Комментарии:
Apocalypse Now version? Schoolgirls don’t surf!!!
ОтветитьHave any of you ever been to Hanging Rock? It's about as foreboding as a turnip.......
ОтветитьIs there any explanation as to why on Earth three young and sound girls disappeared so completely from the scene?... Any continuation?... Any investigation?... I presume there is at least a bit of truth in this story. Perhaps there is at least one more chapter added by the Author to her story with some explanation. I am much interested in what finally happened to Miranda and colleagues. Is there that mythical second volume of the 'Picnic'? Or is it but an urban legend? 😊😊♍♍👍👍
ОтветитьDespite loving the original movie and the book, I can say I really enjoyed this miniseries.
People are so dramatic in the comments, it was not supposed to challenge or replace the original, it was another adaptation of the book. I'm glad the original movie got more attention thanks to this and more room for discussion. It was nice to revisit the Hanging rock in another version!
A remake is being shown at a film festival? Don't they usually focus their attention on new and original films? Artistic integrity is sorta dead now, isn't it?
ОтветитьJust binged it on Binge, I still don't get what happened, it was great though.
ОтветитьAn adaption that didn't work due to inevitable comparisons with a superior version.
ОтветитьIt is not even nearly as good as original. Who would dare to remake perfection? It only looks foolish.
ОтветитьThis looks awful the original was fine
ОтветитьProbably a sham
ОтветитьHey all, I just wanted to say that this is my favourite series and to give it a chance because, oh my goodness, will it tug at your heartstrings.
I'm a 23 year old Australian woman and this book/movie/series is so fascinating and magical to me.
This show is perfection.
I came here to express my utmost disapproval for Dora Lumley resident Karen god i hated her she is such a cunt
Ответитьlet's see, "burning crosses, empowered lesbian witchy crap"....looks pretty "Woke".....PASS
ОтветитьThey were wrong to cast Appleyard so young
ОтветитьThe only reason I like the original is it’s recorded in the 70s so the cameras and audio they used made it really feel as if they were in the 1900s era despite they didn’t have colourised cameras but it just had that nostalgic old feeling that I can’t explain.
Ответитьcan anyone please tell me the song name
ОтветитьAn example how an incident which became folklore in Australia can now become an over-commercialised horror story just for the benefit of it's backers and the front office. Nicely done but personally i think in bad taste. I wonder, if any of those actually affected by this incident in 1900 knew it would eventually become selected as the latest round in what passes for modern entertainment in the questionable 21st. Century....i wonder what they would make of it. Poor old Mrs. Appleyard who wanted nothing but the best for her girls and who lost everything so much that she eventually committed suicide after main hullballoo had finished up amongst the rocks of the title....i wonder what she would have made if it. Then again, it could be said that the public must have their fun and nothing should get in the way of commerce (what do i know).
ОтветитьFor those saying “We don’t need a remake! The original was better!” Firstly, it’s not technically a remake. In another adaptation of the book. Furthermore, it’s a mini tv series rather than a film. I like the original and I like this series. The series wasn’t trying to adapt from the movie, rather a reimagining of the book.
It’s like with the recent IT films. They weren’t a remake of the original tv mini series, it was a new adaptation of the book.
Watched this series recently and loved it, mostly because of the character Albert, played beautifully by James Hoare. What a great talent he is. Stunning scenery too.
ОтветитьI'm from Iran and I loveeeeeeeeee it
ОтветитьJim Morrison makes anything more appealing
ОтветитьThere is NO substitute for the original.
I wouldn’t even consider watching a remake.
Not interested at all in this.
ОтветитьYou can't remake perfection.
Picnic at Hanging Rock is my favourite Australian film. 10/10, and should never have been touched.
Why don't you remake Citizen Kane while you're at it?
Looks rubbish.
ОтветитьSo they turned the headmistress into an evil villain and removed all semblance of subtlety from the original?
No thanks.
I watched the original last night. I was really hoping to find some decent reviews online. No luck.
But it was dated. Going to watch this later.
I ended up liking this way more than I thought I would. I think switching around character motivations and stories helped. Marion was the kindest, Miranda was troubled, Irma was more snooty but also desperate to find a home, Sarah was younger and more like everyone's sister while she wanted to find her brother, Mrs. Appleyard was not a lesbian like so many fans have thought but a social climber who wanted her man, like a meaner version of the French teacher, who wanted what most modern women have.
The guys, I wish I could have had more answers about if they were romantic or not. Marion's story with her teacher was just so obvious and we spend more time feeling for her.
I did think somethings like how sexual the scene between two straight girls kissing got were strange, but I think it was also to give them this close moment. In the original movie, I always had this idea Irma and Miranda were best friends, parallel pretty girls and Irma wanted Miranda's perfect girl label but also loved her too much to take her crown and it was more painful that she was gone for that reason.
I've got the 1975 version. I'll stick with that.
ОтветитьAbsolutely meaningless adaptation
ОтветитьLady Lindsay wrote a fictitious story.
I really think it's a cover up story that really took place in the early 1960s and the young puberty ladies and the female teacher wanted the game to end as they had been in that game for many years.
No trace of them.
Fast asleep.
What kind of dress is the white?what does it called?
ОтветитьAfter watching the beloved original, I was curious about the remake. After watching the trailer, I'm no longer curious about the remake.
ОтветитьNo no no
ОтветитьThere is only one Miranda, Anne Lambert.
ОтветитьWell, this looks pointless.
Ответитьno mention of the original movie? no mention of the book that was based from?
Something tells me this film may have gone woke as fuck. but... I shall see when I get around to watching this "remake"
Did these people even think about what they were doing? What a piece of crap! They should be embarassed and the producers prohibited from making further films. The original has mystery, atmosphere and was simply a truly great film. This is worse than bad from script to actor. If you had anything to do with it I am embarrassed for you, especially since money is all you care about.
Ответитьwtf they remade it?
ОтветитьNobody :
Boomers on this comment section : tHe OriGiNaL mOviE wAs gReAt a MaStErpiEce tHiS iS aN iNsuLt blablablaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa
I doubt it is better than the original.
ОтветитьI don't think it's necessary to remake Weir's film, most of which exists -- as it should -- in the imagination only. Weir created a framework and made suggestions, no more than the thinnest of deer trails that one is not sure are even there. It should be left at that.
ОтветитьI didn't know there was a remake
ОтветитьThumbs down for not even TRYING to edit out the helicopter sounds from the Apocalypse Now soundtrack. Beyond blatant and lazy.
Ответитьnow do a spin off with mike and albert banging somewhere in queensland
ОтветитьUFO GOT'UM
ОтветитьIs this worth watching? I love the original
Ответитьwhen i started to watch this movie i thought is a very good one but after the first episode i realised its a completely shit , dont waste your time
ОтветитьYou cannot remake perfection.
Ответить