Drone vs Helicopter | Comparison of noise generation

Drone vs Helicopter | Comparison of noise generation

RCmags

5 месяцев назад

1,068 Просмотров

Somewhat long video comparing the noise generated by two different rotorcraft: a multi-rotor (drone) and a helicopter.

For a given size, drones seem to be really noisy (or at least annoying) to humans. Other aircraft like single rotor helicopter or airplanes make more agreeable sounds.

Question for the future: Can drones be made quieter with a few simple design choices?

PS: Even a cheap microphone sounds better than the crap built into laptops!

Тэги:

#helicopter #drone #quadcopter #multi #rotor #blade #aerodynamics #rc #radio_control #electric #motor #noise #sound #interference #loud #quiet
Ссылки и html тэги не поддерживаются


Комментарии:

@Sagetower7
@Sagetower7 - 21.03.2024 04:39

I didn't realize how small that model was, omg

Also yes small rotor diameter leads to efficiency losses and lots of noise. Also having the discs not being parallel might also increase yaw power at the expense of upward thrust.

Ответить
@NathanChisholm041
@NathanChisholm041 - 23.03.2024 12:45

That drone isnt noisy at all!

Ответить
@SithLord2066
@SithLord2066 - 23.03.2024 22:08

small motor and small blades turning at high rpm = more noise. Bigger motor turning at lower rpm = lower noise.

Ответить
@johncgibson4720
@johncgibson4720 - 23.03.2024 22:30

The helicopter can be converted to a direct drive that will be so silent that you only wish that it is louder. I FPV my 250 gram helicopter with purely direct drive main and tail motors.

Ответить
@KTHKUHNKK
@KTHKUHNKK - 24.03.2024 01:42

I am like you I don't like the sound of the drone.
I call it a high-pitched screaming sound.

I fly the typhoon h480 it's very nice and quiet compared to the DJI little mini.

Ответить
@KTHKUHNKK
@KTHKUHNKK - 24.03.2024 01:47

It's like a mad swarm of bees

Ответить
@davidraborn3654
@davidraborn3654 - 24.03.2024 03:21

The pro 3 has silicon tips on the props. Sounds quieter than 2. We'll see how long they last.

Ответить
@davidraborn3654
@davidraborn3654 - 24.03.2024 03:22

I loved building 450's Flybarless.

Ответить
@SarojJangid-st7si
@SarojJangid-st7si - 07.07.2024 18:44

Can you make one Axis gyro for rc helicopter for tail motor ( brushed motor) using MPU6050 module please I'm waiting for your positive response

Ответить
@citylumberjack8381
@citylumberjack8381 - 09.08.2024 02:24

I don’t know what you are hearing or not hearing but the helicopter was making a terrible non fundamental harmonic frequency that was like nails on a chalkboard. Does nobody else notice this? I got 3 min in before I couldn’t take it anymore. Yes the drone is loud, but all of it’s harmonic frequencies and amplitudes were more evenly balanced. None actually stood out but the helicopter on the other hand, had that one frequency above the rest that stood out like a sore thumb.

Ответить