Тэги:
#KhAnubis #education #educational #language #linguistics #writing_systems #writing_systems_around_the_world #world_languages #phoenician #phoenician_alphabet #phoenician_alphabet_history #aramaic_language #common_ancestor #brahmic_scripts #india #europe #scripts_of_the_worldКомментарии:
Very poorly researched video. Your videos used to be better than this.
Ответитьلبنان العظيم 🇱🇧🇹🇳🌷
ОтветитьWould've liked it if you didn't use "Bengali" for calling the Bangla script
ОтветитьIt is true the Old Greek Script inspired the Old Georgian And Armenian Scripts But The New One Is Fresh And Different
ОтветитьGreat video...
It's explain a lot...
But you have one mistake...
The Hebrew language ( the original letters called "ashurit")
Have been here way before aramic and Acadian languages and letters...
Because the Jewish people were the ones that use Hebrew and they been alive way before the acadians and aramic.
But they never used the Hebrew language out of their holy places because it was a holly language for them and they aren't allowed to teach anyone who wasn't a Jew this holy language.
Outside of their holy places they used the native languages that surrounded them,
But in their holy places they speak only Hebrew (ashurit).
🧡देवनागरी🧡
ОтветитьThe Eritrean/Ethiopian Ge'ez script doesn't descend from the phoenician script, but from the Old-South-Arabian, which derived from the Proto-Sinaitic, which was actually an ancestor from the proto-kanaanitic script, from which then the phoenician script has derived.
ОтветитьWhat about the Albanian alphabet🇦🇱🇦🇱🇦🇱
ОтветитьGiorgio Tsokalous answered:
"Of course, the extraterrestrial has taught our ancestors long ago."
Please note that a language can exist without a script, if you study the phonology of sanskrit language and Akshar formation (alphabet formation) its logic is non-applicable to existing any human produced language alphabet based on environmental or use factors, rather it is based on sound production by a human using human anatomical features of the sound producing system of humans.
ОтветитьYeah so african
ОтветитьYeah so african
ОтветитьBAYBAYIN SHOUTOUT
ОтветитьCool
Ответить"Georgian scripts are unique in their appearance and their exact origin has never been established" (Wikipedia)
Georgian script isn't a branch of Greek, that's wrong. The order of the alphabet does correspond with the Greek one, but the SCRIPT itself is not a Greek derivative.
There are also the American scripts that developed independently. But those were thoroughly exterminated.
ОтветитьThe Canaanites invented proto-Sinaitic due to their economic relations with Egypt. There's no compelling evidence the Phoenicians had any involvement in its invention. Phoenician script may have STANDARDIZED the alphabet in about the 11th century. Prior to that, you could read bottom to top, left to right, right to left. After the 11th century your would read top to bottom, right to left. But this Phoenicians inventing the alphabet is one of these persistent myths that even a lot of scholars spout without knowing why.
ОтветитьI'm really glad that you mentioned my languages Telugu (తెలుగు) & Odia (ଓଡ଼ିଆ) ❤️
This is a fascinating thing to ponder over.
Love to everyone!
I always knew the first few languages came from around India but now its nice to see that the first few writing systems came from middle east
Ответитьhave you done a vid on the nbisidi script ?
ОтветитьThank the Phoenicians - Spaceship Earth, Epcot 😌😁
ОтветитьMy main languages are Hindi and Bengali and I mostly like to combine English sentences with both languages
Ответитьক=क म=ম স=स hindi and bangla language same
ОтветитьPhoenicia 🇱🇧❤
ОтветитьAnd you will NOT find Semites shouting everywhere we are this and we are that .. only hollow people flooding the comments with everything negative
ОтветитьInterestingly you left off Hangul which I think may be the only writing script used today that was invented by historical persons in 1443, maybe making it the youngest writing system in the world.
ОтветитьMusnad script omitted. As expected
the actual oldest alphabet, seeing how it literally started the whole thing and is what Protosemitic uses for reconstruction.
Aramaic is just pidgin Aeabic. Any average Arabic speaker can read it once transliterated, same for"""" phoenician""""
Ответитьthis is actually shocker how syriac actually made its own script family from aramaic
ОтветитьThe t-shirts for Cyrillic have characters like е, у, х, щ, ы, ь, ъ wrong. е is ye. у is oo. х is h. щ is shch. ы is ui. ь makes the letter before softer. And ъ makes the letter before harder.
ОтветитьWriting systems, not all of them are alphabets
ОтветитьBengali is not a script. The name of the Script is "Eastern Nagari". It is used in Assamese and a few other languages as well.
ОтветитьThe Indus Valley script looks so unnecessary complicated.
ОтветитьMesoamerican script is also independent that you didnt mention
ОтветитьC L A N K
ОтветитьGreeks invented the alphabet. We had many alphabets in ancient time, like the alphabet of Kymh which is called today the “Latin” alphabet, we had the alphabet of Ionia more than 30 alphabets. All the letters we use today are Greek. Greek is the oldest language in the world, the mother of all languages. The proof is endless. Many lies are propagated on purpose, like the one of the Phoenicians, Phoenicians were originally a Greek tribe, founded by Phoenix the son on Aginoras. The Phoenicians (Greeks) took the alphabet by the Minoans (Linear B). It’s crazy how ignorant and shallow you barbarians are. Really non thinking and no caring about the truth. You’ll always be asleep. Eveything around you is of Greek origin you just done know it and believe without critical thinking all the systemic lies.
ОтветитьPhoenix the son of Aginoras was the founder of Phoenicia, a Greek city. Phoenicians are Greeks, just another Greek tribe. Thousands of years later, semetic people appeared and today is it propagated on purpose that they were not Greeks, ridiculous, anti hellenic and of course with no proof at all, the same people who promote the lie about the indo europeans, promote the lie that the Phoenicians arent Greek. Phoenicians believed in the 12 Gods, spoke and wrote Greek and of course their alphabet ( Greeks had many) was greek and derived from Linear B of the Minoans. All ancient sources agree. Saying that the phoenicians are Greek is like saying that the Macedonians, Thracians or the Spartans arent. pure schizophrenia. Didnt expect anything else from uneducated barbarians who clearly have a semetic, anti hellenic agenda and are trying to hide the truth. You poor sheep. You havent even opened a book and you believe lies. Whoever cares about the truth will do the research. Everybody is stealing from the Greeks because they have nothing.
ОтветитьDo the geez langage and a matching shirt
ОтветитьThere is no brahmi for sanskrit. Dont spread wrong information. Sanskrit waa oral language it has no dedicated script until 400CE.
Ответитьactually runic writing is alot older than alot of the writing systems, its been shown to exist on every corner of the planet on very ancient artifacts, makes me wonder how much of this is garbled history. Theres also a theory that the writing system we have that was passed down is a combination of the different zodiac signs being split into two to form 2 different letters, seems to check out.
ОтветитьEgypt ftw 🇪🇬
ОтветитьI looooooooooooooooove my Georgian alphabet! ֎
·⁚ ႨჃ ⁚ ႵႤ ⁚ ႻႪ ⁚ ႥჂ ⁚· ⴓⴔⴀⴊⴍ, ⴈⴄⴑⴍ ⴕⴐⴈⴑⴒⴄ, ⴛⴄⴍ ⴖⴋⴐⴇⴈⴑⴀⴍ, ⴘⴄⴋⴈⴜⴗⴀⴊⴄ ⴋⴄ, ⴚⴍⴃⴅⴈⴊⴈ დექით მტკიცედ და შეურყევლად!
Brahmi originated from the Indus valley script, as Brahmi is much older than that, more than 3.5k years old determined by ancient Sanskrit texts like the rigveda, while Phoenician is much more recent
Ответитьmake a syriac aramaic shirt
ОтветитьThe local script present in the indian subcontinent was indus script therefore it is obvious that brahmi will descend from indus script. The Phoenician script was created much later than indus script and brahmi script
Ответить