Top 15 New Era Survivor Players Part 1

One thing is for sure Survivor used to have way hoter contestants.

im sorry but carolyn is not top 15, i wouldn’t put her in too 25. thats like saying noura would be top 15 of players between s35- s39

YES CAROLYNN MN SWEETHEART I AM HER

Where is Carson. I think hes better then Carolynn tbh.

Glad you gave Danny some love! He’s super underrated. 😊

Lindsay is a great choice! 👍🏻

Oh god I can't picture how BORING 44 would have been if Carolyn and Yam Yam went out premerge. They were the heart and soul of the season.

Carolyn shouldn’t be higher than several of these players

People say gabler was a shock, but erica was obvious. Survivor fans, you so crazy

I think Jam Jam is way too low. He'd be in my number 2 spot

Can you do the same video for Australian Survivor?

Gabler on here…. Ok lol I mean at least you put Lindsay and Danny on there so that balances out i guess

Did you forget to add Heidi to the list or Danny from 44?

Where’s Jonathan?

I only wanna see either Erika, Jesse or Omar at top

I'm happy with where Shan falls in this ranking. I don't know if anyone else feels this way but the way Shan manipulated her tribe showed her skill but she always gave me the creeps!

Ricard is Top 10 in my opinion

Gabler at 13??? Come on now, you aren't serious lol

Lmfao Carolyn above Shan are you kidding me? 😂

I agree with almost everything here except for Shan. She only had the stranglehold on the premerge the way she did because her tribe is possibly the worst tribe in terms of social gameplay in history. She didn’t actually have that much power in the the post merge and was mostly kept safe because of Ricard and because the initial alliances lines were drawn on very outside the game factors instead of strategic ones (which is why they were all so quick to turn on each other the second anyone felt they had the security to do so). Her terrible social performance on the challenge doesn’t help that perception out either.

How is Carolyn ahead of Gabler????

Richard deserves to be higher on this list as, besides not being able to manage his threat level, he was the best player. He got to final five when he only had one other ally, in Shan, at the merge. I believe he is the best player in 41.

I wanna see Ricard back so much

Gablor is top zero

Top 4 memorable players from each season w/o thinking:
Shan, Xander, Erika, Ricard
Maryanne, Mike, Omar, Drea
Cassidy, Karla, Jesse, Cody
Yam Yam, Carolyn, Carson, Heidi

I would swap Ricard and Danny, but good list

Karla being at 15 is CRIMINAL

woaaahhhh shan and ricard are way lower than i thought they would be

When Erika is top 3 next week 🥰

I don’t think Cody was JT to Jesse’s Stephen. I think Cody is Wendell (the likeable social butterfly), while Jesse was Dominick (the master strategist.)

The New Era sucks. Bring back real villains and drama.

I NEED Cody and Jesse on hero’s vs villains 2

Luvus tribe was so talented, but the edit really hated them, probably because they werent as flashy as the other two tribes, but I mean 4 out of 6 in top 6 doesnt come from somewhere, I so wished heather wasnt purpled I think she played a stronger game then the edit suggested

Great video! Can't wait for part two.

IDEA: I think I came up with a new good idea for a video. I'll share it as a suggestion.

I was re-watching the final tribal council from Winners at War because I love Tony's and Michelle's performances. It was something Michelle said that triggered this idea.

She says at one point that she played this game with integrity, and I realized that she indeed appears surprisingly to have done just that. It's funny to me, because usually in Survivor the players that say that, well.. they say it a lot, and they are unaware of the fact that they did NOT play with integrity.

I'm sure Michelle didn't set out to play with integrity necessarily (she probably just wanted to find a way to win), but she ended up playing that game probably because of her personality, and for sure because of her positioning in the game, not having the control.

It would be super interesting to me to see a top, or a video about the players that actually played with integrity, real integrity, not Coach Wade - integrity. 🤣

I guess it would be kinda difficult to make a video about that. First you need to define it. And we only see what production chooses to show us in 42 minute per episode... I wonder if I can think right now of any other players that fit this.

Hmm, Ian from Palau? Colby? Woo? I'm not sure about Woo. Why did he choose Tony? Because of loyalty? But even so, the rest of his game I don't feel he played with integrity, I don't know.

Did Lil' from Pearl Islands play with integrity? I don't remember 😂

I can't think of any more at the moment, but I feel that there are some players that probably were mid-game boots.

Hmm, Morriah from Survivor 43? She was too nice for the game 😂

Ok, this all the effort I'm gonna do. It would be awesome if you like the idea and make a video about this or something similar if you find an angle you like better.

Much love ❤️

I'm guessing the Top 5, in no particular order, are Erika, Maryanne, Jesse, Omar, and Carson.

The new survivor has been a lil rough to watch, Australian Survivor heros vs villains has been way better

shan too low

Day 1 of asking for a vid called “Survivor Winners with the most votes against them”

I swear Idoled Out has really controversial opinions, but every one he explains so damn well that I end up having the same opinions. Here’s my list tho but only ten:
10-Cody
9-Noelle
8-Frannie
7-Evvie
6-Jesse
5-Yam Yam
4-Maryanne
3-Carson
2-Karla
1-Carolyn (I LIKE SWEATING, TOO)

Giving Danny way too much credit for a very lackluster game. He would have made it further if not group with the all black alliance. Cody needs more credit, dude carries the season in entertainment plus good gameplay. His only issue was Jesse didn’t take him and probably would have given Jesse the win. Carolyn and Yam Yam both relied on Carson to get as far as they got neither were threats at all. Carolyn emotions got in the way of taking the other T3 out, and Yam Yam went to Carson for the ok on every vote he orchestrated nothing. Really hope Jesse is in the top 5❤

Lindsay is genuinely one of the worst players of the 40s. Was invisible for half the season then rode coattails

Gabler is my #1 pick 🐊
People like to say he robbed Jesse but no, he killed Jesse in a few words that he said to Cassidy. "I can do it." Badass.

Before I watch this video, I'll just put my ranking here. I couldn't make it just 15 so I got 20 people, who I think played the best games. After I watch the video, I can make a comparison. (It's just my opinion that is slighly biased, don't get too upset)

20th Cassidy
19th Lindsay (42)
18th Jenny
17th Danny (41)
16th Danny (44)
15th Shan
14th Noelle
13th Drea
12th Erika
11th Mike (42)
10th Karla
9th Carolyn
8th Carson
7th Ricard
6th Cody
5th Omar
4th Yam Yam
3rd Gabler
2nd Maryanne
1st Jesse

Honorable mentions: Frannie, Nasser, Tiffany, Eevie and Xander


Edit: Karla and Mike are lower, but I understand their position.

I will defend Gabler's game until the end of time. I truly believe that he played fantastic game.

Im my eyes Shan played good, but not great winning game. I mean I wasn't rooting for her, so I might be biased.

Now RIcard played much more impressive game and he would definitely won had he made it to the end. Litlle lower than expected.

Lindsay was good maybe even great player, but amongst other great playres on her season she doesn't have the most impressive game, but I get why you put her this relatively high.

Danny is underrated and amazing, but I couldn't put him higher. This ranking was already extremely hard to put together, so he stays in 17th, but honestly maybe in few month I will change my mind and put him higher.

Cody and Carolyn played really strong and with different partner or better FTC, they could've been the winners. Very similiar placements.

Yam Yam's social game is truly off the charts. Definitely my favourite winner from this new era (even If I think that Gabler and Maryanne played slighty better).

Well besides Gabler, Ricard and Danny, my ranking is very similar. I will do rest of this in part 2.

Carolyn at 7 despite making FTC and getting 0 votes is a bit too high. Yam Yam at 6 is insane.

My gawd I need Shan to play again like, STAT!

Nah yam yam is way too low he clears erika cmon

Gabler>Erika

Cassidy better be in the top 5

I think my favorites of the new era are Ricard & Omar. Oh and Danny !!

Thank you for giving credit to Carolyn for the Carson idol play.

I think a lot of people give her a raw deal since Jamie and Lauren opted to not turn on the Tika's, but considering how many people get blindsided on Survivor for being overly confident, securing your majority while also showing off to the jury is a great movie. Heck, Boston Rob didn't need to use his idol at the Final 5 of Redemption Island since Natalie and Ashley didn't turn on him, but it could've been very possible for Andrea to turn them. Especially Ashley. Plus, who knows how safe Rob would've been at the F4, maybe Philip and the ladies could've turned on him too for all we know... probably not.