Nvidia's DLSS 2 vs. AMD's FSR 2 in 26 Games, Which Looks Better? - The Ultimate Analysis

Nvidia's DLSS 2 vs. AMD's FSR 2 in 26 Games, Which Looks Better? - The Ultimate Analysis

Hardware Unboxed

1 год назад

255,895 Просмотров

Ссылки и html тэги не поддерживаются


Комментарии:

Macgyver Freitas
Macgyver Freitas - 04.10.2023 22:07

Are you going to revisit this question with FSR3?

Ответить
Jp 297
Jp 297 - 26.09.2023 10:16

If it weren't for DLSS I would never buy another Nvidia card again.

Ответить
druout1944
druout1944 - 24.09.2023 05:40

neither; they both blurry vs native

Ответить
JoshuaJSlone
JoshuaJSlone - 18.09.2023 17:51

Since it's basically established that comparing like-with-like settings DLSS always beats out FSR2, especially at lower resolutions, I'd be curious to see how far that advantage takes it. Like, a comparison among multiple games of how FSR2 Performance mode compares with DLSS Ultra Performance mode. Or FSR2 Quality vs DLSS Performance.

Ответить
BrotherO4
BrotherO4 - 18.09.2023 16:28

question, does higher frame rates help with image artifacts compared to lower framerate?

Ответить
Zenzuu
Zenzuu - 14.09.2023 11:43

It's kind of sad how the main focus nowadays, especially regarding GPUs, is all about DLSS/FSR upscaling technology talk. We get new games that barely look or sometimes even worse and run a lot poorer than games that were released prior, which look and run better without having to rely on these upscaling technologies. A game like Starfield doesn't offer anything special visually to justify the huge performance cost and hardware requirements.

Ответить
commonsense 200
commonsense 200 - 08.09.2023 02:49

while fsr wolud gain quite a bit from improvement on lower resolution upscaling, it also needs to be noted that players who are gaming at 1440p with performance mode, are probably using a really old card, and are not concerned as much about absolute perfect graphics. most new cards should be able to run 1440p with the fsr ultra quality settings, instead of quality.

Ответить
Roman Mayer
Roman Mayer - 07.09.2023 18:28

I was able to watch only half of this video and came to the conclusion that all these differences between FSR / DLSS can only be seen on the 3rd 4th attempt with X3 video zoom. And all the advantages / disadvantages are sucked from the finger.
As a result: I will buy what will be cheaper with good performance.

Ответить
Ravi Peiris
Ravi Peiris - 04.09.2023 09:26

I purchased the 12 gigabyte 4070 ti over the 16 gigabyte offerings from AMD. One of the compelling reasons is because of Nvidia's DLSS as I just jumped from playing on 1080p to 4k and I need as much fps as I can get 😮.

Ответить
Acconda
Acconda - 29.08.2023 16:55

at the 6m:37s mark you mentioned something interesting, which is what I always wondered previously, that 4k performance is better than 1440p quality! so I was previously wondering 7900xtx or 4090 for 3440x1440p UW OLED monitor. Now I am wondering should I just go 4K! however then I would need to wait until end of Q1 2024, as I would not be happy with anything less than the upcoming 27 / 32" oled 4k monitors. damn hard decisions

Ответить
Zingg
Zingg - 29.08.2023 02:30

Pointless comparison. You should have compared fps not a software defined “quality”.

Ответить
David Kerr
David Kerr - 28.08.2023 09:33

All NextGen games will use FSR on Console, because of how demanding games are becoming especially UE5.

Ответить
David Kerr
David Kerr - 28.08.2023 04:10

you cant beat FSR, just like Gsync and Freesync opensource always wins.
the fact that Frame Generation in is exclusive to 4000 series, yet AMD is bringing support to all GPUs tell you all you need to know.

Ответить
Leonard Petty
Leonard Petty - 28.08.2023 01:24

Why use upscaling when you can set the monitor as you want to 1440p or higher have rx 7900 xtx 24 gb

Ответить
Stephan
Stephan - 27.08.2023 08:04

I tried fsr for a bit, and if you're looking for shimmering then you will find it, but if all I do is play the game then there are only 2 things that bothered me. If the game has a really good implementation of TAA, then fsr is a bit blurrier. This I noticed in Deep Rock Galactic, not so much Cyberpunk, and in DRG the textures aren't exactly necessary. The other thing is that fsr doesn't really know what to do with smoke of most kinds. Besides that no worthwhile complaints, dlss is better, but if amd has other features you want (like lots of vram) then fsr is fine for now. The real problem is that nvidia isn't done adding stuff like this new ray construction so fsr could fall behind more.

FSR seems to throw away temporal data a little too quick in cyberpunk for distant rails and wires as soon as they move, but this didn't bother me when actually playing. Sharpening at 100% makes the rails usually still visible, but still too thin, but I only noticed if I was looking for a problem.

Also, DRG has like really good TAA.

Ответить
RHD Benchmarks
RHD Benchmarks - 25.08.2023 21:40

As someone who plays/played NFS Unbound; The version you used for FSR testing has been improved. In release, when going fast, the AA simply disables itself lol

Now, I am excited for DLSS since my new GPU is arriving tomorrow. Always saw DLSS as the much more usable solution for upscaling.

Ответить
Mushroom Hat
Mushroom Hat - 24.08.2023 17:44

Crazy amount of testing from NVIDIA fanboy

Ответить
Chrono Gamer
Chrono Gamer - 20.08.2023 03:37

Man, we are really getting the shaft by not having DLSS in Starfield, aren't we? :)

Ответить
Stephan
Stephan - 07.08.2023 11:51

What do you all think: is FSR good enough that dlss is not a "must have"? imo the issues with fsr are still present in dlss but just not as often or as bad, and I would rather get a cheaper AMD gpu with more vram. Intel could easily take over with xess if they keep up good hardware, but I know intel can be sleezy and untrustworthy. Just look at the 14900k and how it's basically a slightly overclocked 13900k. I hope people know when to recognize this.

Ответить
HarmonicaPL
HarmonicaPL - 04.08.2023 00:21

Is the dlss so good it advocates to buy 4080 instead of 7900 xtx to play in 4K?

Ответить
Ruff
Ruff - 02.08.2023 04:33

I have a 3070... Is it weird that I find FSR to be clearer than DLSS on Warzone?

Ответить
Ankush Behera
Ankush Behera - 31.07.2023 12:30

Please frs3 vs dlss 3 and dlss fg

Ответить
HRF Dude
HRF Dude - 29.07.2023 21:55

except for the absolute best, the 3090 or 4090 if you can find and afford them, in any other case amds are always the way to go! in most regions of the world an amd card is less than half the price of the equivalent nvidia!
also the performance of an amd is way more consistent, nvidia cards after a while just start acting weird, and no amount of dlss or ray tracing could compensate that!

Ответить
ALlixior
ALlixior - 27.07.2023 11:16

In my opinion nvidia works more on dlss cuz they dont actually put the money worth into there hardware from studying a lot of schematics from and and nvidia I can say amd does put more care into their hardware more then nvidia does so yes amd would not have as good of a dlss stand point cuz amd hard can handle abit better without FSR as I have tested both and researched the hardware and professional performance🤔

Ответить
Abdalazeem Al-mashaqba
Abdalazeem Al-mashaqba - 21.07.2023 07:46

Dlss is better..but the free fsr win me

Ответить
Yorki Pudd
Yorki Pudd - 19.07.2023 20:53

Greatly appreciated. Thanks for the effort to make this.

Ответить
Andrej Mazak
Andrej Mazak - 07.07.2023 15:37

cant see adifference

Ответить
Datph 0
Datph 0 - 05.07.2023 10:09

When AC Valhallas in game AA upscaling is better then any game with those feature

Ответить
V S
V S - 05.07.2023 00:09

For the majority of games at 4K I didn't see a difference between the two(Ignoring the labels).

Ответить
SpudCommando
SpudCommando - 02.07.2023 22:57

DLSS looks more blurry, FSR looks sharper.

Ответить
Bender Bending Rodriguez
Bender Bending Rodriguez - 30.06.2023 04:44

Ive never once been satisfied with FSR or the minor performance boost it gives. DLSS allows me to ray trace cyberpunk at 7640 x 1440.
DLSS is significantly better.

Ответить
Charles Horseman
Charles Horseman - 29.06.2023 21:05

It must have taken years to learn how to move your mouth like that when you talk.

Ответить
Francisco Manuel
Francisco Manuel - 29.06.2023 18:55

After watch this video in 4K 60 FPS. My conclusion is that for example I'm not use if you did the convinient AMD sharpening that add extra definition as if Nvidia has a similar tecnology. In another hand, sometimes they look the same. The different is like 1%. And some specific times, it's pretty noticeable in your video. But that in a normal gameplay, it's hard to realize about those issues specially in quality mode. Sometimes they are very evident, but again, depends if we focus in a specific area. What I may is that in the game I used FSR, I didn't felt I'm lossing big amount of quality or big amount of experience of my game. Also Nvidia games sponsored, they still works great with AMD. Since my last setting in cyberpunk in preset High quality, the game just works good and visuality is pretty great in 1080p. Also other games as Century age of ages or Dead island 2, both works well using their technologies and options.

Ответить
Francisco Manuel
Francisco Manuel - 29.06.2023 12:43

Hi, my monitor is 1080p. My Internet can deal only with 1080p 60. I gonna download to watch to 4K 60 and previously I watched the whole video. Apparently it's true FSR it isn't better. Aside of that in my experience using FSR in 1080p, I didn't feel games are unplayable, they are still pretty. I didn't test DLSS, so I cannot judge much about it. I believe, even if it's worse FSR, it's fine, I'm able to enjoy games using AMD technologies. I knew about this when I choosed AMD vs Nvidia. I'm happy with my AMD GPU. ^^

Still I'll try to check to max quality video these tests.

And my opinion is in general that if it's possible I would run native. But in Cyberpunk 2077 for example, this games just it's fine using FSR. On the end, only when we put high attention to details we realize about differents.

I could have for free an Nvidia or an AMD GPU. Just, other details made me to decide AMD, even for future security because nvidia GPU weren't new, the Nvidia GPU my brother offered to me. But the AMD GPU was new.

Ответить
KukiGraph
KukiGraph - 27.06.2023 22:37

some people say that DLSS is 50% or more better than FSR, they are crazy haha, the truth is that it is not that much, sometimes it looks almost the same in resolutions of 1440p or higher.

Ответить
Kotz Totz
Kotz Totz - 27.06.2023 19:20

I am really wondering what comparisons between balanced modes, especially at 4k.

Ответить
aykut sirma
aykut sirma - 26.06.2023 14:52

So, it is useless to buy AMD graphic cards according to DLSS 2 vs. AMD's FSR 2 comparison where NVIDIA is best to get as it is most expensive? thank you. I will get a monitor for my new GPU (I will buy soon for my new PC) where I cannot decided which GPU should I get: NVIDIA or AMD? thank you.

Is there any support for mmorpg too to use DLSS 2 vs. AMD's FSR 2? thank you.

Would you make a 1080p comparison for DLSS 2 vs. AMD's FSR 2 too? thank you.

Ответить
SciFiViKing
SciFiViKing - 20.06.2023 10:49

FSR looks awful. Like i'm playing a low bitrate game. I hate it.

Ответить
Dead Pixel
Dead Pixel - 16.06.2023 20:05

As many have already stated, the ghosting and blurriness you see in some games when using DLSS is easily fixed by upgrading the DLSS DLL file to 2.5.1. Dead Space remake, for example. Updating to DLSS 2.5.1 completely removes the ghosting and blurred textures. It looks just as good as native resolution.

Ответить
Rob M
Rob M - 05.06.2023 09:41

Hey wait... Did they even mention which GPU's they had this test running on?

Ответить
OperatorPuski
OperatorPuski - 30.05.2023 06:04

I'm kinda confused on these tests. I'm assuming the results are being displayed on a 4k monitor? What are the initial render resolutions being used for the baseline? When you say lowering render resolution, to what level or percentage are they being lowered to? I also think screenshots with spotlight the specific artifact, ghosting, or shimmer effect will show better on video.

Ответить
Kelsipher Zatozia
Kelsipher Zatozia - 29.05.2023 18:38

The problem I have with DLSS is that it's just flat out blurry on a 2560x1440 monitor using the DLSS Quality setting.
Also DLSS suffers pretty bad from the trailing edge of objects creating a noticeable ghosting effect.
So for faster moving games like MWII that also require a sharper image, FSR2.1 is just better.

Ответить
Lucromis
Lucromis - 28.05.2023 20:58

Most games release with older fsr versions from my experience. That’s the main factor why dlss is better, it seems even earlier versions of both the dlss is better and fsr has caught up but I rarely play a title with fsr 2.0 or better.

Ответить
A H
A H - 26.05.2023 16:34

There was no need to test in the same quality setting - the result is absolutely evident without test.
You should test DLSS 2 Balanced vs FSR 2 Quality, and DLSS 2 Performance vs FSR 2 Balanced.

Ответить
Adam Martin
Adam Martin - 24.05.2023 17:48

The Problem is that they are both very good and you have to be picking them apart to notice which does not happen when you're playing aka (Real-World Scenarios) applies here so while DLSS is better do you need it? No because you're just not going to notice!!!

Ответить
Via_Negativa
Via_Negativa - 24.05.2023 15:47

Don't really care how they look but Dlss always seems to get me more frames.

Ответить
Raffa's Dimple
Raffa's Dimple - 23.05.2023 06:54

Guys, 1080p

Ответить
FrostyBud777
FrostyBud777 - 13.05.2023 10:51

I’m so glad I’ve got a 7900 XTX. I love FSR compared to DLS in cyberpunk. I never like using DLSS in cyberpunk because of the bad ghosting. Now I use FSR and everything is much better. Playing 4K with medium ray tracing at 80 to 90 FPS most of the time with this card. So thankful

I have been Nvidia fan boy for years over 15, and I’m finally glad I went team red. $1200 for a 4080 is ridiculous. I went with a 7900 XTX for 999 on new egg but was also eyeing up to 6950 XT for $630

Ответить
Rhadoo RootBwoy
Rhadoo RootBwoy - 11.05.2023 10:14

Conclusion: DLSS looks better than FSR. I'm not surprised by this, as AMD's algorithm seems way less complex than NVIDIA's AI based solution.

Ответить