The Mandalorian: Season 3... Why It Sucks

The Mandalorian: Season 3... Why It Sucks

The Gold Man

1 год назад

115,535 Просмотров

The Mandalorian Season 3 brings to us the return of The Mandalorian and Grogu as the embark on an adventure to retake Mandalore from the evil Empire and Moff Gideon only on Disney Plus. This season of Star Wars: The Mandalorian heavily features the likes of The Armorer but more prominently Bo Katan Kryze. With Star Wars: The Mandalorian Season 3 focusing mostly on Din Djarin, Grogu, and Bo Katan, how did the season turn out. In this video essay, I discuss the newest Star Wars season The Mandalorian Season 3 and Why It's NOT Great.

Chapters:
0:00 - The Mandalorian: Season 3... Why It's NOT Great
0:48 - The Cloud of Boba Fett
5:50 - Episodes 1-5
17:35 - Episode 6
22:57 - Episode 7&8
34:10 - A Future Bright or Dim?

For business inquiries please email:
[email protected]

Music:
-80s Retrowave Music - Hackers Royalty Free No Copyright
-A.L.I.S.O.N - Golden Dust
-My White Daisy
-Star Wars The Book of Boba Fett Theme EPIC ORCHESTRAL VERSION (from Samuel Kim Music)
-Star Wars The Mandalorian Theme EPIC VERSION (from Samuel Kim Music)

✪ Thumbnail ✪
-Render Driver: https://instagram.com/renderdriver

For business inquiries email: [email protected]

❗️WANT TO WATCH MORE OF ME?❗️
-Gold Man Gaming: coming soon
-Man of Gold: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCo0gSn_jGnw_pwfTvPH7xjQ
-Twitter: https://twitter.com/TheGoldMan25

The Mandalorian Season 3 brings to us the return of our favorite Mandalorian and Yoda esque duo in Star Wars. After the somewhat negative reception of the book of boba fett, many fans were either skeptical of this new season of the mandalorian or excited for Star Wars to get back to some high level storytelling. With the promise of retaking Mandalore, there was a lot to be excited about. With that being said, how did the Mandalorian Season 3 turn out? Was it as good as the previous two seasons? Was the dark cloud of the book of boba fett too much to overcome? Did the season do a good job at progressing the Mandoverse? Hello everybody and welcome to another video, my name is the gold man and today we are going to talk about the mandalorian season 3.
Before we discuss The Mandalorian Season 3, we need to discuss the giant dark cloud that hangs over this season. And that is the Book of Boba Fett. If you watched my Book of Boba Fett 1 year later video I made a few months back, you would know I have a strong hatred for the series. There are a lot of Star Wars shows and movies I don’t like. The Bad Batch is one for example. I may dislike it, but at least I can say it’s its own series that is completely harmless. Or a movie like Solo, a fine movie that doesn’t do any harm to anyone. I cannot say the same thing about the book of boba fett. Sure most of the series is inconsequential. Like what happened with the war on Tatooine as of right now doesn’t affect anything else. But the decisions they made with Mando and his story have great consequences. Firstly, as we all know it greatly diminishes the ending of Mando season 2. Mando and Grogu’s emotional goodbye was now undone only a year later. Now at the time I came to terms with the fact that Mando season 2 was kinda diminished, but I had optimism that this decision wouldn’t ruin Mando season 3. I thought that they would surely explain that Mando and Grogu were reunited in a different show. And for viewers that didn’t watch Book of Boba, it would be weird for a second but that’ll be it. The story would be able to progress. But boyyyyy was I wrong. The first episode of the season makes no attempt to explain what happened. All we get is Mando saying he completed his mission and then Grogu was returned to him. At the end of the day I get that this is all semantics. If we took the exact episodes of the book of boba fett and put them under “The Mandalorian” title, then this wouldn’t be a problem. It’s kinda the same thing about the complaints about there being Mando episodes in Boba Fett. People only complained because the title of the series was “The Book of Boba Fett” and 2 episodes barely featured Boba Fett. So I get those who disagree with me telling me if I ignore show titles this isn’t a problem. Sure it isn’t a problem to me, but again, what about the people who hadn’t watched Boba Fett. Other than the story, what made the mandalorian appealing to so many people was that it was its own story. I know people that watched the first season of the mandalorian when it came out without seeing any of the movies and they understood it perfectly. The Mandalorian was a show that came with no extra baggage. The Mandalorian Season 2 received some criticism for having pre-existing characters show up like Boba Fett, Bo Katan, ahsoka, and Luke. But I’ve always disagreed with this criticism. Yeah I didn’t like seeing Boba Fett, but with the other 3 you didn’t need to know who they were to understand what was going on.

#themandalorian #starwars #videoessay
Ссылки и html тэги не поддерживаются


Комментарии:

@chuni2753
@chuni2753 - 02.02.2024 20:54

Holy shit it really was lizzo? I knew it was jack black but I was only making fun of her by saying she's lizzo.

Ответить
@gabriels9919
@gabriels9919 - 31.01.2024 08:41

Bad batch did everything the mandalorian did but way better while still doing its thing, mando can't hold a candle to it(not lettong the stray slide XD)

Ответить
@Andy-nt3ln
@Andy-nt3ln - 26.01.2024 12:03

I honestly don't know why people didn't like season 3. I thought The Convert episode was waaay too long but other than that I loved it. It was nice to see Bo Katan take charge & follow in her sister's footsteps & lead Mandalore back on the right track.

In my opinion, this is just another case of people wanting to tear stuff down & people with ADHD getting tired of something as they're prone to do. I won't go near The Force Awakens trilogy but I've watched & enjoyed all the Disney+ series. Have they been perfect? No, but nothing is.

Ответить
@Mumbo_Jumbo_Report
@Mumbo_Jumbo_Report - 17.01.2024 21:46

This is exactly why I’ll never watch this show after season 1 I gave up! Grogu was the biggest disappointment of this entire show, HE ADDS NOTHING AND I HATE HIM TBH ONCE LOVED NOW HATED!

Ответить
@androognoix1685
@androognoix1685 - 17.01.2024 06:08

Bro why tf you call out on this season of a show specifically it’s actually better than andor

Ответить
@cr3d294
@cr3d294 - 15.01.2024 03:16

I think there's a lot of set up in this season and not a lot of pay off. But people are treating it like it's the end of the series. You don't open a book, read chapter 20 - 30 and critique it cause it's part of a greater whole. People need to chill. Now we know there's a movie this most likely set up for that.

Ответить
@Jander833
@Jander833 - 07.01.2024 02:10

Can I...get that gif/clip of Daisy Ridley winking anywhere?

Ответить
@PrinceVoid7
@PrinceVoid7 - 02.01.2024 17:57

I'm sorry, I had to remove my like after you said you liked the sequel trilogy.

Ответить
@Jlopezocasio
@Jlopezocasio - 10.12.2023 00:17

Why would there have to be some big goodbye seen at the end? In this story alone they visit everyone several times. The second season ended with Mando thinking he wouldn’t see Grogu again while here he just decides to live in a planet away from the Mandalorians. The only goodbye scene needed was for Paz and his kid. He ignores orders for his kid and that should’ve been the case in the end with him doing it mainly for his kid or asking for them to look after his kid.

Ответить
@RibbitRibbit721
@RibbitRibbit721 - 01.12.2023 02:54

Im sorry, I'm a hardcore star wars fan, but I kinda liked season 3.

Ответить
@larikauranen2159
@larikauranen2159 - 27.11.2023 16:47

Lol. I really forgot everything what happend in the 7th and 8th episode

Ответить
@DoomDuckGod
@DoomDuckGod - 25.11.2023 00:44

Tbh, I would’ve clicked on this video MUCH sooner if it was titled "Why it's fine" instead of "why it sucks." I'm so tired of the negativity overall.

Ответить
@davidgoodwin3408
@davidgoodwin3408 - 24.11.2023 06:26

All this complaining ain’t gonna stop any of you from watching whatever they put out next

Ответить
@stoneyhaze9956
@stoneyhaze9956 - 22.11.2023 10:32

Ok so did you the shirts "THE FORCE IS FEMALE". Men are allowed to have nothing they love anymore. Do you see how pathetic Star Wars is now? Book of Bobba Fett literally destroyed my favourite character. Luke is a pathetic weakling in the newer trilogy movies. Star Wars is dead and the amount of money they are losing is totally deserved. Now obviously I want women/girls to like it but making it all women and shitting on are old favourites is so disgusting. How many shows and movies do women have geared towards them? Your gonna fuck with Comic books and Star Wars. That's how vindictive women are. "Look at those boys and their male patriarchy! Those toxic masculine hero's of theirs". Come on ladies lets fuck that up for them.

Ответить
@BobHenderson-dr2wy
@BobHenderson-dr2wy - 19.11.2023 07:47

Grogu adds the kid element they need to capitalize on the younger audience, and for those moments when you need to throw a character in harms way for the "epic" battle. Sure, they could have made them complete mercenaries but the executives that fund these things like the family connection premise.
Personally I think Star Wars needs to loose all of it's cannon and just use those wonderful set designers and artists and do a story completely not related to cannon at all, how about a whole new galaxy to explore, rather than tediously trying to tie every story together so it all fits.

Ответить
@peter_schomus
@peter_schomus - 10.11.2023 23:28

We want to see a bounty hunter be a bounty hunter.

Ответить
@callahan123
@callahan123 - 07.11.2023 01:39

I agree with you.
I have to add that this season takes more or less everything that worked out and put everything that didn´t worked in this season.

I never watched the animation shows because I´m generally not interested in animated shows as spin offs. Most of the time I don´t like the style of the "drawing", it´s much more made for children and they usually go over the top when it comes to action - in a dumb way.

So to see characters from these shows mean nothing to me. You are right, The Mandalorian shouldn´t have all this ballast from earlier properties. But ok, some characters like Ashoka in the one chapter worked for me.

WHAT they could have done in season three - be brave.
Let Bo Katan be bad, let her be the villian of the third season. Let her take Grogu hostage, by uniting with some angry Mandalorians to fight and trick Luke to get the kid. Ever saw an angry dad?
Maybe that´s against Bo Katans character people know from former shows, I don´t know, but I think there is a good case, watching only the Mandalorian, that some might say, Katan is an egoistic power hungry one dimensional character, who only cares about her own goals and not about others.

I don´t think that the first two seasons were perfect. I don´t like the main villain. I don´t like the concept around the dark saber. I don´t like some characters, because they were played by bad or lame actors. But I still love these seasons. For me, most of the times they are on par with the original trilogy. They have this kind of charme which seems so easy to create while being so rare to achieve.

Ответить
@ApolloXL5
@ApolloXL5 - 06.11.2023 09:31

Season 3 of Mandalorian was terrible and made the Mandos look like complete idiots for living on a planet next to a lake that is inhabited by space alligators and have kids abducted by flying lizard birds on a daily basis.

Also the New Republic is shown to be just as bad as the Empire and Mando is save countless times by Bo Katan.

This season is just another example of how bad Disney is handling Star Wars.

And I doubt that we will ever see the Rey movie, since Disney have announced many projects that then never happened and Rey is by no means a popular character.

And Star Wars isn't dead, huh?

Perhaps you should watch the s**tshow called Ashoka.

I have no faith in Star Wars under Disney, since I got burned a few too many times (with the Sequel trilogy, Boba Fett, Kenobi, Mando season 3 and Ashoka).

Ответить
@KaiserShield
@KaiserShield - 05.11.2023 19:43

Justice league was a garbage movie because of synder. Cut or uncut. I’m so tired of morons defending that hack writer that ruined the DCU.

Ответить
@alexmartin3143
@alexmartin3143 - 05.11.2023 08:34

My biggest gripe is Sabine I guess gave up on Mandalore completely despite her being the last representative of clan Wren. Yeah yeah her character is being pooped on currently but we didn’t know that during Mando S3…

Ответить
@vinylstarboy9547
@vinylstarboy9547 - 05.11.2023 08:26

Am I crazy or is it partial Bo's fault that they lost Mandalore? She destabilised her sister's rule, got her killed and had the planet conquered by Maul. Why would anyone follow her?

Ответить
@khalfrankisatool1162
@khalfrankisatool1162 - 04.11.2023 22:28

I love lore so the season was cool to me, but I understand why others don't like it

Ответить
@AliDixon95
@AliDixon95 - 03.11.2023 19:28

Best scene since 1980? Man stfu 😂

Ответить
@user-kw6rh8xq2f
@user-kw6rh8xq2f - 03.11.2023 15:13

There is nothing good about the sequels

Ответить
@Shawnsrumi
@Shawnsrumi - 02.11.2023 09:24

It was a good seasone… this why everyone hates star war geek dicks… touch grass and stop basing you personalities Star Wars losers

Ответить
@T4RC
@T4RC - 31.10.2023 15:00

„I loved everything about this, but in hindsight, it sucks“ lmao.

Ответить
@Vortex_7114
@Vortex_7114 - 31.10.2023 11:21

idk how any of this works but this shouldn’t happen. like didn’t the episodes get approved by many ppl? how did nobody speak up saying “what’s the theme of this season?” or questions of why

Ответить
@Vortex_7114
@Vortex_7114 - 31.10.2023 11:10

who didn’t watch boba fett?? we all thought it was going to be good.

Ответить
@MrMind5
@MrMind5 - 31.10.2023 09:31

Book of Boba Fett was 100% better than S3 of Mandalorian. Get mad lol.

Ответить
@axelfoley6566
@axelfoley6566 - 31.10.2023 01:18

All of y'all suck season 3 rocks everybody enjoyed watching them retake mandalore everybody enjoyed the two different mandalorian factions coming together y'all need to stop fucking hating

Ответить
@acountryboysopinion6001
@acountryboysopinion6001 - 30.10.2023 20:56

Now they need to show the Bendu creature from Rebels in Live Action.

Ответить
@alexcramer2987
@alexcramer2987 - 30.10.2023 19:27

You don't like fun. LOL, just messing with you. Great analysis!

Ответить
@setlik3gaming80
@setlik3gaming80 - 30.10.2023 17:51

Dismal Disney FLOPS again and again and again and again and again and again and again and again and again and again and again and again and again and again...

Ответить
@setlik3gaming80
@setlik3gaming80 - 30.10.2023 17:47

You MUST love Disney Star Wars you Bigot.

Ответить
@setlik3gaming80
@setlik3gaming80 - 30.10.2023 17:41

Fun!... Fun? The Woke never have fun. They are an absolutely miserable group of unclean dregs upon society. When the woke says fun they mean misery. Be Woke Be Miserable.

Ответить
@setlik3gaming80
@setlik3gaming80 - 30.10.2023 17:37

Disney Star Wars shills are having a good time as long as those Disney checks keep coming. When the money is gone, these shills will dry up like water on a desert planet, ignore them

Ответить
@setlik3gaming80
@setlik3gaming80 - 30.10.2023 17:34

You have got good taste.
Disney Star Wars shills are slobbering lap dogs of disdain

Ответить
@setlik3gaming80
@setlik3gaming80 - 30.10.2023 17:31

Disney Star Wars is only FILLER

Ответить
@TheAcesRedd
@TheAcesRedd - 30.10.2023 17:27

All respect lost for this opinion when it claimed dc butchering the dog shit Snyder movie is what screwed up the DC stuff. Hiring hack Snyder in the first place is what fucked them.

Ответить
@setlik3gaming80
@setlik3gaming80 - 30.10.2023 17:26

Womandalorian jumped the shark in Season 3.

Ответить
@setlik3gaming80
@setlik3gaming80 - 30.10.2023 17:23

Baby Yoda is a ridiculous character.
Get rid of it.

Ответить
@newthejsterjacob408
@newthejsterjacob408 - 30.10.2023 02:31

Something that seemed so obvious which is crazy they didn’t do is Moff Gideon being defeated by the mythosaur symbolically being rejected and defeated by the mandalorian culture

Ответить
@newthejsterjacob408
@newthejsterjacob408 - 30.10.2023 00:26

It’s so weird how they handled the children of the watch it seemed pretty obvious to me that they were criticizing this stance and that mando is a better person without those practices. But then they go back on that? It’s good that mando is back in the fold of the people who held back his emotional development and it’s aspirational to have that sort of belief

Ответить
@jarrodedson5441
@jarrodedson5441 - 28.10.2023 04:39

This season is so bad it makes me never want to watch any future mando seasons

Ответить
@SirPanikalot778
@SirPanikalot778 - 25.10.2023 23:06

By FAR my biggest problem with this season was that I did not like Boka Tan. She's stubborn, egotistical and annoying when she's on screen. And the worst part? She never had character growth. Instead of finally accepting that the darksaber doesn't belong to her or something along those lines, perhaps a character arc or something, she just gets her ego fulfilled and is just as boring as she was prior.

I would have rather seen the darksaber lost, broken, stolen, or destroyed prior to her finally obtaining it. It would bring more clarity and relatability to her character, rather than the "oh she beat the thing that jumped me while I was off-guard".
Just imagine her chasing the darksaber after it had fallen off a cliff, or desperately scrambling to repair it - some kind of struggle would have been far more compelling and entertaining.

Ответить
@2ChainZsensai
@2ChainZsensai - 25.10.2023 14:39

They literally done like World War Z Muslim dumb fuck job on the script.
Guard(=John Pav): Yous should not change in disney way. It will make Chaos.
Girl(K.K): Its okey

Fuck You KK

Ответить
@swingmattuk
@swingmattuk - 24.10.2023 23:49

One point on the darksaber, we have Ezra returning to the galaxy now and the possibility of Huyang’s return, who likely witnessed and guided the creation of the darksaber, there’s the potential for its repair - perhaps if Huyang and Sabine return, the mandalorian Jedi with an ancestral claim on the blade as a member of house visla (clan wren), as she hasn’t made a lightsaber herself, perhaps they’re hiring at the reclaiming of the darksaber from Bo

Ответить
@TheLed2012
@TheLed2012 - 24.10.2023 11:21

I'm just gonna say as cool as the darksaber is I much prefer the helm of mandalore being a symbol of leadership rather than a jedi weapon. Yes it was made by a mandalorian jedi, but it just feels wrong. It isn't a weapon based in their culture. Yeah, a lightsaber is cooler than a helmet, but what that helmet means is so cool especially if you have played kotor 2 or read kotor themed comics. It has more cultural significance especially when you consider how the mandalorians in this show put so much emphasis on keeping their helmets on. Idk the darksaber just feels like fan service, and as signature weapon for Djinn I much preferred the beskar spear or his rifle. We don't get to see someone fight with a spear that often, especially in star wars, so having that just made him feel unique, but this is star wars and every main protagonist has to have a lightsaber(yeah i know there shows/movies that dont do this, but it is definitely not the majority).

Ответить