Judge Scolds Defense Attorney Over Questioning of Shooting Victim

judge bias af

I could never be a lawyer... I would have to lie and create scenarios that didn't happen... I wouldn't be able to sleep at night!

The alternate reality defense usually works

How does one put evidence on the record if they can't ask a witness about facts not on the record ?

Surely he had the opportunity to ask this while he was throwing his questions out….why didn’t he ask then?

I'm pretty sure that the prosecution uses speculation on EVERY SINGLE CASE. What a joke this judge should be put in jail.

Judge is skinny Archie Bunker

I don't know why the lawyer didn't enter the 911 call into evidence or ask/question this other male witness they were talking about first before going down this line of questioning. To me that seems like basic logic but I am not a lawyer so maybe there is more to this then I think.

Cross-examination is a key legal right. The case will be tossed if the judge interferes in any way.

Scum defense lawyers

Court Proceedings 101: The is a requirement of Establishment BEFORE further questioning; otherwise it's considered "leading" (asking someone to speculate).

wtf is a centella lol

Thats a "scold"?

LOVE THIS JUDGE!!!

Si

I don't know what they are talking about.

Regardless of how the atty is conducting himself; the judge is "stooping down" 2 the atty's level RE: misconduct. That's what I'm sensing here.

Less than one minute in, and the fact that that attorney is actually trying to defend his bs is beyond angering.
I cannot stand liars.

Just sit down and listen to what the judge is saying you can't make up stories

The Judge shouldn't have let the attorney go on. He should have just said "I've made my ruling. That will be all"

The judge is 100% right. The defense attorney, by asking hypotheticals, is attempting to create evidence/testimony into the case.  
THAT'S not allowed! Attorneys cannot create evidence!

"Understood judge...... but".

Should've stopped before the "but".

"That's my ruling. End of it." If only all augurents could be settled that easily.

Judge is right, the jury will think there must be some evidence of the BS.

I hate it when grandpa and grandpa fight 😥

She keeps changing her story?? Disqualify her as a witness!!

informative

He served less than 2 years in a hospital after being found innocent because of insanity. I just cant even anymore

Dang, tuat judge was realky civil.

So Americans can’t hire an attorney to defend them in court? The government gets to decide your defense? No wonder they’re 5% of the world population and 20% of the worlds criminals. Land of the prisoner.

Umm, is no one going to ask if the judge and the defense attorney are related? Like brothers or something? They look almost like twins. Maybe it's just me.

Assumes facts not in evidence

This judge is horrible. Facts come out on the witness stand, not where the judge has prior knowledge of testimony. Defense attorneys should absolutely be able to question a witness on statements, or recollection of facts.

Are any of you Clarance Darrows attorneys? Shut up.

To be quite fair, the victim has an obligation under the law, NOT to make her injuries any worse than they originally were.
By bleeding so much, Lauren Kanarek blatantly and deliberately (& probably with malice aforethought too) sought to make her injuries that much worse.
Case dismissed.

lol

The job of the attorney is to ask question, judge is not his teacher, usa is so barbaric and fcked up.

The judge is straight wrong on this. The way you get evidence in about whether or not something happened is to ask a witness. What the judge is basically saying is that you can't ask any questions that elicit facts that contradict what facts the Prosecutor has put into the record.

Why doesn't this clip show the questioning that was objected to?

Judge was in the tank for the state.

Still not guilty.

I really hope the poor dude the lawyer is defending isn’t on trial for anything serious……..like anything past the theft of a lollipop or a single smartie (not the whole roll of smarties but just….one single smart) I’m guessing that smart is the singular of said candy smarties lol

I'm sorry, this is as basic as it gets. Are we sure this defense attorney actually passed the bar? Talk about grasping at straws.

This rude attorney reminds me of Craig Mueller…the attorney for Michael Lee McDonald regarding his divorce from Candace McDonald a few yrs ago. Mueller got on everyone’s nerves…he was rude & condescending & arrogant jerk…he was awful & this guy seems to be a “brother” of Mueller.

I honestly have no idea what is going on, but that Judge, is awesome!!

And if there’s gunshot residue on the body, you know that they at least were in so much of a range of the intended target. It leaves what’s called flashback.

The position of the body there’s always pulling up the blood, and which usually tells corners which position the body was laid in if it was move

It takes only two hours after someone dies before they start to go into what’s called rigor mortis

There’s no such thing as benefit of the doubt when it comes to the law because then you’re trying to imply that circumstantial evidence is more important than factual evidence

And that’s why I would make a poor defense attorney, but I’d make a great prosecuting attorney

I don’t lie to judges, and here’s why they’ve heard and seen it all