Комментарии:
I wonder if it's because in Asian culture there's more of a focus on the collective rather than the individual and the song is about someone living their life selfishly with pride rather than living as part of a collective family/group and maybe that brings out a lot of repressed rage and confusion in Asian people? lol
Ответитьewing buat aku ke sini
ОтветитьSo no questions have been answered. 🤨
ОтветитьThe craziest thing about this is that we have so many examples of governments manipulating things and lying to us yet we still second guess questioning things currently going on.
Ответитьc'mon, karakoe killings and colonialization? really? 🤣🤣🤣😂😂💀
ОтветитьMy way is not that French song the lyrics to the French song are completely different. The music is the same. The lyrics to my way is written by Paul anka
ОтветитьCrazy
ОтветитьBut its not a sinatra song. Its a french song so that Asian womens colonization explanation is dumb. Its americas fault we have good media others like? No american cares about watching Phillipinos sing karaoke.
ОтветитьThat kan kill me my members if I sing it. It can be the day of rememberance and protest because it can kill us. 💯 of the course if they can sing that 1000 times, there is a protest will come on and make us sad and their families are died and we make orphans in it.
ОтветитьHow stupid are Phillipines ?
ОтветитьSounds like a curse to me! 🤷♀️
ОтветитьI just learned this now and this nvr happened in our locality. Friends, fam n peers sing this all the time, off key or not and no one died yet
I think the song means something deeply personal to the killers thats why any error triggers their murderous rage
The explanation of the lady is too complex. Filipinos just attach a lot of memories and emotions to songs, thats all
My family in the Philippines thinks the song Frank Sinatra’s My Way is a curse
ОтветитьMy way more like die way boing😅
ОтветитьFilo get triggered over Sinatra 😂
ОтветитьIs this video trying to portray a narrative that these murders are a fault of Caucasians in America??
Ответитьi can't believe this song haunts me to death when i'm living in philipines singing the worst frank sinatra song at a fucking karaoke bar. i'm almost choked out when this song can't get you out of my mind when karaoke songs are meant to be fun and not murder people like in GTA 5
ОтветитьAmerica is the world biggest terrorist organisation.... Funny but true'..
ОтветитьI can explain the reason why this song is taboo. It's not like your theory of triggering agression or most of the theories I've read in the comments. The real reason why the song is connected to so many murders is because the somg "My Way" is always played at a funeral. It will always be played on the hearse from the funeral to the cemetery. With that said, singing My Way on a public place had became a superstition that means you have a death wish for yourself or someone else. Yes there are also cases of people murdering someone after singing or hearing this song. It's not always the singer who dies. And if there's someone who believe strongly on this superstition, they will grant you the honor of being the one with the death wish.
ОтветитьWho is here from MR. BALLEN
ОтветитьGreat
These people are very heartless for killing innocent people that just sing my way
Filipino people can be cruel sometimes
But not all of them are cruel
In the Philippines, countless people have murdered people who are singing my way by Frank Sinatra
Me, an American: wow thats crazy, why are people in a foreign country killing eachother to the tune of an American classic?
Leftist college lady : well its actually your fault for being interested in the video because theyre Filipinos, its only being sensationalized because theyre singing an American song. And American colonization blah blah blah blah blah............
Actually the song MY Way was written by a man who's wrote many hit songs & that would be Mr. Paul Anka, story goes Sinatra team ask Anka to write a song for frank .
ОтветитьWe need to look at the data. There must be other murders while singing other songs besides My Way, therefore what is the statistic of murders across all karaoke venues? How popular is the specific song My Way in Philippines karaoke? If the only karaoke murders has been due to My Way then yes there may be something supernatural at play.
Ответитьconsidering frank sinatra abused his wife and children and he publicly called for Sinead O'connor to be beaten up because she spoke up about the abuse of children that was going on in the church - I don't think anyone should be blaming the Philippines for a curse of violence attached to his song
ОтветитьThe store front Filipino church next door to my office here on Saipan, just adopted "My way" as a hymn!
ОтветитьGood job researching this and explaining it. Keep up the good work
ОтветитьI am completely confused i don't get the explanation i assume karaoke bars have other popular American songs why is it my way and not beat it or toxic is they some cultural thing i am missing
ОтветитьHELP I LISTEN TO IT AND I SKIPPED I ALMOST HAD A HEART ATTACK
ОтветитьI can tell you 100% why My Way is banned. It afends people because there is too much gay related into the song that afends some people to the point where some will kill you for using a gay term or related words. that hit some people in there soul. There is a lot of people out there that are Homophobic where they will not ameet it. I am one of those homophobic person. And I can hear it in the song.
ОтветитьAs a non white, welcome to America! LOL Shut up and play!
ОтветитьIn the Philippines the My way song was called a curse song because in 1998 (i think) the "My Way" killings happened because people didnt sing it right.
ОтветитьPlease correct me for the context
Ответить12 people is hardly 'countless'
ОтветитьThe background on how Americans colonialized the Philippines gives a view to the world that America continued the practice of colonialization. The current exploits of America in the Middle-East is not about freeing the people but more on exploiting the resources in the Middle East. Russia and China is enemy because of the resources they have in their land not necessarily their totalitarianism or relationship with Marxism and Communism.
ОтветитьThe reason this is interesting is because people are telling over a song. It doesn’t matter what song it is it has nothing to do with mimicint of American culture like the woman is saying? Lol did she really just bring up US colonization? Yeah there is definitely a bigger story here but the reason it’s interesting from the beginning it is because people are killing each other over a freaking song 😂 the fact that that Filipino “ expert” doesn’t doesn’t think it’s interesting that people are killing over a song Is crazy to me.
ОтветитьIs this fake or real? Idk real know
ОтветитьFilipina es HISPANA 🗿🔥🗣️🇸🇽🇻🇦🇯🇪
ОтветитьWho else came from tiktok ?? 😂
ОтветитьIm a Filipino and im your subscriber now
ОтветитьSeems like that professor copied the western idealogy of "blame everything on white people."
12 or more people are dead as a direct result of singing this song and her answer is "it's because of colonization"
What utter tripe.
One of my grand-uncles passed away last year, and at his funeral, we played My Way. It inspired such a bittersweet feeling in me, and every time I hear this song, I think of that moment.
ОтветитьNo wonder the majority of them have amazing singing voices... they traditionally sing alot through out their life more than the average ethnicities
ОтветитьWell, what happens when you play Elvish music in the middle of Mordor? The orcs definitely won't be happy about it.
Ответитьits the arrogance of the singer
ОтветитьI sing this song all the time… guess I won’t be going to the Philippines any time soon
ОтветитьHonestly I really hate to hear someone singing off key especially if it’s a song that has a special meaning to me or a song I really like. So when you combine that with alcohol…..well….. I can see why it happens. It’s also a song that can elicit strong emotions because of the chords.
ОтветитьLots of people here have no clue what’s going on in the Philippines. As an expat living in the Philippines, I’d heard my share of loud, obnoxious, off key, off timing, sh*ty voice benching out crappy stereo system past 10pm to early morning, and the cops here take their sweet time hours later to break up the party so we can go back to sleep! Typically happened once every 2 weeks! Why you asked? The Philippines has Barangay fiesta, birthdays, crap load of national holidays, contests, etc constantly. So bad that even the provincial government has to impose quiet time from 10pm to 6am weekdays, and 12pm to 6am weekend. New proposal targeting impose a fine of 1,000 pesos (roughly $19) or up to six months in prison for violations. Before the government stepping in, there are times people got so piss off that murder is not out of normal realm!
ОтветитьI swear I almost died when singing this song eith my guitar. I literally forgot to breath and gasped hard ehe I got to verse 4. And earlier I just learned there's My Way killings.
Ответить