Комментарии:
Starting it right now!
ОтветитьWhy is it so extremely hard to find a way to watch this or any of these fan edits by simply being able to find a streaming version or download link to download to a phone? I am extremely frustrated to now just finding out all these fan editions exist but not a one of them make it easy to be able to watch through streaming or download links.
ОтветитьHey. Would it be okay for someone who hasnt experienced the trilogy to watch this edit anyways? I don't own the official copies but they do sit in my Prime subscription. I planned to watch it with my family after we finished LotR but I'm not sure that'd be a good idea lol
ОтветитьI have no peers to help me with downloading the dvd.iso torrent and the direct download doesn't work either because you have to pay to use it.
EDIT: I got one peer now thank you, I will seed as long as I can.
EDIT2: They're gone now. :..(
EDIT3: PLease I'm at 80% done, I just want to see the hobbit in all of it's glory.
EDIT: fuck it, why bother
Where am I supposed to watch this legally?
ОтветитьI’m dying to watch this. I was backpacking SE Asia when part one came to theaters. I took a 16 hour bus and a ferry to get to a theater for opening night. I can’t explain my utter dismay/shock/disappointment at how terrible the film was. I waited years to watch the others and they were even worse than I suspected. I watched The Bilbo Edit and it was everything I’d hoped Jackson’s would be. I’ve heard this is even better. Is there anywhere I can watch on my phone?
ОтветитьThis is the version that I will typically watch and I'll watch the theatrical versions (minus botfa) when I watch the extended versions of lotr which don't actually too often. I watch them when I really want to get lost in middle earth.
Hobbit trilogy: 7/10
Hobbit fan edit: 8/10 at least at this point.
Just needs the beards.
ОтветитьI really don't understand why so many people hate on the Hobbit.
ОтветитьKeep the torrent alive brothers!
Ответитьi cannot access the site to watch/download the film, is it still available?
Ответитьsooo how come the link doesn't work?
ОтветитьThank you so much for not only this amazing edit, but providing the .iso files and cover art! J.R.R. Tolkien's The Hobbit sits gorgeously next to my Lord of the Rings boxset, and, as with many others, is now a part of my annual marathon. Can't thank y'all enough!
ОтветитьI watch this before watching the extended edition of The Lord of the Rings. Great job on this.
ОтветитьI think I am one of the people who like The Hobbit Trilogy more then The Rings Trilogy.
ОтветитьI'm so glad this exists! A four hour, nonstop adaptation of The Hobbit to me is THE WAY the film should've been made. So sad that even artists like Guillermo and Peter can get fucked over by the scumbags in the movie business.
ОтветитьI'm so glad this exists! A four hour, nonstop adaptation of The Hobbit to me is THE WAY the film should've been made. So sad that even artists like Guillermo and Peter can get fucked over by the scumbags in the movie business.
ОтветитьHoly SNAP. My least favorite part of the originals was how long the battle was at the end, you managed to not only shorten it, but still maintain a cohesive scene. The way you managed to cut between Fili and Kili works so well. I’m trying to download the edit now so I can add it to my frequent rewatched of the LotR trilogy
ОтветитьThank you for your work finally i can enjoy the hobbit trilogy without some stupid changes
ОтветитьI just want to say me and my dad love this fan edit and we appreciate all the hard work you did to make it happen
ОтветитьGreat edit, this was mostly what I've been looking for for a long time. A few things I would have kept would have been the stone giant scene, I just thought that part being cut out looked odd. I also would have kept the scene from Laketown in the extended version where Bilbo says "Thorin Oakenshield keeps his word," to me that scene just cements those two's friendship. Also even though the scene where the dwarves are struggling to find the keyhole, though a little drawn out, I felt it was necessarily drawn out and should have been left in.
Overall it was a great edit, the transitions were great, the pacing was amazing. Oh and the use of the original Hobbit theme at the end battle when Thorin charges the orcs made me cheer out loud, that was something I didn't expect and really appreciated. Thank you, this will be the version of the Hobbit I will watch for the rest of my life.
next fan made, the lord of the rings
ОтветитьJust curious to get everyone’s reccomendation of which I should watch right now. The cardinal cut or the tolkien cut? Which do you all prefer and why?
ОтветитьI've been looking to rewatch all of the Jackson films but with this instead for years. I think I'm gonna finally do it and Ive heard this is the best edit. Side note: Looking at your website I actually found out we went to the same high school. My sister and your sister were like besties at Stafford. Anyways. Congrats on your work my man.
ОтветитьYou know what would be cool but a lot of work
If you used some sort of software/programs to make some of the character’s appearances better like de-age Ian McKellen to look like he did during the lord of the rings (Ian McKellan still looks good but he is obviously older) and make Thorin older and look actually like a Dwarf
Thorin is meant to be the oldest Dwarf in the company but looks like one of the youngest and him, Kili and Fili just look like regular men
Is there by any chance any possibility to have Greek dialogues also? It would be great!!
ОтветитьThis cut is the new cannon. I do not care. It definitely is the way to watch the hobbit.
ОтветитьCan I get a link to the full movie pls
ОтветитьI just saw your complete edit and enjoy it, in perfect HD and amazing 5.1! I always thought what The Hobbit would be like if I reassembled it by following the book and removing everything that had nothing to do with it and spoiled it; although I was always lazy, and I recently discovered this project that successfully made it. So congratulations and a thousand thanks for making me enjoy this way and giving me the definitive and perfect work.
ОтветитьI remember how disappointed I was after seeing auj in theatres and the jarring way it was filmed along with the overuse of cgi. I'm about half an hour into your edit and I'm enjoying it 100% more than I ever had, I'm excited to finish this whole edit and have a Hobbit film that I can actually watch and enjoy rather than the actual Hobbit trilogy which has always made me feel hollow. I'm not expecting a LOTR because nothing can come close to that but its already amazing that I am enjoying this edit as I really am no fan of the Hobbit trilogy films.
ОтветитьI just finished watching this edit of the movie, and WOW! It's incredible! I absolutely love it! Thanks Maple Films, for your great work!
ОтветитьThis is the absolutely best The Hobbit out there. Finally I can enjoy it!
Ответитьi love this movies soooo muchhhh
ОтветитьI just watched this work, simply fantastic, the only version I'll watch now, I was very happy to have it with Portuguese subtitles, it would be a dream to have a dubbed version
ОтветитьWhere can I find Danish subtitles for my kids?
ОтветитьThis has become the only way I can watch director Peter Jackson's vision of The Hobbit. It is now part of my Middle-earth movie marathon (in place of the overstretched Hobbit movie trilogy). It's so nice to experience it as one film with all of the side-quests, most of the unnecessary characters, and many of the silly CGI moments omitted. Truly a remarkable improvement presented in great HD quality and closer to what a Hobbit movie should have been. It is well edited and J.R.R. Tolkien's The Hobbit is more faithful to author J.R.R. Tolkien's source material. I highly recommend this film-edit to anyone who was disappointed with the The Hobbit movie trilogy like I was. Thank you Maple Films!
ОтветитьThe original just bored me to death, I thought my ass would grow roots in my chair as I sat and watched with growing disbelief how far from Tolkiens story it was. This restores Tolkiens story to the best that can be done without access to all of the material and is a better job than what the studios put out, its now closer to what it was probably intended to be and watchable, better colour, better editing, more coherent, less boring if that's possible, more entertaining, it's what it's supposed to be a fairy tale prequel to the Lord of the rings and not an epic for epics sake. So nobody should fall asleep watching this edit or worry about having to shave due to the length of the film, it's just right and your kids can watch it too and enjoy it for what it was supposed to be and they won't have grown up and gone to uni before it's over! Great job, well done by a Tolkien fan who strangely has technological ability as well as enthusiasm for folklore , very happy, very pleased with this cut. I highly recommend it as a Christmass film, Christmass eve, glass of port, put your feet up a roaring fire and the kids entranced. I guess it made a hobbit of me and restored my faith for a moment, I'll get to be a kid myself again and share their pleasure at least to the 25th of December. Its a happy edit and that's all it needs to be. T
ОтветитьCardinal cut video made me come here, which one is better :O?
ОтветитьI just finished the edit and wow. Really solid work. I once hated these films, but this helped me to love them. Thank you.
ОтветитьSo what are the main cuts from the film? I've seen my fair share of fan made films of the Hobbit. Why is yours any better? Just curious.
ОтветитьCorrect me if I'm wrong, but did you also alter the soundtrack in some scenes? If I recall, the scene where they're attacked by the wolves and orcs used the Nazgul theme which made no sense, but when I watched your cut it used a different theme.
ОтветитьI mean, you're never gonna be able to get rid of the distracting cgi and overall saturated artificial look, but at least we have a version that's watchable lol.
ОтветитьI just learned about this and im so excited to watch it with my bf! It will be his first time watching the hobbit so i wanna do it right
ОтветитьThe Hobbit movies are in no way BAD films, but really don’t stack up when compared to the source material. A whole lot of stuff was added that didn’t need to be, and it’s hard to justify a lot of the fluff.
ОтветитьWhere can I watch the edit?
ОтветитьWhere can I watch this?
ОтветитьJust wanna say I watched your edit for the second time last weekend with my 60 year old father and we both loved it. Your edit really does elevate the films into a masterpiece. Like another user said, it now sits in a USB stick I pull out whenever revisiting the Lord of the Rings movies.
ОтветитьAnyone here from OSW's Hobbit review?
ОтветитьThe only downside to the fan edit is it renders your blu ray copies of The Hobbit trilogy useless.
ОтветитьThree words: less is more.
Ответить