The secret formula to Agatha Christie's murder mysteries - Jamie Bernthal

The secret formula to Agatha Christie's murder mysteries - Jamie Bernthal

TED-Ed

1 год назад

712,899 Просмотров

Ссылки и html тэги не поддерживаются


Комментарии:

MsDinoGal
MsDinoGal - 24.10.2023 17:08

I liked the part where you took digs at her work for “reinforcing stereotypes” so no one in the comments could criticize YOU for not doing it. True academic courage right there.

Ответить
Daphne Solomon
Daphne Solomon - 24.10.2023 10:50

Which was the book she won her sister's bet with though? Was it The Murder of Roger Ackroyd? That one is brilliant

Ответить
CreamoLeaf
CreamoLeaf - 22.10.2023 09:48

The murder of Roger Ackroyd will forever hold a special place in my heart. It is the kind of book that makes me wosh it is possible to momentarily forget a story, just so I can experience the act of reading and discovering it once again.

Ответить
Sjinzaar
Sjinzaar - 22.10.2023 09:44

Compliments to the animation team doing this video. Thank you!❤

Ответить
Banannakis
Banannakis - 21.10.2023 12:03

I think I heard once that one of the reasons she did two-dimensional characters was because when she did more fleshed-out characters in (The Mysterious Affair At Styles) people either figured it out too easily or claimed that another character made better sense as the killer. Also, I believe it was more work and time-consuming. Instead keeping things simple and the whole less is more philosophy clearly sold more books.

Ответить
Jannette Berends
Jannette Berends - 20.10.2023 22:55

Two dimensional people? She gave the best descriptions of psychopaths ever. The charming young man, the kid that murders because it wants something, the CEOs, the nice tomboy girl. The false confession also there. Some books are a study in psychology.

Ответить
Helena McGinty
Helena McGinty - 19.10.2023 11:25

I like Christie for the same reason I play match 3 games on my phone. To distract from real life.
Her writing has no depth although her sense of humour often shows through. I have always found her racism and classism unpleasant. Later books became boring. Very samey.
But along with Sayers et al these moneyed women had the contacts to get published and the time and leisure to write.
They were not cleaning, cooking, nappy changing, washing clothes all day either for their own families or people like Christie.
But neither were they afforded the privilged education that men of their era had which gave us some great novelists like Green and Waugh.

Ответить
Mark Macrone
Mark Macrone - 25.07.2023 21:44

You forgot to add author MAX STRAVAGAR he's the William Shakespeare of our times!

Ответить
zig zig 🔮
zig zig 🔮 - 07.07.2023 14:50

My family loved the Poirot and Marple tv series! 📺 I watched them with my family. Good memories. ❤️

Ответить
Sidharth Kumar
Sidharth Kumar - 18.05.2023 10:51

Seriously?! You people are now digging out their secret writing recipes and revealing to everyone.❤

Ответить
inne putteneers
inne putteneers - 26.04.2023 01:39

By now we can ask chatGPT

Ответить
Dark & Twisted
Dark & Twisted - 17.04.2023 20:13

Brilliant! For the love of all of us writers, please continue this series.👍

Ответить
Aff
Aff - 14.04.2023 18:44

Spite is an incredible motivator

Ответить
Ashley Centilles
Ashley Centilles - 26.03.2023 07:50

I really love christie 🥺🫶

Ответить
Montecinos Pavez
Montecinos Pavez - 18.03.2023 21:26

Who are you to say: "Agatha Cristi got it wrong"? Your prejudices are not hers or mine.

Ответить
Reinar Foreman
Reinar Foreman - 10.03.2023 16:49

Best selling doesn't always mean good, though.

Ответить
Raskolnikov
Raskolnikov - 03.03.2023 21:36

i love miss marple more than Poirot

Ответить
Barnacle
Barnacle - 28.02.2023 07:05

ted-ed can you do terry pratchett's discworld next🥺🥺

Ответить
Shivam
Shivam - 14.02.2023 19:33

Vast spans have passed. Ten springs...yet yester evening it is. The Sun is waning...and there dwell we! Amid the mulberry trees, upon the green grass, wind caressing us, her hair gracing my face. I smell her fragrance now. How may I forget her? By what cause does one cease to think of their essence, the source of their being? Every passing moment, I perceive her. Her unearthly beauty, an eternal blooming flower, how the moon rises through her grace, how her melodic laugh causes spiritual awakenings in sages, how I attain the prime paradise of merriment by embracing her, I perceive each of these moments. In our faith, the ultimate purpose is salvation. Enlightened beings sunder from the sorrows of the world and merge unto the Supreme. Yet I seek not such enlightenment. My salvation is she only. To abide with her eternally, that is the bliss I desire.

This is a dialogue I wrote for a tragedy I'm developing. It concerns a man who after losing his lover has sworn an oath to defeat the God of Death and bring his lover back. Here specifically he is remembering her on the eve of a battle.
Was it nice? Can I hope to write a masterpiece someday? Also criticisms are welcome 🖤

Ответить
Aditya Mozumdar
Aditya Mozumdar - 06.01.2023 00:33

Thanks for spoiling Five Little Pigs for me... I am still halfway through that book🥶🤣😢

Ответить
Kimmy Cassie
Kimmy Cassie - 15.12.2022 16:38

This might be the sign to start reading Agatha Christie. I only know Murder on the Orient Express from the movie (which from what I know is adapted a bit differently)

Ответить
Capt Syam
Capt Syam - 27.11.2022 06:56

Agatha Christi novels were my favourite during college days, these were available in translated version in Malayalam, thanks to my friend Venu chettan who had the entire collection. Congratulations to Ananthu for bringing these memories back, best wishes

Ответить
ইসলামিক পেইজ
ইসলামিক পেইজ - 16.11.2022 10:09

Agatha Christie is a crime Queen

Ответить
Kirstine Termansen
Kirstine Termansen - 27.10.2022 15:30

Thanks and pay Please

Ответить
Mollie Tenpenny
Mollie Tenpenny - 25.10.2022 07:15

How to write like Agatha Christie:
Step 1. Have a sibling rivalry....

Ответить
Maryo Cecilyo
Maryo Cecilyo - 16.10.2022 19:28

Obrigado!

Ответить
Mahatapa Chakraborty
Mahatapa Chakraborty - 16.10.2022 16:31

❤❤❤

Ответить
McKenna Williams
McKenna Williams - 13.10.2022 22:10

I feel proud of myself that I can pinpoint which books the examples are from

Ответить
Reymart Bara
Reymart Bara - 11.10.2022 17:21

Im just a reader, but now i know why i like the story lol

Ответить
Zander Craft
Zander Craft - 08.10.2022 14:36

Hi! I love you channel and have question for you:
Can you make, please, vid about Shirley Jackson? She is my favorite author)
(Sorry for bad English)

Ответить
Tech Ruchin
Tech Ruchin - 27.09.2022 17:22

Harry Potter is the bestselling book of all time. All potterheads leave a like.

Ответить
Squidbucket Team
Squidbucket Team - 11.09.2022 15:35

Rian Johnson be like:

Ответить
impostory
impostory - 08.09.2022 12:07

Pretty sure Bibble and Quran is the best selling book

Ответить
Invox
Invox - 02.09.2022 01:04

I'm sorry, Jazus is the best-selling of all time. Have you ever thought about how many bibles have been sold? 😅

Ответить
ruhan dasgupta
ruhan dasgupta - 30.08.2022 18:52

Madge on her way to make agatha so mad that she becomes a bestselling author: I’ve won, but at what cost?

Ответить
Richard Philbin
Richard Philbin - 28.08.2022 04:07

"Best selling" should be two words in this case.

Ответить
As The Name Suggests
As The Name Suggests - 27.08.2022 10:02

Goodness I love her so so much

Ответить
juleenar c
juleenar c - 27.08.2022 08:13

I wud like to call Dan Brown as her descendant when it comes to story telling..... the part where the readers think that they have found the culprit but later understand their assumptions were wrong.

Ответить
Snakeybakey
Snakeybakey - 26.08.2022 20:11

I love how far the woke part of the video, Ted Ed shows the books burning. Ironically quite self-aware.

Ответить
Roger Phillips
Roger Phillips - 26.08.2022 18:50

My mom read every one of her novels several times over!

Ответить
Evolin dica
Evolin dica - 26.08.2022 11:07

Just remember that every sentence and descriptions in her stories are indispensable.

Ответить
Aesya Mazeli
Aesya Mazeli - 26.08.2022 05:47

I like her because people who die is always people of wealth. I don't care about poor people dying, it's a dime and dozen in the real world.

Ответить
Gökhan Zengin
Gökhan Zengin - 25.08.2022 12:24

Nice video.

Ответить
Gavin Gleemonex
Gavin Gleemonex - 25.08.2022 04:37

King James theologist is the best selling author of all time. The scenario in this video is untrue.

Ответить
Contul meu Google
Contul meu Google - 24.08.2022 22:12

still not better than Jules Verne.

Ответить
Plasma Nightmare
Plasma Nightmare - 24.08.2022 10:42

YES

Ответить
Primus Torus
Primus Torus - 23.08.2022 20:20

It is a bit of a mystery how most of Christie's books on Goodreads are below the hallowed 4.00 rating average. At least there her books are underrated and not overrated. The handful of Sophie Hannah books, written with the blessing of the Agatha Christie estate, prove that Christie was a genius and most writers, including Hannah are not as good as the former.
Just try to read the Monogram Murders a new Poirot mystery to see how easy Christie made writing look.

Ответить
A.R.S.
A.R.S. - 23.08.2022 15:08

I’m one of those people that loved her plots but hated her writing style

Ответить