WHO KILLED WHO in Scream 4 (2011)

Alright Scream team, you know the routine. Who was Charlie and who was Jill?

Jill: you got the body i got the 🧠

at the risk of going ape shit...only thing I disagree with is the three murders at the house. in that scene, the physicality of the Ghostface there after stabbing Perkins seems a bit different and much "smaller" than during the other murders (in an intentional way in terms of how that scene is shot). so either Jill solo or Jill+Charlie. but hey, that's just a theory.

Charlie never said that he was responsible for Kate’s death. I get what Jill said but like how could it be certain that Charlie did it because what she said doesn’t really tell us who was responsible.

This is my idea... when the cops explain to Dewey about the person down the street and one going around, they were lying. They both went the same direction. As with the scene you stated, Dewey had timed them and made mention of them going from front and back, notice when Sid fights the killer after Jill is cut, both cops come through the front door. If one had went around, they would've seen the killer leaving. So I think they made up the line about going around to cut him off(to cover their butts with Dewey), making it far easier for him to get back to Olivia.
Those two deputies were goofy and kinda lazy anyway, not like they were really trying to look for a killer. People are dead and they're joking and playing games and everything else right up until they die.
And of course now we know that Kirby survived.

I was do research on the location of Jill's house and the barn where the stab a thon was filmed and if we are to assume that the timing is like how it is in real life, then the time it would take to walk from one to the other, would be: 4 + 1/2 to 5 + 1/2 hours.
Also, in the film, the cops die before Kate enters the house, so the open window could have been Jill who hopped out the window and got into costume, killed Deputy Hoss and Perkins, then ran around to kill Kate.
To me, this is the timeline:
-After school, Charlie and Robbie drove out to the barn and set up the Stab-a-thon
-Jill is locked in her room
-Everyone then starts to head to the party
-Gale enters and is exploring to find the best places for her cameras
-Hoss and Perkins make their rounds
-Jill comes out of the bushes and kills them and leaves their bodies in the car
-Kate enters the house with some shopping
-Sidney reads the news of Gale's attack from Charlie
-Kate goes back out for the last bag of shopping and see the cops car isn't there as Jill drove it down the street
-Jill then gets picked up from Kirby and hangs out there for a bit together until Charlie and Robbie get there with Trevor getting there approx. 5mins later.

this is so intresting because the wiki actually gives her 7 kills so i guess she was the intended killer. id love to see a breakdown trying to make that possible

The last bit from Scooby Doo was HYSTERICAL because Matthew Lillard is in Five Nights at Freddy's and he plays William Afton who killed kids but then is thwarted by their ghosts they become the meddling kids! HAHHHAHAHAAHAA That's good!!!!

My opinion on watching scream 4 and who i think killed who:

Marnie: Charlie
Jennie: Charlie
Olivia: Charlie
Rebecca: Jill
Cops: Jill
Kate: Charlie
Robby: Charlie
Trevor: Jill
Charlie: Jill

Jill: 5 kills
Charlie: 5 kills

I refuse to believe that Jill didn’t get her hands dirty before her reveal.

I mean, how could she handle that knife so well when killing Charlie and stabbing Sidney?

If you get can get everyone that you want dead and pin it on the other person... that in no way makes you an inferior Ghostface. THe opposite in fact.

Scream 3 is often considered the only scream with 1 killer but actually this one has 1 killer too because Charlie does all the heavy lifting

seeing this makes me realize that nancy and jill were masterminds... but amber was really the ultimate (amd underrated) female ghostface.

Where's the scream 6 who killed who

Randy’s still alive OMG and he even proved saying he loves horror

Better Ending: both sidney and jill both wake up and chase back and forth and when they go outside kirby runs jill over with her car

If Kirby was able to survive off screen and come back in Scream 6, Angelina will be the killer in Scream 7. In my script anyway.

bro ur doing much on Charlie... How did Jill know where Gale got stabbed in... ofc it was Jill who attacked Gale in The Stabathon

This might be a hot take but
I think Charlie stabbed Kirby and Jill killed Trevor

I think Jill is the one who stabbed Gale at the Stabathon. She texts Kirby to pick her up, obviously she is at the stabathon and will later. Jill tells Sid she'll go to her room. Sneaks out, obviously Hoss and Perkins find the window open. Jill sneaks to the stabathon. Charlie was the host of the stabathon, so it'd be pretty obvious if he went off. Besides when Jill was in the hospital in the end. She told Dewey her and Gale would write a book together with their matching shoulder wounds. The only way Jill would know that Gale was stabbed in the shoulder, would be Jill had to be the one to attack her at the stabathon. When Dewey breaks up the stabathon. Jill sneaks out the back, heads back to her house. Obviously, her mom isn't there because she'a grocery shopping, as shown to Sid near the end of the movie. As Jill is heading back to the house, she runs up on Hoss and Perkins, killing them. Kirby probably didn't leave the stabathon right away as seen as a group of people are watching Dewey shoot up at Ghostface. She probably stayed around to find out what happened. So as Jill is killing Hoss and Perkins, Charlie has probably already left and probably told Kirby he'd meet up with her at her house, but instead helps Jill move the bodies of Hoss and perkins into the car and drive them 2 blocks down. While Charlie is moving the car and bodies of Hoss and Perkins. Jill is meeting at the end of the street where she told Kirby to pick her up. Charlie stays around the house. Jills mom comes home. Charlie calls Sid and she and Jills mother try to run. He runs around the house. They shut the door. He stabs Jills mom. He obviously runs off not wanting to be caught by sheriff Hicks who is running around the side of the house. So Charlie is probably now on his way to Kirby's, as so is Sid because she read Jills messages earlier and knew where she'd be. So Sid takes Hicks car and drives to Kirby's. Charlie left as soon as he killed Jill's mom giving him a head start before Sid because she was talking to Hicks before she left. So Charlie arrives at Kirby's as did Kirby and Jill a little bit before them. Robbie probably rode with Kirby. Robbie is pissed about the stabathon being ruined, he gets drunk walks around outside. Trevor walks in and says Jill texted him, she goes upstairs to Kirby's room to get her phone to prove she didn't text him. Trevor runs off trying to find Jill. Jill is actually outside killing Robbie, while Charlie is distracting Kirby by almost hooking up with her. Even tho Kirby is the one to iniciate the hookup, it's still a distraction for Kirby not to go looking for anyone. Trevor who went upstairs to find Jill, who isn't there because she's outside killing Robbie. Trevor cock blocks Charlie. Charlie gets pissed and walks off. Which gives him to put his ghostface costume on. After Kirby asks why Trevor is still at her house. Trevor probably then tries to find Jill again, now she's returned upstairs to make it look lije she's looking for her phone the whole time. Trevor runs into Charlie outside, who knocks him out and ties him up. Kirby goes to find Jill coming down the stairs saying Trevor is a liar i didn't text him, Kirby says well he went looking for you and Jill says she hasn't seen him since she went looking for her phone. So as Sidney shows up at Kirby's door and tells Jill to come with her. Robbie appears around the corner stumbling and bleeding out, charlie who was already outside and dealt with Trevor pops up around the corner. Sid and Jill run upstairs. Kirby takes off to the basemement. Sid climbs out the window as Jill hides under the bed. Charlie chases Sid out the window and around the corner. While all this is happening. Jill leaves the bedroom to probably to put trevor in the kitchen closet. Sid runs back around inside the house where Kirby runs into and tells her to come to the basement and hide. Charlie then takes off the costume, runs to the basement doors and tells Kirby he found Robbie. At this point it's pretty obvious Jill calls Kirby and plays the horror movie trivia game to make it look like she's about to Kill Charlie, but was all a distraction for Kirby. So Jill is in the house calling Kirby while Charlie is tied up to a chair. Sid runs back upstairs to find the Jill is no longer under the bed, while Kirby is distracted by the phone call from ghost face. Kirby ends the phone call with a list of movies thinking she wins, when it was just to get Charlie to kill her. So as Sidney is headed back down the stairs. Charlie stabs Kirby, walks off. He clearly walks back around to the front of the house as Sid appears at the basement door calling for Kirby and then Charlie grabs her and as she tries to get away after slamming him into the door, Jill pops around the corner, as she clearly has been in the house the whole time, clearly because she wasn't under the bed where Sid left her and there was a phone call made to Kirby. After they're both revealed. You all know how it goes from there. But other than that you're right about who killed who before then.

It made the most sense

I felt like jill was the one who attacked gale

Fax

Man, you talk exactly like James from Dead Meat...

I, probably the only one that likes Charlie more than jolt

3 years later kirby lives and is ready to fight back

this man is literally randy meeks irl 😭

It’s funny because Kirby survived as we see in scream 6

lol charlie did everything

I believe that Jill killed Deputy Hoss, Deputy Perkins, and Kate because she sneaks out of her bedroom window while waiting for Kirby to pick her up, and kills those three people.

3&4 are the worst of the movies

jill killed her mom and the cops and then met up with kirby

didnt jill at the end of the movie in the hospital admit to attacking gale?

Just to make more sense of who the killer is behind the mask in the movie, I think they should make the height of the stuntman who played ghostface be the exact height of the actors who played the killers

Honestly, I agree with Zack where he said that Jill was not the most likely killer to get away with it because she talked to much and couldn’t keep her story straight which I would agree with. The Only person who I actually think would’ve had the best chance to get away with it is Nancy Loomis .

Olivia was the hottest in Scream 4 but I think that in the end Charlie kinda lied to make Jill think he was really powerful as to the Olivia kill

Filmed In 2010.

This video is so wrong it's not even funny.

Rebecca Hoss Perkins and Kate's Killer: Jill.

Jenny Marnie Olivia and Robbie's Killer: Charlie.

I used to believe that Jill killed the cops and the other two guys at the end, but my opinion changed when i realized Charlie had the gun in act 3. However, even though she didnt kill the cops, i think she killed Rebecca. I can see why people think Charlie, since its also possible. Both of them dont have an alibi during her attack. Some people can argue that and say Jill was in the hospital and was possibly surrounded by her mom, Trevor, and cops. But i think she could have easily slipped past them considering how good she did it in the 4th act. And even with a small cut on her arm, we know Jill has endurance and doesnt care about the physical pain shes in as long as she gets to her goal. I dont think she is strong enough to carry Rebecca up to the top of the building. Even though she is stronger than she looks and might have done it herself, she would have probably been seen. But contrary to that, i also think Charlie might not have the strength to do it himself either. Since both Charlie and Jill arent seen, I think both of them could have carried or took turns carrying the body while the other is a lookout.

But thats just my personal theory, i also know Charlie could have also killed Rebecca because he is also not seen. I just like to think they were working together more than the movie makes it seem, since it portrays Jill as sweet and innocent till the end wheres shes borderline psycho/sociopath. I also think jill made the calls in the intro while charlie did the killing, it would imply Jill was more of the brains and Charlie was more of the brawns and did things for Jill. Charlie is easily manipulated from how in love he is with Jill. Even though I believe Jill only got 2-3 kills, it makes sense for them both to be very involved and Jill leading Charlie from behind while he does the killings and she plans it.

And even if Jill only got 2 kills at minimum, i think shes a really smart and tough gf. I also think Charlie is one of the most brutal and they compliment each other. imo they're my fav gf duo and the most closest to achieving their goal of making another live remake movie (Charlie) and getting fame from it (Jill).

On to another point, and you can change my mind if youd like, but i think its a little tone deaf to say that Jill is useless and did nothing. She might not have stabbed people with a knife, but Charlie most likely wouldn't have killed all those people if he wasnt in love with Jill. Jill is the idea and brains behind the whole killing spree, certian people had to die at certian times (sidney, gales attack, rebecca, jenny, olivia) and Jill is the one closest enough to be able to think of a working plan. I think Charlie is more smarter in the movie aspects of the killings, mainly because he runs the cinema club and most likely knows what the viewers want and is willing to do the dirty work. Its confirmed that Jill and Charlie talk a lot more and communicate secretly during the 3rd act when they say they should stab each other like how they practiced. And since they were "secretly dating" they spent way more time together planning this than the audience would think.

Lmao Jill did nothing. Imo Charlie was responsible for all the kills.

Jill said it herself - Trevor "Did all the work for her" and Charlie was the "idea", meaning that she was the brains and Charlie did the entire work

I feel like the gun is a pretty big giveaway that it was Charlie who murdered the cops, we don't know how far Stabathon is from Jills house, it's entirely possible he ran or even just stole a vehicle. In order for Charlie to end up with the gun if Jill killed the cops they would have had to meetup alone at some point which doesn't make a whole ton of sense if Kirby drove Jill

Your explanation makes so much sense Zack because when reviewing the footage the police would have seen that the killer had a much frame so it makes sense that Jill made Charlie do all the killing and the only kills that she did weren’t on camera

I want your Friday 3D shirt lol

jill was just smarty