Abigail Requesting $5 - Red Dead Redemption 2 Item Request

“Playing with jack” thats sus

Uncle: you sus baka!

I got this request at 8.20am, fishing with Jack complete but he hasn't asked me for a thimble yet.

I’m doing a true completionists run meaning I made spreadsheets of every weapon request activity you name it and this is all I have left for chapter 2 can someone please help me get this request. And my next story mission in the last one

Arthur when I gave her $5: here I got a little will 5 do?

meanwhile he has $2600 in his bag

Tested on the latest version. John has to be out of the camp, meaning the mission pouring forth oil 4 has to be available and the fisher of men mission must be completed and this request becomes available between 9 a.m. and noon.

Im in chapter 3 how?

Uncle make a face “can i have some too?” 🤣🤣

This is becoming frustrating. I'm starting another playtrough only because Abigail don't make the request... and i already did the game chalenge 8.

Where’s the location though???

I lost my chances coz I just 60 cents on my pocket. It's make me feel like want to restart all the game. Sory for bad English tho

I can't

Im past the fishing quest and near to the end of chapter 2 but i can't get this to trigger. I've tried everything.