This is what Tarantino HATED about 1917 Movie

Bill - ego driven rubbish

Bill obviously hasn’t heard of the Harlem hellfighters

tarantino thinking wolfenstien is abt nazi werewolves😂

Imagine the incomprehensible amount of interruptions and over talking that would occur if Bill Maher and Neil Degrasse Tyson had a conversation.

So ignorant in WWI you had Africa they fought for the colonies not just in the trenches you doltz.

WW1 had a lot of participation by non-whites from French and British colonies.

1917 won the DGA award for Best Director in 2019, but "Joker" and "Once Upon A Time In Hollywood" were better movies.

THIS IS PURE ANGUISH LET EACH OTHER TALK

Maher loves cuts so much he cut off Tarantino

Boiling point was done in one take ... without cgi ...
I think??

Every cuts in 1917 is so obvious for a professional editor 😂

Some one needs to tell Quentin that Once Upon A Time in Hollywood was overrated.

I thought it was a pretty shit movie, the cinematography was excellent, but the story and script was terrible, only redeemed by the 'based on a true story'

The Hateful Eight is the best Tarantino movie... change my mind.

Inglorious basterds is a close second.

You know how 1917 isnt a good movie the only thing people talk about it for are its technical achievements. Not its story, not its characters, not its themes, all it has is its long cuts.

Rope is so much more difficult from a storytelling, acting, and blocking perspective.

Also Maher is such a kissup blowhard that this was borderline unbearable.

Ok love QT’s passion for film but it’s as JA can’t get a word in

Judd Apatow didn't say a single thing in 8 minutes, fifteen seconds

The Harlem Hellfighters & other African American soldiers were in WWI. Wtf.

What's the common thread in these things... Bill Maher talks over absolutely everybody...Even Quentin Tarantino on the topic of movies.

I know people in Hollywood don't give a fuck about history, or reality in some cases, but anyways, there were hundreds of thousands of Blacks and Africans who served during WWI, several hundred thousand were combatants in Europe.
I'm kind of surprised Quentin did not know that. The lack of knowledge Bill demonstrates never surprises me though. For more than 20 years Bill has been told what to believe and think. Though recently he has claimed some of his views have changed, I haven't seen him genuinely apologize to any of his previous guests who he has mocked and talked down to.

worst movie ever zzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz but the 1917 movie was decent

so what was your excuse quentin? cos outih was as boring a film as I have ever seen

the worst fucking conversation ever dear lord

I would give my yearly salary to watch Quentin talk with Jordan Peterson

The movie was so boring it was just two soldier trying to deliver a fucking message to the other squad bruh 😪

I really hate this line of thinking. Just because you made something that is difficult to make (long cuts in our case) DOESN'T mean that it's automatically good. There has to be a point to do something like that, like the perfect example Tarantino mentioned with Hitchcock, where the one cut MATTERS. Hitchcock didn't make a movie with long cuts just for the sake of it. 1917 on the other hand did that as a marketing trick. There was no purpose for the long cuts. They did it for the sake of doing it. That has no value in my opinion. 1917 would have been exactly the same if they didn't have long cuts. Same story, same characters, same drama, same action. The long cuts serve no purpose other than to trick the average movie viewer into thinking the movie is special.

jesus christ bill shut up for 2 seconds... what are you doing?

The hell they are talking abot cuts. The film just manages to create an atmosphere like you are with the main character and it has an insane climax. The whole "no cuts" stuff just lets you feel the intesity of the whole story + the feelings of the main character. It's just brilliant story telling. Who dafuq gives a shit how much cuts he made.

Bill Maher is the guy in the bar you try to get away from when he starts loud-talking you all about your job after he asks what you do for a living.

I would never argue with QT about movies. He knows it all and more than anyone. Id prefer to listen and learn

George, Bunggle and of course Zippy 🎉
Welcome to the Rainbow 🌈 show !
😅😅😅😅😅😅

The Interrupter

Not cutting in a film isn't interesting at all. It's like music with no sound.

More than 380,000 African-Americans,12,000 Native Americans, and 200,000 Hispanic Americans served in the Army during World War I, 18 percent of the military at that time was foreign born, so plenty of chances for diversity in that conflict. I realize 1917 was about two British soldiers and that's a fair point, but they laughed at the notion that there was diversity in that war as if it was obvious there was none, which isn't actually true.

Maher is such a crawfishing worm

AFRICAN AMERICANS FOUGHT IN EVERY WAR FOR OUR COUNTRY! WE FOUGHT WITH FRENCH AGAINST GERMANY! 700K REGISTERED, 350K+ SERVED IN SEGREGATED UNITS. BM IS IGNORANT ASSHAT.

1917 is nothing like wolfinstine

Whitewashing the first world war as if the British empire didn't send Indian troops to the front. As if the Americans didn't send black troops to the front. Bill Maher is so cringey.

-"How can something look like theres no cut and have a cut?"

Wow was he born in 1901?

Is 1917 the movie were they keep cutting back to the starving men that are eating like animals or was that Quit on the western front either way we get it how many times are you going to drive home there was nothing to eat 5 or 6 different scenes

Tarantino does have a point, many movies lately really tend to take shortcuts or do such minimal effort to justify its existent. Every comedy movie is so safe its hard to get any real reaction if its not done by people who have been in comedy for a long time. Horror movies rely on cheap jump scares and paper thin character development. The only movies that can really kill it anymore are action and animated.

Bill tooo chatty

The opening thoughts really make understand that they know nothing of the Great War

“People of color couldn’t get into ww1”
Yeah because the Ottoman Empire and Autro-Hungarian empire were toooootally white armies. (Sarcasm)

Bill maher is so annoying

Imagine lecturing Quentin Tarantino on film directing and editing.

bullshit talker

A legendary director can't explain because the big mouth opinionator doesn't stop talking

what do you mean people of color weren't in WW1? dude, I may have just googled this, but 171 African Americans were awarded the French Legion of Honor, not to mention ALL the warfare between the colonial at the time. Compared to Caucasians , that's not a lot, but to say they WEREN'T a part AT ALL?

Bill's too high or he doesn't know his history. Britain, France, and Germany were colonial powers who conscripted subjects from all over the world.There was millions of people of from india, africa, and the west indies who fought in WWI.