Hogwarts Legacy All Bad or "Evil" Choices

Can you please play resident evil 2 and 3 remakes with naughty mods?

I am curious, how did you find this game? Did you like it? 😊

I'm kinda dissatisfied most of the evil choices are at best morally grey or in some position that they were done with good intentions

I sorta wish you gained something in the end if you choose to use the power instead of contain it

It’s like they were scared to go evil

I wish they added different story ending for Sebastian's questline like a good and bad ending where he ends up not going to the dark magic route and saves his sister or something like he doesnt do dark magic but his sister dies or you do dark magic and she lives but you get this ending something like that.

*Uses Crucio
Onai: Why would you use that spell?
*Never brings it up later

Very unsatisfied with the endings and “bad” or good choices. Outside of come conversation you essentially get the same thing. Outside of the main storyline and what you do with the ancient magic. The side missions have a better storyline than the actual main one. The game is incredible but a very lackluster choice system and endings. I thought learning/using the unforgivable curses gave you a specific ending but none of that matters. There’s 4 questions that “change” the ending

The only definitively evil but was burning the painting.
If you want evil, you’ve got to do it yourself. Avada Kadabra the Cats.

Only real critique is how it seems the game is Afraid of you having that dog in you or something lol

Game of the year!!!!!🤩😍🤩😍🤩😍🤩😍🤩😍🤩.

literslly the same ending no matter if you're good or evil lol. not pleased with this games story.

Wish this game had something like the honor system in RDR2

Obi-Wan vibes in Fig... but sad you cant realy become the dark Lord

I am disappointed that you can't use the power if you choose to absorb it, it is just a choice, it doesn't make a difference other than changing the ending a bit, it is underwhelming imo

Missed the part where you need to find goblin stones for a girl and you can decide to keep them lol

Can we kill npcs like we did in Darksouls?

I wish they had a morality system in this game. There's a lot of good opportunities for good/evil choices in Hogwarts Legacy, but none of the "evil" decisions don't have any consequences.

I just put the painting guy in the hogs head because he was so annoying, and it affected black too

When the evil choices are so plain you can’t tell they are evil then they aren’t that bad

Death eater levels of evil: accepted the magic
Voldemort levels of evil: uses crucio instead of avada kedavra and turns Sebastian in after learning all the unforgivables from him (and choosing the use unforgivable on X option every time)
Umbridge levels of evil:
All of the above and downloading a mod that allows you to use avada kedavra on anyone

i choose “i want the power for myself” and got that evil ending. 5 minutes later : nothing happen, no upgrades,no power buff

damn, your character is even dressed like a villain, makes these cutscenes look even more epic, like we're about to fight this final boss who just got a hold of the forbidden magic the heroes have been trying to keep from him

The game was great and the main story was like standard good up until the end.... I get wanting an epic battle against an evil dragon but would've been better if the fight continued after to fight Ranrok himself as a dark wizard like Rookwood. That was a great fight. Also if you go evil you're found guilty of forbidden curses or something and thrown in Azkaban. Would make sense canonically kinda. I also thought headmaster black would've become more serious and mournful about Fig in his speech but no they kept him goofy...

shame they went with the game of thrones ending lol

EHEHEHE

no bc why did we politely learn unforgivable curses 💀

Nah im tryna watch the world burn

Spoiler. I chose the good path and didn't keep the power for myself. Then professor fig died and hogwarts had a funeral for him. Is choosing the good path the only way for this to happen or does it also happen when you choose to keep the power.

I haven't burned up the painting (yet), but I did put Ferdinand Octavius Pratt in the Hog’s Head Inn. If you go into the library after doing that, Pratt is complaining about where you put his frame. Rather funny.

Other bad choices could be eg: not giving Zenobia her gobstones or not giving people their family heirloom or an outfit/gift a student wants back but instead u keep it for ya self

The relationship with Sebastian had the best vibe

The devs should’ve taken more time with the game and actually make your choices in the game have consequences or make your story different from each choice you make. Really ruined the game for me when I realized no matter how many bad things I did…you got the same ending as everyone else

You shouldn't be giving Ominus the choice to agree to Imperio. The whole point is that it's done whether the victim likes it or not. That's why it's mind control. Having him agree is just pointless and gives an out for the player.