar brawl!
ОтветитьWow, with the complete lack of facts I thought I was watching the History Channel
ОтветитьYou don’t draw a longbow like that! The reconstruction isn’t even on the same battlefield! Garbage!
ОтветитьHow? How can anyone - in less than 2.5 minutes - make so many glaring mistakes? I’m gobsmacked…….. even the bloke who said “…..the longbow isn’t an accurate weapon” was either edited badly or has no knowledge of the longbow. Yes accuracy was surrendered to volume in volleys, but in the right, trained over years hands, it was - and still is - an accurate tool.
Poor show. Poor show indeed….
Hideously inaccurate depiction of how to shoot a heavy bow.
ОтветитьThe king on Netflix?
ОтветитьWhy is an English longbowman using a thumb draw?
ОтветитьCannot discount the role the muddy fields they were negotiating in slowed, basically forestalled the French army too. Bogging down horses and riders. Making them easy targets for the English bowmen.
Ответить12 arrows every minute at 150 mph, 300FPS up to 300 yards. . get some of that Frenchie,
ОтветитьWhy do the French have the arms of the Holy Roman Empire there? Come on Smithsonian, you can do better than that.
ОтветитьI think the longbowmen practiced more than many of the opposing swordmen, they had to by english law.
ОтветитьSaturated fire used for years to come
ОтветитьInteresting to mention all french prisoners were killed...disrespecting the rules of battle....
Ответитьit didn't cut down the french and the french won. First of all, the hundred year war wasn't English vs French, it was Armaniacs French vs Burgundian French and English mecenaries hired by Burgundy. And it is French Burgundy that won the war and at the end, Burgundy even turned its crossbows against England who lost its usefulness and destroyed the English longbow army so badly that the English had to run back to their isolated island. Making Burgundy the wealthiest and most powerful nation of medieval Europe. Burgundy today is Eastern France.
ОтветитьWie? Des wars jez schon oder was?
ОтветитьGood summary but It’s shame you could have gotten the coat of arms right , the black Double headed eagle on yellow background is the German Imperial standard , the French had golden fleur de Lys on blue background
ОтветитьWhat's wrong with this is the idea of loosing arrows into the sky wlly nilly. At Cressy, Poitiers and Azincourt, the English tactic was to advance to about 150 yards from the massed French mounted knights, then either dig ankle breakers (holes) or plant stakes, to about 30 yards out. As the English always occupied the hig ground in those battles, they waited until the French charged. At 100 yards the English loosed straight into the front rank of French knights. As they went down, taking the second rank and some of the third with them, the second English volley was loosed into the third and fourth ranks. All three battles were fought after very wet weather, so the field was muddy and sodden. After two or three volleys, the English archers pounced forward and knifed the helpless Frenchmen caught under their dead or dying horses. Then they returned to their ranks to await the next charge. As you can see, this video is hopelessly wrong.😊
ОтветитьFun fact: Skeletons of longbow archers can be identified based off how their shooting arm developed compared to the other arm.
ОтветитьBattle of Agincourt in 1314 was the first major battle of the Hundred Years War.
ОтветитьThe guy in the thumbnail is using a pinch grip, which means his particular bow was 20# max....
ОтветитьJust to correct the expert you do not fire arrows, there is no gunpowder involved as in firearms an arrow is loosed, released, shot never fired.
ОтветитьBased English
ОтветитьRe: the thumbnail. Longbowmen wouldn’t have had chainmail. They were commoners.
ОтветитьLiterally everything about this video is incorrect, but I have no time to address it.
ОтветитьThis is also where "flipping the bird" came from. Without your middle finger you can't draw the bow. The French, certain of a victory said they would cut off the middle finger of every English bowman after the battle. But thats not what happened. So therefore after the English achieved victory, they all raised their middle fingers at the French. To show they coyld still shoot their arrows or flip the bird.
ОтветитьWhy they are not fighting again 😢
ОтветитьHow would the long-bow stack up against the recurved composite bow popular on the Asiatic Steppes?
ОтветитьThe English won the battle but the french won the war, and kicked the invaders out .
ОтветитьThose arrows are going as fast or even faster than a Major League fastball too.
ОтветитьThe filmillustrations of this video were “more than creative” (for one claiming to be a documentary) to say the least: German knights posing as French, and English longbowmen shooting with thumb release (i.e. Asian and/or Near Eastern style), later wearing Templar cross...😤🤪
ОтветитьEngland was basicly a French colony at the time, being conqered and ruled by the Normands for many years, but AngloAmerican propaganda runs the net.
ОтветитьArrows fallimg down on people
Didnt The british shoot their Longbows right at you?
Just because the tactic isn't one of precision doesn't mean the weapon isn't capable of it.
Ответитьthe whole english longbow subject is as boring as ... please help me !
ОтветитьYep. And if you didn't die from the initial hit, the infection from them pissing on the ground where they stuck their arrows would, eventually... no next battle.
ОтветитьWe already know those informations. Where is the more rare information? It's just an explanation of bowmen. No questions answered.
ОтветитьThose are german not french
ОтветитьFought for just ego, finally what did they achieve? ( England Vs.France)
ОтветитьEr... "Welsh" longbow!
ОтветитьWrong 180lds of force to pull a bow lool every museum iv been to here in England always say the same to reach the distance would need a minimum of 180ld but these guys was doing it day in day out
ОтветитьInteresting comments, the Longbow was used for years, why? It must have been an effective weapon, whatever it's faults, simple as that!
ОтветитьBowmen,ready!!Always against French Frogs
ОтветитьHa there's a lot of quantative data here. 35000 arrows a minute sounds dubious. How many arrows can a man carry? How many can an army make and carry?
ОтветитьVirtually nothing here was accurate.
ОтветитьThis seems to be a pattern with the English and French. The English attack with numerically inferior forces, the French think it's an automatic win and get cocky, then they get their teeth kicked in by archers firing massive volleys of arrows
ОтветитьAlso if the French caught one of our boys with a longbow they would cut off those 2 fingers. The English would taunt the French by sticking up those two fingers at them.
ОтветитьThe fact I am dealing with trick shot archers, those who do archery for sport and didn't know this basic info is baffling.
ОтветитьYet again unhistorical armour without any padding underneath.
Ответить