Trick The Crones And Save Both Anna (Baron's Wife) And The Tree Spirit | Witcher 3

There is No good Ending

Is this a troll? 😂

You didn't show how you got to the baron before talking to the witches

Anyone complaining about the kids, Here’s one solution…. Who cares let’s be honest kids are annoying and if most games had an option to kill them you would, Like in high on life.

Personally I prefer the ending where you save the tree. The baron is an abusive pos, and no way would he change his ways if Anna actually got cured, Anna worked with the crones, “took care” of the kids knowingly they’d be offered to the crones, I don’t care for the circumstances that led her to do that it’s just awful. As for the villagers, they’re basically a cult and are in good terms with the crones so I don’t feel bad for them either. The only victims here are the children.

How dafuq did you get those glow and cut effects ????!!!

How did you make your weapons that powerful Like with the heavy attack and the light attack with your swords?

Why would you think anyone cares about saving the tree spirit the choice is either the Barron's wife or the children.

How do I find this sword you have?

Im stuck and cant trigger for meet tamarra hos to fix

best outcome is free the spirit. kill the devil worshippers of downwarren. free the kids. and put the baron and anna out of their misery as theyre terrible people if you think about it. the ghost is technically good just pissed. and tamara can live free without the rotten parents. the baron and anna dissappear either way so might as well save the kids in my opinion

There is no good or bad ending. Its supposed to be morally ambiguous. Save the kids and the spirt, villagers and Anna dies. Kill the spirit and save the villagers, Anna lives but goes crazy and kids get eaten.

you must choose beetwen save the kids or baron wife

I cant/wont decide, i uninstalled the DAMN game!

Where you using RTGI?

Does this also save the children?

Good ending both of them death

😂 Man do some research

Si tuviera que elegir entre los endings malos y la mala edición de estos eligiria ninguno de los 2

Fuck this quest where’s the video on how tf he swung the sword like that😭

It is possible to save both Anna and the children. Taken from steam forums:

To avoid this and save both the children and Anna, start Ladies of the Wood as you normally would up until the part where you help Johnny regain his voice. Then when he tells you to follow him back to the orphanage, leave instead and go to the Whispering Hillock and speak to the Tree Spirit. Agree to do the ritual. You should already have the feather. Go and collect her bones and then find a black horse. Return with everything and begin the ritual. She will then possess the horse and leave.

Go back to the swamp and resume following Johnny. Speak with the Crones, agreed to do as they ask. Get the dagger from Anna and go to Downwarren. Speak to the Ealdorman and get his payment (the ear) and return to the bog. Speak again with the Crones and tell them you freed the spirit. They will now know that the spirit freed the children and not Anna, and she won't be cursed. They'll be angry at you for deceiving them but they'll keep their end of the bargain and tell you what happened to Ciri. End of quest.

Wish I knew 😂 I already talked to the ladies

downside of this secret ending is the whole village of downwarren killed one another because of the punishment gave by the black mare (whispering hillock)

You’re just gonna skip the fact that you went to go tell his daughter just walked through is so pathetic and worthless

Ok, this video confuses me. Is it possible to save the kids and Anna or not? What the point of this video if you can't do both. The normal way of playing already has either choices. If I have to sacrifice the kids to save Anna.

Where can i find the sword you use...

A nice little experiment into what constitutes a “good ending” to most people.

i always give the baron every bad decision to guarantee the bad ending, just dont like him.
and also choose the most violent/ignorant option in the dialogues.

I decided to save the orphans, Baron was abusive to everyone, he was hurting and killing his men, beating his wife in a drunken rage. ann was a angry with baron because he killed the man she was cheating with and would sometimes try to kill him or herself. The villagers would willingly sacrifice their kids to the crones, so to me the only true good decision is to save the kids. Who’s only crime was existing.

It's a witcher's job to kill monsters, not save children. I cannot allow that evil tree spirit to wreck havoc upon this world.

"once you free him"
It's a her.

The issue I have with this game is replay value. Once you do a quest that’s it, no real replay value. If you grind TOO many levels then the XP is lowered which is SUPER DUMB.
By the time you hit level 99 the cap there is nothing left to do, literally nothing left..

Sure but don’t the kids die??

I guess my reward was to see him hang

Are you using the mod for sword combat? Looks quite cool.

I don't care about the kids, i give the good ending to Barons wife because they deserve a goddamn break.

You also save the kids

The consequences of doing it this way is :
Lost of life the villagers of downwarren
Lost of life the kids at the swamp (you didn't asked the horse to save them)
but
Anna live
Mythical horse live
you pissed of the crones.
thus with the intention of saving mythical horse and anna you killed a village and the kids.

Killing she who knows and saving anna is the best outcome

Is this what the game looks like with the new update or are you on a good pc? Looks immaculate, I wish you could macro a quick cast between signs on console 🥵

You don't have to go to tree first. I have done the ending where she lives and Baron takes her to find a cure. It is in the dialogue you choose. Hell, funny thing is, in the over 1k hours I have played, I have never gotten the curse ending. That was a new one for me. But that is what I love about this game and why it is such a masterpiece.

Do you use a lightning mod in this video? Looks really good

got the good ending without doing this trick. also, I killed the tree evil

What ability is that one with the the king down swing

What's the armor

Geralt's a witcher. Witchers' mission is to kill harmful monsters. So I killed the Tree Spirit and two of the three Crones. To kill the third Crone, you must get the bad ending where Ciri dies. Or you can get the good ending and hope Geralt or another witcher kills the remaining Crone. In my first play through, I got the bad ending so I vanquished the last remaining evil Crone.

No one:
Children: ?

But see this way both the kids and all of downwarren dies. And no matter your personal theory on the people of downwarren and their culpability being involved with crones, there has to be innocent people there. Women, children… that don’t have a say in the villages dealings with crones. Plus there is absolutely no way to know the tree spirit isn’t evil. For me I always just kill the spirit. I don’t think Geralt would ever free something like that, plus he’s on a mission to find Ciri not play Hero in the swamp for zero coin.

The problem with this path is that you freed an evil spirit that will wreak havoc on the people of Downwarren and the crones will kill and eat the children. Imho this is the worst possible outcome.
I've taken all possible routes and prefer to save the innocent children or to kill the spirit and save Anna and the villagers - though they're all not innocent, just apathetic to the evil surrounding them, and Anna is just as much a perpetrator as a victim.