Rings of Power is Not Very Good: The Final Autopsy

I play Wow and this is hilarious to see a Tier List applied to Rings of Power.

This is absolutely the worst take of lord of the rings ... they should cancel the series!

You have to learn to care less, to get throught this....

A terrible but more accurate title for the series thus far would have been:
"The Lord of the Rings: Racial tensions throughout middle earth?"

Great analysis.

Galadriel is an idiot OR a terribly written character. When we look at the season as a whole however, it becomes clear that she is in fact a terribly written idiot - this had me dying

Extremely well done. 👏

Why does durin look like nick rekieta so much?

Theo is either a half-elf or full elf because they put way too much effort into keeping his ears covered.

Love the films….didnt like the books,….. not watched the series but enjoyed this, ty

With your take… maybe do remake comparisons…..

👍🏻

Just watching this and if you’re still taking suggestions please do a series on the Netflix show “Arcane”, I believe you will enjoy watching as a fan and talking about it as a critic. Plus season 2 is due to come out in November.

Thank you Sir! For all that you do for us, the suffering and sacrifice. God Speed.

galdalf

Tolkien’s elves were dark haired, with exception of one family of golden haired elves.

It’s OK for Gandalf to decide to “follow his nose”, as people often employ catch phrases

I love your videos man, I started watching with season 2, and i can't stop! The points you make are fair and you express extremely well what I have been feeling while watching this show but couldn't explain. Thank you for your work!

If we're taking info from the Silmarillion, the reason why everyone takes orders from Galadriel is that she's their elder. Basically, Celebrimbor is her youngest cousin, Gil-galad is her nephew and Elrond is Celeborn's nephew, a couple of times removed. Obviously that doesn't work at all with this set up, but they seem to have left her with the privileges of an elder statesman even if they don't know why. And of course that adds to the whole wtf-ness of the whole thing.

I'm glad you bring up something like George of the Jungle, because it's always a touch frustrating when objections of consistency of logic are dismissed as "it's fantasy" or some such. Because even an intentionally absurd film and world still needs to have a firm grasp on reality so it can maximise the contrast between the sensible and nonsensical.

You know what the Nori and Gandalf stuff is totally extraneous but I'll be damned if I don't feel relief when that plot comes back around because it at least has something approaching heart and feeling. The other characters just stand in front of something pretty and have bland dour conversations. Nori is like the only character that seems to be awake!

They’re 100% gonna make Keman and Theo Nazgûl which infuriates me more than anything else in this show

excellent analysis. refreshingly objective compaired to the usual narcisistic torrent of mild funny stuff from popular review channels.

Finally rewatching extended edition fellowship of the ring, watching your videos has really help me appreciate the small details, like just how friendly gandoff and frodo are genuinely extremely friendly and close to each other in the beginning

Just here to say I have just finished rewatching your awesome Season 1 breakdown in preparation for your Season 2 breakdown
And it might be the first time I've felt genuine excitement about anything RoP related

You listing off every instance where consequences didn't happen and then asking questions that haven't been answered is pretty damning, lol.

elendil, durin jr and disa are by far the best actors in this show.

Why do you assume that skin color in fantasy is a sign of geographic origin? That’s not part of the lore. You’re just making bigoted assumptions. That’s pretty stupid. Do better.

I so wanted this to work but no just no

Have you seen hunters on prime

Your dedication is commendable! thank you!!

Thumbs up! Enjoying your analysis of both seasons.

I am writing this comment to support your channel and thank you very much for your hard work.

Wrong.

You have more than earned the subscription

horses ride 6 days non-stop is impossible... [plot hole]

thumbs up!

To add more comments for the algoritm: Galadriel has to believe the volcano to be part of an evil plan, because shes a fanatic and wants everything she believes to be a sign a sign. Sadly shes correct all the time (by accident), so she doesnt realize how insane she became.

The whole Dam plot is so fucking dumb 😂

Slight mistake: Waldreg is clearly in perfect tier.

😂😂

The only good Christmas movie?
What about It’s A Wonderful Life!?

Have you seen the second season? jumping up and down whyle trying to withold a laugh

i agree,,, you put at least twice as much thought into this than they did ,,,,,, problem is they get payed and we have to watch this sh**,,, good luck + likes ;)

👏👍

Die Hard, the only good Christmas movie?!?!?!?! That is a throwaway line that could start a war.

is it bad im excited for a season 3/4/5 just so i can watch more of you take it apart

"Poppy mostly inoffensive." That didn't age well lol. Unfortunately the writers thought we always need two Hobbits.

Lago didn't hurt his ankle on purpose. The wizard broke his foot with the stick!

If there is a master’s degree related to script writing, producing or whatnot, I’m sure you could use this show as a foundation on “what not to do”.