9 Reasons Red Dead Redemption 2 Is Better Than GTA 5

Simple - you don't care about your motorbike, but you come to realise deep down you're a horse connoisseur.

I like gta better

100 reasons why red dead 3 will be better than gta 6 which we been waiting over 10 years for lol gta 6 needs to have a survival aspect to it its why red dead 2 and even the first game had was just purely a better experience

Rdr2 actually makes me feel like I’m in the game exploring alongside Mr.Morgan 🔥. Every detail and comments and every little thing the NPCs do are out of this world and makes the world way alive.

The way you take care of the horse and how your hair, beard gross with time and how you’re able to style it or trim it.

I mean everything with this game was so amazing !!!!!!!!! Has so much to do and so much to explore with side quest and scary swamps wit those creepy ass night folks coming at you.


The animals are super cool up to freaking snakes 🙏🙏.

READ DEAD REDEMPTION IS AND WAS BETTER THAN ANY GTA GAME EVER MADE.

GTA 6 BETTER BE LOLE RDR2 or even better 🤦‍♂️🤦‍♂️

Lets put it like this... Most shooter games I play typically revolve around WWII-Modern

I never thought I would have fun with a "Spaghetti Western" genre game UNTIL the Red Dead Redemption series. Nothing more needs to be said

Rd2 feels like you’re actually living in a world and GTA feels like a mid simulation. (GTA was still a great story mode tho).

GTA V Is Way More Funnier Than RDR2 RDR2 Fells A Horse Simulator All You Do Is Riding A Horse

Still I Think GTA Is Way More Better Than The Whole RDR2 Franchise

A lot more then 9

Cheesus my guy. Breathe once in a while... You're narrating so goddamn fast I can't even comprehend what you're saying...

They should make a new the warriors game

Rdr from the first one with John and rdr2 both makes you feel real emotion. It makes you sad. Depressed. Cry because they showed reality not like gta where yes there's some reality though mostly fantasy because it gives young kids fantasies of how you " should be " which nobody should be going out like wannabee thugs killing and shooting for no reason while in gta fantasy land anyone can get rich. Rdr makes you work to survive and get that money ( that's reality ).... If notice to the difference of people in gta v online and rdr2 online. The rdr community is much more respectful. Yes there's still good ol trolls in rdr 2 online though not like gta online where 90 percent there think their thugs or their 10 year old kids with ignorant parents letting their children cuss at adults online while playing a game not meant at all for kids..... And in reality rockstar pushed pushed pushed by millions of your dollars to advertise gta v that's the ONLY reason it was so big in sales though I don't believe rockstar did the real sales count. They only showed gta sales mostly for America and South America and Europe. Rdr2 online was and is played GLOBALLY telling you rdr as a whole is way more well known and played way more on a global scale. Though most here don't know that. Yes I love playing gta though to know the reality of things so gotta speak it..... And for someone who's done prison time in the past for past drug use and trafficking it's sad seeing people act so disgusting and rude acting like wannabee gang bangers in gta online. Most never lived that life though Rock star pushes it like it's cool than slaps a thing on the front of games before the game starts saying don't try this at home kids lol. They know what their doing because their elite owners have agendas and show you right in the game what their agenda is that they push on kids even on adults. It's sick though it's on almost all mainatream industry's while we got a world now everyone thinks their thugs while never have been in a prison cell once in their life. The life isn't glamorous.... Note to young kids. Love forgive and respect others. Stop trying to be something Rock star games pushes you to be. Facts spoken......

RDR2 story gets better with every play thru there is soo much.

only gta5 fanboys still think it's better thank RDR2. Everyone else knows RDR2 is better

Read dead in my official opinion… it’s story is way better as well I also just finished walking around the whole map

GTA would be more exciting if you can buy things with real $$ but people can steal it. Make the game about real theft. Or if no money then you can earn things through play that can be stolen.

RED DEAD ONLINE IS ASSS GTAO IS BETTER

GTA
“I have a family please don’t kill me”
“I didn’t ask” *Shoots face and continues to shoot body*

RDR
“Please spare me I have a son to come home to”
“Whatever you say” *Walks off*

YEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEES

It’s a HUGE upgrade frm a HUGE game

RDR2 is better than all GTA games. yes, even GTA IV

Way better than gta tbh

Aimagine red fed in vr

Ngl bro GTA 5>>>RDR2

When I played red dead 2 and finished I gone back to play gta v and it doesn’t feel the same well of course but you know what I mean

I liked gta 5 but it couldn’t compare to gta iv

They didn’t kill of Johnny

Excellent list; one point you made really stuck with me, and that was the point about the Wanted system in each game. In GTA V you can walk right down the street with a minigun and wipe out every single living thing in a 2 mile radius but after you die/get arrested npcs, whether they are cops or regular civilians going about their day have completely forgotten about your murderous rampage. The media outlets don’t mention it at all unless it’s strictly an event in the main story. However the people of Red Dead Redemption 2 on the other hand remember everything; it’s possible you took the life of their loved one and they will make sure you don’t forget that anytime soon. I’ve had multiple npcs walk up to me and scream and curse me for slaughtering their husbands and sons, and I can’t even lie and say I didn’t feel at least a twinge of guilt. Red Dead Redemption 2 at least made you feel like you were having major impacts on the world around you due to your actions, and people would act accordingly, whether your actions were good or bad. That mechanic wasn’t just a feature of the main story but also present in the actual free roam game.

Red Dead Redemption II went in GTA IV’s direction by keeping it grounded in reality and keeping it more realistic. Whereas GTA V went into the direction of Saints Row by making it more silly and ridiculous to the point where I was saying, “what the f**k is this?”

Yes RDR is better

i really love your video and I would say gta v is for players who love to joke around and just have fun while red dead redemption 2 is for more story based and serious players

Men play Red Dead, boys play GTA.

Rdr2 is not better than Rdr1
So it can't be better than gta 5
When it didn't even beat its previous game..

The fact we can't buy property and houses in singleplayer is disgusting especially since they advertised it in the gameplay trailer

Red dead redemption 2 has the greatest single player campaign in the history of gaming, there's no shame in saying that.

Shooting someone in GTA V felt like shooting a plastic balloon that refused to pop. Shooting someone in RDR2 felt like your bullets actually carried weight and teared through your target.

Thank you for explaining why this game is amazing without spoiling the story.

Rdr2 and GTA are by far the best games that rockstar has made.
But in my Opinion Rdr2 was just given so much love and compassion in development.
Beautiful Landscape and amazing characters and I feel so attached to every character in the game. (Spoilers)
After some of the characters in gang died it felt so heart breaking but yet so bitter sweet..
Read Dead will always have a special place in my heart and I wanna thank Rockstar for such a great experience.. 😢

Me, toward NPCs

Arthur: Hello, mister!

Franklin/Trevor/Mochael: SAY HELLO TO MY LITTLE FRIEND!

Rdr2 is way better but gta 5 story is very underrated and actually very good just people don’t appreciate it

In gta 5 I only related to Franklin but today I went upstairs and saw Jimmy and Tracy fighting and slamming there doors shut afterwards and it just made me think about my little girl and now I have a new fondness for micheal and enjoy playing him as much as I do Franklin but Trevor just seemed like a super weird character I hate Trevor. I’m excited to try rdr2 along side my first pc gta play through.

The reason why I play GTA 5 is to just cruise around the map with different vehicles , that is impossible in RDR2 so from my perspective GTA is the better game , I don't care about the stories so it really depends on what you are looking for

Apples and oranges and different strokes for different folks.

No need for reasons, As soon as that load screen is gone u will see proof and feel proof

look at them now…

Why i like rdr more than gta games:
1: In rdr u can save people from serial killers, criminals and u earn loyalty and honour, deaths are sad and broke u emotionally while in gta 5 u just rob banks, kill whoever u like and it doesn't really matter for a gta character to die u just stand like there and im like oke while rdr deaths are sad, rdr is more realistic and brings u back into the old days, old pistols, old guns, better graphics and characters, these are just of the few reasons why rdr franchise is better

The story and single player as a whole is much better than GTA. Online is.... Well.... I think everyone knows about red dead online Vs GTA online

Just think of it like this: Rdr2 is the better version of gta5

Only reason: RDR2 was next gen(2018)and gtav was old gen(2013)

I've been playing gta online now for years I own nearly everything my rank is 659 lol my life right... yh ik but looking at this red dead online I am very impressed 👌 I am 100% gonna buy this and start playing rdr online 😆😆
Goodbye gtav online 😢 💔 u will be missed
RIP.