Комментарии:
The allies had no chance of winning world war 2 with out the US, it is not because of how we fought it was because of the powerhouse of our industrial might at the time, even the soviet union would not have survived if it wasnt for the crucial war supplies we provided them.
ОтветитьFor the Germans, starting the war was not about winning, it was about destruction.
ОтветитьGermany didn't really declare as much as acknowledged that we had already been at war, in the Atlantic. Hitler's only reason for attacking France was to facilitate the invasion of the Soviet Union. Once he cleared out the continent he wanted peace with the British but they weren't having any of that, so he went ahead with Barbarossa and lost everything.
ОтветитьAlso the Russians where always planning for war with Germany and the English rejected peace deals with Hitler so those 2 didn't make sense to much. Lastly not to play down the us the russians would have beaten germany eventually due to the fuel shortage and man power shortage by the time the battle of stalingrad. but it was more of an overestimate that the Japanese could deal with the us and Germany thinking it could beat Russia the turn west. Potential history does a 2 part vedio on this topic exploring the what if myths of Germany winning ww2. Stating that nazi Germany would not have won ww2 no matter how you splice it without going into fantasy.
ОтветитьAmerica ....tough, powerful, impressive.....then the alarm goes off and they wake up. 😅
ОтветитьI think the only way Germany could have potentially won. Is by waiting to start their invasion in the late 40s or early to mid 1950s. They didn't have the infrastructure or command structure for a continuous and protracted war.
ОтветитьBut, one big problem; Hitler was a demon possessed megalomaniac! 👿
ОтветитьBevin Alexander seems to agree with you
ОтветитьThey could have won if hitler had listened to his general and moved his panzer divisions towards Normandy, but he didn’t, and it gave the allies the foot hold they needed in Europe and the rest is history
Ответитьwell the whole point was war with russia, as in the first world war. they only invaded france/belgium because of treaties and to cover their flank while doing so. russia was trying to do what germany did 20 years earlier, invading poland to free all the oppressed workers. any excuse is a good excuse.
ОтветитьWhat you said easily could of been done
Ответить1. They already tried it and it didn't work, the British refused any terms
ОтветитьHow about not be obsessed with murdering so many people of the countries they invaded....how about instead of being evil .... storming into villages and machine gunning down citizens which then culminated with the holocaust....they tried being benevolent and built those nations they invaded as we did with Germany and Japan after we won..... perhaps that would've helped too.
ОтветитьProblems:
1. Royal navy
2. Ideology
3. Wilson, ideology again, and even if this happened the Allie’s would still win
Wrong. If Hitler delayed 1 year, finished the " heavy water experiments" developed the V-2, the world would be speaking Deutschland today. So we got really lucky.
Ответитьyour changing the characters of the germans, the invasion of the Soviet Union *was* the ultimate goal of hitler and the nazi's, and either way, if the germans didn't strike first, the soviets would've.
ОтветитьDon't invade Russia AT WINTER.
ОтветитьBro is a future general
ОтветитьThey try to have a deal with UK but after breaking repeated treates were not trusted and Wiston gave them the 2 finger salute
ОтветитьNo no no. So this is so easy as Germany couldn't really afford a war on several front. Firstly don't invade Russia. While still invading uk. Go all out invade uk. U.s can't land troops. And to try retake uk while japanese were all out to get them wouldn't have been ideal. So staying would have been left to the germs. Witch with conscripts now from all uk. He wouldn't need to split his army and he would be able to concentrate on starlin. When starlin fell. America would be next. But by then the Americans would have the atom bomb and Germany would have tried to negotiate a truce. End of ww2 Germany now hold 3/5 of the world's economies. He could also take Spain and most of Africa with no one to stop his march
ОтветитьHoi4 be like
ОтветитьThey would have never kept a peace pact with the Soviets because the Nazis hated Communism.
ОтветитьJapan throw a bomb to scare the Americans from joining the ww2... poor humans
Ответить#1 was tried. Did not work. Hitler went after Russia for two reasons: England was waiting for USSR to turn on Hitler and holding out for American entry, and Hitler knew Stalin would attack Germany.
# 3 was the most viable of these three, but Hitler borked it by bonking the U.S.; if he had held off I believe the U.S. populace would've forced Roosevelt to make the main effort in the Pacific.
But Churchill and Roosevelt were planning a Europe first campaign well before 12-7-1941. Hitler made it easier for them.
If japan never went to war with america, then i would bet that germany wouldve had a good chance at defeating the european allies. Maybe being able to land in the british isles.
ОтветитьThe Germans wouldn't have been able to avoid a war with America. A lot of political games by the Americans put japan into a position with the pearl habour attack effectively being a bait to join the war
ОтветитьThey would not have beaten the British Navy it was the largest Navy at the time.
ОтветитьDeclaring war on US was stupid.
ОтветитьI think Hitler’s main screwup was attacking Russia…
ОтветитьGermany and Japan achieved their goals after the surrender, so basically they won
ОтветитьFascists will be fascists, they’re not particularly smart. They just wanna conquer the world and build big ass buildings to give the facade that their regime is rooted in some mythologized historical narrative. At the end of the day, it’ll all fall apart.
ОтветитьAll they had to do was not attack Russia and most of Europe would still be apart of Germany
ОтветитьOnly the last one is realistic, Germany did not need to declare war on the US, they didn't need to uphold a guarantee for Japan. USSR has to be invaded, that's the whole point of the war.
ОтветитьIF Germany didn't attack the ussr, the ussr would betrayed germany first
ОтветитьYeah but they had Hitler so none of that would ever happen.
ОтветитьYou sir have gained my subscription 🫡
ОтветитьGERMANY SHOULD NOT HAVE TRIED TO TAKE ON THE SOVIETS
Ответитьin reality germany can win With 3 ways had population of 300 milions . 2 had resources and fuells like USSR orhad . 3Dont be nazi so question is easy they can win if they are USSR or US LOL But same can be done for each county in world if smallest country in world can had win WW2 if they are USSR or USA now to you video Germany vs USSR was inevitable and USA to come war is also very doubtfull but even if USA was not in war they will still lost on east only one differences will only one block in EU in cold war .
ОтветитьAfter 70 years , it is easy to say . If you and me were there at that tiime , we would have peed in our pants !
ОтветитьMost people don't know that half of all the people lost in World War II Russians (Soviets). Great Britain and the United States would have never been able to invade if the Russians were not fighting 2/3 of the Germans.
ОтветитьKill Hitler, get Herman Georing off the drugs then shoot that far waste of space. Then make Rommel the new Furher and jobs a gooden.
ОтветитьHe was a crazy guy … he didn’t care to win
ОтветитьWell did you want to become a slave
ОтветитьGermany was doomed from start when hitlers inner circle met for first time because they all hated each other!
ОтветитьWar with Russia is what ultimately led to the downfall of Germany, however war with Russia was a matter of when not if, and the intent was to strike early while Russia was still struggling to get on its feet, rather than later when Russia had more means to fight, either way Germany still struck too late.
ОтветитьProbably the dumbest thing I ever heard.
Ответить