Комментарии:
Un des plus grands films jamais réalisés. Tarkovski a réussi à donner à cette adaptation d'un roman des frères strougatzki une dimension qu'il n'avait pas en le poussant dans une ambiance post apocalyptique qu'on ne trouve pas dans le roman. Imaginez cela : la "zone" devenue une attraction où les touristes affluent pour observer le territoire interdit à la jumelle en dégustant des saucisses achetées auprès des vendeurs qui profitent de l'intérêt des visiteurs. Je ne vous ments pas, c'est bien ainsi que se présente le roman. Tarkovski a ajouté un côté beaucoup plus sombre. C'est incroyable que ce soit en URSS où la censure a entravé de nombreuses ambitions artistiques que ce film a pu être tourné. En occident malgré la quasi liberté dont on bénéficiait peu de producteurs auraient risqué leur argent dans un tel projet.
ОтветитьYou are awesome.
ОтветитьIf film had been shot based on the novel and not on its "motives"the audience would not have left in droves (I remember it well) The people did not understand the genius
Ответитьnklnklnnl
ОтветитьI don't understood ending of the movie..
ОтветитьWhat happen when you find a place where you desire get fulfilled,
The movie depicts,
whether we actually know what we desire and the desire is truly we wanted it or any other still there that we were forgotten or suppressed in sub-conscious and later emerged out in later life and force us to commit suicide.
The stalker and two others go to the place ( where your desire comes true) called Zone where the world is prohibited and are afraid to enter the room because they never know what their real desire is and afraid of that place and wanting to destroy it.
Humans always crave for some desire and parallelly afraid of getting fulfilled coz he never knows what he wants.
That's why?
We have stories like 'Aladdin and the lamp'
Aladdin is us
Lamp is Desire
genie is nature
If we know what to ask then nature has the capacity of fulfilling it.
First we should know what to ask, the story tells us that we should know first, what we want....otherwise you stand as a fool and try to destroy the opportunity i.e. lamp.
Here in movie, the fulfilling room.
i dont get it
Ответитьangle cosine square root of .48 south west in the night sky, if you have the eyes to see it. cosine square root of .48 is the angle on the map psychological schema from mecca through rome and paris. A middle class education is aware of this. Remember there are people frightened of it for good reason.
ОтветитьМне по-жизни везло
И хребет не сломало
Вроде всё хорошо
Только этого мало....
Много неувязочек и неувязок в фильме. Да и вообще в сценарии тоже. А баба - правильно говорит, что если нет горя то и счастья нет тоже. Человек не познавший горя счастливым никогда не станет. Откуда узнаешь что такое счастье, если не познаешь горя.
ОтветитьGreat imagery and story of function and purpose..Watched it a few times but recalled it in my mind about a million
ОтветитьIt is all based around the meteor strike in Siberia..The 1907 Tunguska event..
Ответитьsigma fr!!!!🤩🤩🤩🤩😍😍😍🥰🥰🥰🤪🤪🤪😶🌫😏😏🤥😑😑😛😛😛😛😛😛😛😛😛😛😛😛😛
ОтветитьWho is here after reading Rahi barve's tweet 😀
ОтветитьI can only watch this in 10 minute spurts because it is intensely beautiful. Every shot is a masterpiece
ОтветитьThank you Mosfilm for restoring and uploading this beatiful film
ОтветитьI hear a lot of dub reggae sounds
Ответитьfears sobered you up
ОтветитьA thousand thanks for posting this masterpiece.
Ответить子供のころ親が出かけ深夜家に一人でいたさいみたときから30年間この作品の虜です
Ответить¿de donde sacaron un land rover en la urss?
ОтветитьИ пророчество и Апостольство не нужная история. Для этого нужно нормальным обществом быть.
ОтветитьLudilo! ❤
ОтветитьWhat a boring-ass sack of crap! Spoiler Alert! NOTHING HAPPENS and everyone is a huge dork. At least The Tempest had poetry, all these guys have is baldness and an amazing ability to waste your time. I guess Christian meta post-modernism is a dull as the gay iewsih kind. Yeeesshhh this movie stinks! I give it 241.45 thumbs down.
ОтветитьTarkovsky was a visionary who literally died for his art.
Ответитьis this the dutch transfer?
ОтветитьWhy is the beginning not sepia gold color but rather black and white?
ОтветитьThey performed through all that polluted water and toxic ashes. I understand why all they died at a young age. What a pity
ОтветитьOne of the truly masterieces in film history. btw, I´m a S.T.A.L.K.E.R pc-games fanatic,
ОтветитьTarkovsky is Timewriter!
Ответитьsad
ОтветитьMaaan... I hate that the original was taken down with subs for all languages
ОтветитьThe Writer says he wanted just to change his readers but his readers have changed him, makes me wonder if humanity is changing the Zone at the same time as the Zone changes the people that enter. The Zone has this beautiful, quiet environment but also it has rubbish (needles?) floating in the water, and there's the shot of black oil (?) overcoming the water with the sound of a train - noise pollution from outside? If the Zone is understood to be something like God than it feels like humans are polluting the purity of God somehow. It does seem similar to what the Writer comes to believe - that he shouldn't know his deepest desire, because he believes it would be awful and believes the same of humanity as a whole I think.
ОтветитьReligion och vetenskap går hand i hand!
ОтветитьLiked and subscribed.
Ответить💤 😴
ОтветитьWonderful film. I liked that for the adults; life was grey outside of the Zone. But since the child had the Zone living in her, life was color no matter where she was at.
ОтветитьWow! Mosfilm channel giving us this masterwork for free!!! Thanks from Brazil!
ОтветитьEn mexico hablamos español no ingles lastima se ve buena la pelicula
ОтветитьLets sneak in....using the loudest damn vehicle on earth.
ОтветитьObjectively, the greatest film ever made.
ОтветитьFor people wondering why this movie is free. It was created during the soviet union which is now non existent. So pretty much anyone owns the rights to this movie cus its just actual history, like a roman play from the year 13 bc
ОтветитьMad men watch this movies and than the mad men give their own narratives. I am just curious at the ending! What was that cat doing inside a small jar? lol
ОтветитьNothing happens in this movie… unless you watch it wondering about life and almost depressed… there you realize it actually happens a lot.
Ответитьشي غريب كل ما رجعت بالزمن كانت الافلام اجمل
ОтветитьI watched Stalker recently, after watching another good film, Ivan’s Childhood, and it immediately became one of my all time favourite films with it’s engaging, minimalist storytelling, the Stalker, Writer and Professor, in spite of their different personalities, backgrounds and viewpoints on life, are still likeable and relatable characters, and the themes of faith, hope, and mankind’s struggle for happiness and finding meaning in life, along with quiet moments, lack of any villains or end of the world style narrative, good acting, charming and funny interplay between the three leads, a calming, cerebral atmosphere, that make it oddly relaxing and comforting, this is one of Andrei Tarkovsky’s more optimistic films, especially when you consider a lot of his other ones are quite melancholy when you really think about it.
In my personal opinion, the two most emotional moments in the film was the scene where the Writer, rejects the Room, no longer needing it to find inspiration for his books, notices the Stalker crying on the floor after having a breakdown over leading people into it, regardless of their moral stance or what they do with their wishes, to feel like he had a purpose in his lonely, miserable life, and the Writer, who, outside of briefly putting aside his negative feelings to try helping him find the Professor when they’re separated, had been the most confrontational and cynical with him throughout the journey, gently puts his arm around him and hugs him, showing a more compassionate and humble side, as the Professor, a man who always tried to find logic and reason to explain life, realises that the Room is beyond our comprehension of good or evil, yet at the same time, if it’s destroyed, the Stalker bringing hope back into the lives of people would be for nothing, also gives up on entering it too and the three quietly sit together in solidarity. As the area flickers with a yellow/brown light, I interpreted it as the Room trying to tempt them subconsciously into giving in to their deepest desires, regardless of if they want more than what they initially had, especially since Porcupine wanted his dead brother back and killed himself in guilt after choosing a selfish wish of getting money over saving him, but they still remain defiant together, showing friendship, empathy and camaraderie to each other and when the Stalker and his Wife return home, the Writer and the Professor don’t look all sunshine and rainbows, but they don’t look miserable either, they just quietly watch him leave, and presumably go back to their old lives, as wiser men who have changed for the better, hopefully, they continue to stay friends with him, because the poor guy really needs them.
As for the second moment, it’s when the Stalker’s Wife sees the Stalker’s despair over his perceived failure in the Room, calms her husband down and puts him bed, trying her best to soothe his anxieties until he falls asleep, and gives that great, well-acted monologue about how in spite of all the difficulties she endured, in both her relationship to him and how people treated him badly, whether it’s inside the prison or out in the Zone where people inevitably leave him or die due the unpredictable nature of the Room, along with struggling to raise their disabled daughter, but his Wife does her best to accept and understand his fears and worries, cares for him and their child deeply, never treats him like a liability, and that he is loved and and valued by the people closest to him, and she’d rather take a life of passion, and pain, over a grey, dull, unfulfilling one, because she loves her family that much and I found that so sweet, hopeful and beautiful. Plus, they got a cool new black dog to play with!